The term "#solutionism" gets thrown around a lot. Any time an attempt to address a problem fails, it's easy to point at the technological elements of the failure and deride the whole enterprise as a solutionist muddle.

1/ An old Apple 'There's an app for that' ad; the screen of the
If you'd like an unrolled version of this thread to read or share, here's a link to it on pluralistic.net, my surveillance-free, ad-free, tracker-free blog:

pluralistic.net/2021/10/13/the…

2/
Which is a pity, because solutionism is real, and it's a scourge. I mean, it can literally kill.

Take Poshan Abhiyaan, a Modi/World Bank joint project to address malnutrition-based "stunting" in children under six, something 38% of Indian children suffered in 2016.

3/
As @AarefaJohari describes in a long investigation for @scroll_in, the absolute failure of Poshan Abhiyaan is pure solutionism: the program spent money on an app to track which kids were malnourished, but it didn't offer sufficient funds to feed them.

scroll.in/article/100752…

4/
There are a lot of details, but that's it in a nutshell. The program's funders - including the Gates Foundation - spent lavishly on an app to keep records of child hunger, and didn't care or didn't know that there wasn't adequate funding for food for the kids they tracked.

5/
The closer you look at the scheme, the worse it gets, and Johari's reporting is a case-study in solutionism at its worst.

The front-line workers in India's anti-child-hunger campaign are the women who work at anganwadis - who meet with parents and kids and give them food.

6/
The anganwadi system is a disaster. The centers themselves are grossly underfunded. 40% of them don't have running water. Many have toilets, but often they are purely ornamental, not connected to water or sewers.

7/
One anganwadi, in Shivni, Barwani, had been shuttered for ten years awaiting roof repairs, while Mehmooda, the woman who staffed it, had spent a decade in a "temporary" center in a classroom.

8/
The anganwadis are understaffed. Th full staff complement is just two workers, but many only have a single worker. They are grossly underpaid - though they work for the government, they are classed as "honorary" workers, earning "honoraria" and not entitled to benefits.

9/
It's not uncommon for anganwadi workers to retire into dire poverty, with no pension or savings to support them.

These underpaid workers have inadequate tools: they lack soap, and the scales and height measurement tools used to evaluate malnutrition are often nonfunctional.

10/
The anganwadi workers treat malnutrition the obvious way: by providing food. But they don't get enough food to help the families whose kids are starving - the rations are so thin that a month's food is gone in a week.

11/
If you wanted to improve the anganwadi system, there are some obvious places to start: equip it with good buildings staffed by adequately compensated workers with functional equipment, and then give them enough food to address the hunger they find.

12/
Instead, they got an app.

Really, you couldn't ask for a better example of solutionism, but it gets worse. The app's interface was in English, a language large numbers of anganwadi workers can't read or speak.

13/
The phones the workers were given to run the app were old, underpowered 2G phones that hung and crashed repeatedly. Workers - themselves at the edge of poverty - were pressured to buy better phones to run the app. Many went into debt to do so, fearing for their jobs.

14/
When better phones were eventually distributed, they were locked down so workers couldn't install the messaging tools they used to talk to each other and the families they served.

15/
Even when run on adequate hardware by someone who was familiar with technology and could read English, the app was still terrible. It lacked basic functions, like moving a kid who aged out of the under-four category into the over-four category.

16/
So kids got double-counted, distorting statistics. The statistics, by the way, were available to anyone nationwide through a "realtime dashboard" that omitted vital data that the workers had collected, like height and weight (these being the key to evaluating malnutrition).

17/
To top it all off, the app didn't let workers revise the data they entered if they found an error.

The funding breakdown for the Poshan Abhiyaan program is solutionism in budgetary form: 36% for phones, 36% for "behavior-change campaigns," 8% for scales and height charts.

18/
The discretionary budget for the women who staffed the anganwadis? Just 2% of the total.

None of this is to say that a program aimed at helping starving children shouldn't have good record-keeping.

19/
The paper system that the anganwadis used may have been accurate, but scattered paper records are hard to collate and learn from - for example, to identify places where more funding is needed.

20/
The thing that makes this solutionism isn't that it used digital technology - it's that it ignored all the parts of the problem not related to digital technology, sidelined the workers who understood the problem and treated them and the families they served with contempt.

21/
Child hunger isn't the result of behavioral problems or poor record-keeping. It's the result of not enough food. Job one: make sure that the workers on the frontline have the food they say they need for the families they serve.

22/
Job two: pay the workers a living wage. Repair the buildings they work out of. Staff those centers adequately. Make sure their toilets and scales and height-measurement tools work.

23/
Then, if you must, add some digital technology - by incorporating the workers themselves - let them design and test the apps, evaluate the hardware, and field trial them. They are the experts and should drive the process.

24/
The problem with solutionism isn't that technology is irrelevant to problem solving - it's that technology developed in a vacuum by people who will never have to use it will only ever make problems worse.

eof/

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Cory Doctorow

Cory Doctorow Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @doctorow

13 Oct
Today's Twitter threads (a Twitter thread).

Inside: Charter uses bad credit threats to corral ex-subscribers; Adobe uses copyfraud to preserve spyware; India funded a starving kids' app, but not food; and more!

Archived at: pluralistic.net/2021/10/13/the…

#Pluralistic

1/
The paperback for Attack Surface - a standalone Little Brother book for adults - is out!

us.macmillan.com/books/97812507…

Signed copies:

darkdel.com/store/p1840/Co…

One-month only audiobook sale with Little Brother and Homeland:

sowl.co/uqT2G

2/
Charter uses bad credit threats to corral ex-subscribers: "Resubscribe or we'll keep trashing your credit report."



3/
Read 22 tweets
13 Oct
The death of Adobe Flash in January 2021 was long overdue; Adobe's hyper-proprietary interactive runtime was a source of persistent, terrifying security vulnerabilities that had harmed web users for decades.

1/ A spooky graveyard; in the foreground, a tombstone bearing t
But the demise of Flash also meant that all the Flash-based media that had been created since its debut (as 1995's "Futuresplash") was snuffed out, orphaned, unplayable and lost to history.

2/
Adobe may have skimped on security, but it spent lavishly on sales and marketing, so major media and public organizations locked up years and years of media and interactives in the Flash abandonware format.

3/
Read 16 tweets
13 Oct
Las Luchadoras Contra La Momia (1964) gameraboy2.tumblr.com/post/664896156…
Las Luchadoras Contra La Momia (1964) gameraboy2.tumblr.com/post/664896156…
Las Luchadoras Contra La Momia (1964) gameraboy2.tumblr.com/post/664896156…
Read 5 tweets
13 Oct
I'm more of a Charter-@GetSpectrum hostage than a customer: I need the internet to earn my living, and my town (#Burbank) has signed an exclusive deal with Charter, so I send them $134.99/mo for some of the worst internet in California.

1/ A ped-style glyph of an armed robber sticking up a victim wi
It turns out that Charter doesn't stop abusing you when you stop being a customer: the company is now sending threatening letters ("offers") to ex-customers demanding that they sign up again on pain of a bad credit report.

2/
That's not how Charter puts it, of course. They say they're extending a lifeline to ex-customers whose years-unpaid bills are in collection, trashing their credit.

theverge.com/2021/10/12/227…

3/
Read 11 tweets
12 Oct
Halloween (1978) dir. John Carpenter wilwheaton.tumblr.com/post/664877829…
Halloween (1978) dir. John Carpenter wilwheaton.tumblr.com/post/664877829…
Halloween (1978) dir. John Carpenter wilwheaton.tumblr.com/post/664877829…
Read 4 tweets
12 Oct
Battlestar Galactica (1980), “Galactica Discovers Earth: Part 1” gameraboy2.tumblr.com/post/664875763…
Battlestar Galactica (1980), “Galactica Discovers Earth: Part 1” gameraboy2.tumblr.com/post/664875763…
Battlestar Galactica (1980), “Galactica Discovers Earth: Part 1” gameraboy2.tumblr.com/post/664875763…
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(