The paradox of the simultaneous collapse of the Left while it has also become the quasi state religion of the West lies in the nature of it's shifting demographic base. A century ago, Leftist parties represented the urban proletariat. People a single generation removed from the
farm who could be organized into militancy quite readily. It was this militant impulse, give me my demands or I wreck your shit, that frightened establishment authorities and could generate revolutionary potential. The modern Western Left Party draw's it's base from the upper
middle class. This, even more than even aristocracy, is the most reactionary element in a society and the one's least likely to rock the boat less they face the dread specter of downward social mobility and be cast back into the petit bourgeois or horror of horrors, the actual
working class. How do you go about resolving this contradiction? First you abandon any thoughts of militancy and second you start larping as the operetta revolutionary. This is your average Dem-Soc party member best exemplified by your AOC types. The demands are plentiful, the
threats to back them up are gone, and when push comes to shove you vote present and cry. How did a revolutionary Party become a skinsuit for reaction? Why did the Western Left abandon the working class? The reasons are primarily two-fold. The first is the deliberate playing both
sides game of Western intelligence agencies. The ultimate aim of the US during the Cold War was the creation of a docile anti-Soviet left. If the Soviet Union was the eidolon of the Worker's, then Western Leftism must not be about the workers at all. The bourgeoisie must become
the embodiment of Leftist values, which to say the Left must become counter-revolutionary in all the areas that matter to Capital but are free to go wild on any number of social directions that don't touch money. All of the Culture Warriors that CIA money paid for ultimately went
in this direction to create ersatz social revolutions in lieu of economic ones. The second element of why the Left abandoned the workers is the gradual change in racial composition of the working class in the West. Bluntly speaking, Western capitalists are using racial aliens to
schism elite/proletariat networks that drove the revolutionary potential during the early 20th century. By having a ethnically distinct underclass, it undermines inter-class solidarity and has the secondary benefit of impoverishing the native working class and further cleaving
them from elites who could otherwise harness them for revolutionary purposes. Most Western bourgeois Leftists have contempt for their own working class members and are merely patronizing of ethnically different ones.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Duke of Qin

Duke of Qin Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @qin_duke

4 Oct
Taiwan is Chinese clay by right of history, right of blood, and most important of all, right of force. Power is the ultimate arbiter of territorial disputes, not popular will. If the opinions of powerless people mattered, the US military wouldn't be occupying Iraq, Libya, Syria.
It wouldn't be occupying Diego Garcia or Guantanamo Bay. It would recognize Russian sovereignty of Crimea and the Donbass. Obviously none of those things are going to change, so hearing how Taiwan deserves blah blah blah because of Democratic Magic or Popular Sovereignty and how
it is the responsibility of the US and all Free and blah blah blah nations to recognize Taiwan and defend against Chinese "aggression" is all a bunch of blatantly transparent bullshit that only children and well paid nitwits would take seriously. If you aren't willing to fight
Read 4 tweets
26 Sep
All the blue check China Watchers raging about how the Michaels were actually hostages and how their release proves China was lying about their arrests have absolutely nothing to say about the US dropping the extradition case against Meng proves their so called Rule of Law is a
a complete farce. Her arrest was ordered on political grounds for political purposes which a fucking five your old could see but apparently living in DC made this difficult to conceptualize yet even as the case against her unraveled because of political issues they can't
realize that their oh so smart "Lawfare" campaign of combining selective legal persecution and political warfare doesn't get you the law but actually the same as combining anything with politics, which is simply more politics. These arrogant smarmy dumbfucks don't realize that
Read 5 tweets
18 Sep
A lot of people mistake the CIA as Rightists, when in reality they and all of America's sundry alphabet agencies not populated by outright mouth breathing dimwits are actually creatures of the "Left". The socio-economic backgrounds, the education credentials, the personalities
that are deliberately cultivated all select against actual natural conservatism but select for bourgeois Liberalism. The CIA, is in essence the heart of Western Social Imperialism. It's mission, to prevent Communist Revolution via Democratic Socialism. Advance the American Empire
via making everyone fly the Rainbow flag. It's alliances with rightist forces are alliances of convenience against the geopolitical interests of the American regime, but that only lasts only for as long as they are useful and necessary. Once a sufficiently ideologically aligned
Read 6 tweets
17 Sep
Tearing down old symbols must always serve as the prelude to the erection of new ones. Just as Christianity and Islam demolished the idols and temples of pagans they vanquished and replaced them with their churches and mosques, faith no matter the creed must be sustained. Even
revolutionary Communism intent on destroying the old social order put in it's place a pantheon of revolutionary heroes and icons and a shining vision of the future new order. American liberalism assaults the old beliefs, but offers nothing in return. At least nothing worthwhile.
Everything is PR artifice. Your old idols are torn down for the Rainbow Big Mac. Your bonds of community must be dissolved and in return you have reddit and discord channels. Sanctity is replaced by the "Well Akshually" snarkiness of the petite bourgeois intellectual. There is no
Read 4 tweets
17 Sep
The phenomenon Karlin is noticing is actually quite interesting. What has changed is not an increase in Chinese nationalism but a demographic shift of it's constituency. 30 years ago, the Nationalists were basically Sovoks, while the elites were barely restrained Zradists.
The biggest pro-American liberals in China were those born in the 60's and 70's who are today in their 50's. What has happened is that those born in the 80's and 90's and 2000's are less instinctively awestruck than before even as they are less reflexively hostile than those who
came of age during the age of Mao. Each succeeding decade sees this trend accelerate. Less uncritically accepting of what the West has to say about itself or China, wariness about it's intentions, and now even a rising feeling of contempt and hostility for Western society, seeing
Read 5 tweets
6 Sep
Clip of a starlet on a Chinese dance competition show. Beautiful girl but mediocre dancer. There is an interesting lesson that despite modernist appearances, there is a huge prudish streak in Chinese society that many people don't realize. The most popular comments were actually
criticisms of her dress as being too revealing and vulgar, something you really wouldn't expect from the primarily female audiences of a reality tv dance show. This reminds me of an earlier incident when a principal dancer of the Shanghai song & dance company launched a digital
Jihad against a photographer and a number of dance students for taking what were by Western standards milquetoast photos she judged to be risque. The thing was, the overwhelming majority agreed with her. This would practically be unheard of anywhere else that wasn't predominantly
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(