This is what happens in 3 years of meeting IOC policy for a trans woman athlete looks like in real life & not what it looks like in flawed studies of non-athletes like Wiik et al @RogerPielkeJr
HYPOGONADISM & THE BIOLOGICAL HEALTH IMPACTS XY TRANSGENDER FEMALE (NON-SURGICAL)
Hypogonadism another term for abnormally low testosterone production in the gonads (T<10nmol) and concomitant symptoms suggesting androgen deficiency.
Transgender women retain their gonads and endocrine system undisrupted
while utilizing androgen blockers to reduce testicle production of testosterone. ecreases in patient quality of life long-term.
Common physiologial contraindications: sexual and mental health, muscle atrophy, decrease overall physical strength, increase in subcutaneous fat levels, acclerated bone loss and premature abnormal aging,
large drop in hematocrite levels, cardio vascular health, decreasing primary endocrine function, permanent androgen receptor atrophy, increased vulnerability to coronary heart disease, prone to joint health and injuries,
elevated insulin levels and insulin resistence, elevated core body temperature during exercise, reduced stamina, fatigue, delayed recovery, lethargy and diabetes.
Assessing any group of athletes as a monolithic group especially amongst trans athletes is flawed. Trans is an umbrella term many different body types & stages of transition. Blanket inclusion or exclusion does not work.
ANDROGEN DEPRIVATION BIOLOGICAL HEALTH IMPACTS XY TRANS FEMALE (POST OPERATIVE)”
Complete androgen deprivation is another term for non-existent production of the sole primary hormone required testosterone, due to a bilateral orchiectomy (removal of the gonads) to create the vulva
Though XY chromosomes, requires testosterone levels to be (T>14nmol or higher) to be healthy and relieved of symptoms of complete androgen deficiency.
Transitioned women, do not retain gonads responsible for hormone production, the circulation and communications loop of the endocrine system is disrupted, organs, glands are no longer linked and are acting independently on their own.
The symptoms of CAD result in decreases in patient quality of life long-term. Common physiologial contraindications: loss of sexual and mental health, complete muscle atrophy, increase in subcutaneous fat levels, acclerated bone loss,
premature abnormal aging, large drop in hematocrite levels, cardio vascular health, ceasing of primary endocrine function and protein|androgen synthesis, permanent androgen receptor atrophy,
increased vulnerability to coronary heart disease, prone to joint health and injuries, elevated insulin levels and insulin resistence, elevated core body temperature during exercise, reduced stamina, delayed recovery, lethargy & diabetes.
I talk to @JMcKMelbourne about my work with @Hogshead3Au & Martina Navratilova's policy working group, my journey with testosterone we also talk she about Caster Semenya in Athletics and World Rugby's trans women ban. 3cr.org.au/inyaface/episo…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Chemical castration is the use of drugs to lower the production of hormones in your testicles.
Doctors use this method to treat hormone-related cancers, such as prostate cancer or for XY pre operative transgender women. Other names for chemical castration are:
hormone therapy,
androgen suppression therapy,
androgen depressive therapy.
Let’s take a closer look at how chemical castration works, what the long-term risks are, and if it can be reversed.
Caroline Layt
Caroline’s a Trans Woman who advocates for Transgender people in sports and wider society, as she was bullied and had her own rights questioned when she played women’s [club and representative] rugby union and rugby league in the early 2000s.
Despite prejudices she experienced when she was outed in 2005, she had positive people support her and she still managed to eke out a good career and
The disgusting transphobic discourse in some mainstream media publications, and the apparent dismissal of transgender people by our prime minister @ScottMorrisonMP , is extremely damaging to trans and gender-questioning children.
The use of emotive phrases such as ‘castrating children’ is likely to create unwarranted concern and fear amongst the general public who have no personal experience of trans people and will influence their attitudes and perception of trans issues in a very negative way.
@ScottMorrisonMP , #Trump & many other far right conservative politicians & political parties using transgender children as a conservative rallying call to arms against progressive changes in society has lead to an increase in stigma, discrimination, social exclusion,
“The term ‘rapid onset gender dysphoria (ROGD)’ is not a diagnosis or health condition recognised by any major professional association, nor is it listed as a subtype or classification in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) or
International Classification of Diseases (ICD). Therefore, ‘ROGD’ is an acronym describing a proposed phenomenon, with insufficient peer-reviewed scientific evidence to support its implementation and/or use within clinical, community, social and legal settings.
Lisa Littman of Brown University authored the study that first reported ROGD, which was published in the journal PLOS One in August 2018. Within a week, following criticism of the study, the journal announced it would conduct a post-publication reassessment of the article.
We only have to look at our personal experience of the people around us to realise that the generalisations used in arguments against trans women & girl athletes are completely unfounded.
Arguments calling for the blanket@exclusion of trans* or intersex people on the grounds of fair competition are based upon the following factors;
1-all those assigned as male are better than all those assigned as female at birth
2-medical transition does not affect sporting ability
3-Some may attempt to cheat if the system is changed.
Under the current system in 🇦🇺, social costs such as the health individuals, homelessness, the mental health crisis, housing inflation, & ecological costs such as emissions, pollution, habitat loss, over-extraction of water, & soil degradation are all too easily ignored or worse,