It's frustrating, that so much analysis flying around of Commission proposals on NI Protocol is dented by selective memory and / or damaging pretence of false balance (for fear of usual Brexitist attacks on "biased experts"). I suffer from neither. So let's be crystal clear:
Start from the premiss that there is no backstory here, that all claims are equal and everything is possible: yeah, maybe the Commission offer doesn't sound so generous. Why didn't they offer all this years ago? Why don't they go a bit further to meet UK demands?
But since entire mess was caused by HMG's Hard Brexit + callous disregard for NI's wellbeing, that EU & UK already reached agreement, in which EU made major concessions compared to normal system for 3rd countries, while UK has consistently breached own duties = different picture.
Commission proposals reflect what EU often does so well: find dispassionate solutions to actual problems; here, giving real priority to NI's wellbeing. Whereas HMG continues to whip up hysteria over manufactured grievances; using NI as pawn in ulterior populist, rightist agenda.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Michael Dougan

Michael Dougan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @mdouganlpool

13 Oct
While we wait to see the EU's proposals for reforming the detailed operation of the Protocol on Ireland / Northern Ireland (then find out the reaction of the Johnson Regime), here is a quick reminder of what the basic position of each party currently is:
1) EU says: we spent years hammering out a workable framework to the terrible mess your Brexit created for IRL and NI. No-one claims it is perfect; it is built on compromises by all sides. Now - let's find workable solutions to real life problems having an adverse impact on NI.
2) UK says: we want our Hard Brexit with only a distant relationship to EU, and while we don't want a border across the island of Ireland, nor will we accept checks across the Irish Sea - but we don't have any credible plan to deliver all 3 of those mutually incompatible goals.
Read 5 tweets
5 Oct
Wondering why Johnson Regime is so determined to insult & antagonise EU, disrupt UK relations with Member States? Swopping partnership & cooperation of EU membership for other extreme, of petty belligerence, wasn't inherent in UK withdrawal. It's a deliberate policy choice. Why?
Now clear to all, save the most swivel-eyed Leave fanatics, that Brexit - particularly in the extreme incarnation pushed by Johnson & Co - has no particular upsides and a great many very considerable downsides. So if Brexit is to be fabricated into a "success", it can only be...
... by doing everything in Tories' power to drive deepest possible wedge between "us" & "them": whipping up nationalist resentment in UK, acting so obnoxiously that EU is glad to see back of them. Brexit can be warped into a "success", for minds poisoned by anger & bitterness...
Read 5 tweets
3 Oct
As usual, when Johnson speaks, he lies... but also manages, despite his carefully managed stage persona, to reveal some hidden truths. A good, and very telling, example from today's prime ministerial musings:
One hand: Johnson claims current problems are part of "necessary" post-Brexit transition. Rubbish. Johnson's Leave cabal chose & designed this Hard Brexit & its inevitable problems. It could've been very different if they had made less extreme choices. None of it was "necessary".
By the way: Truss claims it's not Gov's job to sort these things out; we're not "command & control" economy. Utter drivel. Tories' Hard Brexit was ultimate act of "command & control": Gov actively imposing vast changes upon economy & society in pursuit of ideological (own)goals.
Read 7 tweets
27 Jul
Back to work = time to scrutinise the UK’s proposals (published 21 July 2021) for rewriting the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland. Here is a short(ish) thread with some thoughts:
1) Let’s start with the UK’s diagnosis of the problems created by the Protocol. According to HMG, this terrible deal was inflicted upon poor Prime Minister Johnson as he valiantly battled on all fronts against domestic traitors and foreign adversaries.
2) What a disgraceful denial of responsibility: it was the Johnson Government that proposed a trade border down the Irish Sea, not as some temporary backstop but as a permanent regime, in order to pursue the Hard Right dream of a Hard Brexit for the rest of the UK.
Read 17 tweets
9 Jul
Almost time to batten down the hatches for the weekend. No better company than Netherlands Bach Society: glorious talent; extraordinary generosity. Here, a few recommendations from their recent cantata releases:

No 2:
No 3:
Read 4 tweets
30 Jun
Busy day for Protocol on IRL/NI. Already said earlier today what needs to be said about Belfast High Court ruling (though reaction of Brexitists could still fill an entire psychiatric conference...). Now, some brief comments on this afternoon’s Commission announcement, voila:
1) obviously very good news to see certain temporary measures on foodstuffs (I won’t need to smuggle my ham sandwich over on the ferry this weekend...); as well as other more lasting adjustments (eg on trade in medicines, need for extra car insurance docs, status of guidedogs...)
2) but on core issue, of UK’s legal duty to enforce basic EU customs rules on GB trade into NI, this really is only a temporary fix: doesn’t resolve need for UK to start doing its job properly; whether that’s by agreeing to regulatory alignment or just enforcing the agreed rules
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(