People talk about Jewish trauma from the Holocaust as if it's this event that happened a long time ago and it shouldn't be something we're still affected by. This is very silly.
Do you realize how short 80 years is, in the context of history???
Everyone I know has met someone who was literally the target of a Genocide. Very often their own grandparents. You expect that kind of trauma to just fade away in just 80 years??
We still mourn for a temple destroyed 2,000 years ago, you think we're just gonna be chill about the Holocaust while survivors are still alive??
Like, some of the most horrific and well documented stuff ever done to people, and you think we're just gonna dust ourself off and go "we're good" without even a century having passed
And I'm not even saying this to excuse anything but too many leftists talk about Zionism as if Jews were living comfortably in Europe and then all of a sudden came to the land for no reason other than lust for territory
And then made a whole bunch of weirdly aggressive decisions. So strange! What could have happened that made Jews in 1948 so hell-bent on having a state?
It's almost like having a state full of people who had seen their families gassed to death will affect policy
And then there's these fancy pants academics who chide the unwashed masses of Jews going "tsk tsk why aren't you over the Holocaust yet"
80 years isn't long! Stop gaslighting the Jewish people!
I'm not even trying to make a value judgment as to whether we should or shouldn't, just that, whether you like it or not, it has an effect, and it's simply unrealistic to expect it not to
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Netanel gets at what I've been trying to say the past couple of days. You don't need leadership programs. And you should distrust anyone who wants to mold you. You're not a pile of clay. You're a person.
Idk guys maybe we don't need "leaders", maybe we should try to build a Judaism in which we interact as equals, with authority grounded in text, not personality.
Here's the number one thing I have learned in my life:
If you have good Torah, and you know its good Torah, you don't need institutions, you don't need to shove yourself into a box. No more.
If you don't fit in their boxes, that's not your problem, that's theirs. Cut them out of the equation. Bring your Torah directly to the people who need it.
Because the people who need your Torah, also don't feel served by those institutions. Correctly. They're looking for Torah, and they don't even know they're looking for your Torah.
"women aren't able to say Sheva brachot" seems to me to be the clearest example of "we made it assur because feminism, even though there's no reason it should be"
They're birchot shevach. The s"a leaves them out when listing who can't say them. What's even the hava amina guys
"Ah but you need a minyan of ten men"
You also do for hagomel. And yet the woman in question says it despite not counting for the minyan.
Like, look at this. A guy is like, hey, it seems from the s"a that a woman can say Sheva brachot. Why do we not allow that? And he gets no answer beyond "mesorah". theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/top…