Apparently there is a thread going around about Yemeni Jews and the operation that helped rescue thousands of them claiming they were “exploited” because of their threatened status. Ironically the person who wrote this thread also has me blocked. 1/
Let’s get something clear, as with any operation there are pros and there are cons. The cons are things some Yemeni Jews are still fighting for today such as having items (books, jewelry etc.) that were said to be too heavy for the plane found later on in museums.
2/
Also cases of mistreatment during the early founding of the state which is still being fought for recognition and acknowledgment. However, the pros greatly outweigh the cons not the least bit being our flat out survival. No mention in the thread of the refugee camp near Aden.
3/
The camp at its peak held 16k Jews, well above its capacity, before the operation was approved with no hopes of them being able to go back to their homes in Yemen. Instead of inserting your own narrative of the events maybe listen to those who were involved.
4/
For example these two threads translating the words of Dr. Yehuda Amir who was a child during the operation.
There is no mention of the riots in Aden protesting the UN partition in 1947, which spilled over to other areas in Yemen as well, that preceded the operation and killed dozens of Jews along with looting and burning of homes and synagogues.
Even the most critical of the community about the treatment of the state towards them upon arrival don’t whitewash how much of a necessity it was at the time.
2 things can exist at once:
1) we were treated poorly upon our arrival
2) the op saved many of our lives.
7/
I have shared multiple personal stories, such as moshe’s below, about how they view it as a miracle. They don’t require others twisting their perspective for some political narrative. Stop using us for some agenda you want to push, it’s gross.
The decision to justify your conclusion over the 2014 war data specifically is a giant flaw in of itself. In a proper analysis the paper would look to see if the iron dome succeeded in changing the way Israel responded to rocket attacks from Gaza.
To choose the only war out of the 3 (not 4)* after iron dome deployment, where the abduction and murder of Jewish teenagers were clearly an important factor in shaping the Israeli response, is dishonest at best.
2/
This would have been monumentally apparent if you had actually included most obvious piece of data required for this analysis. The number of rockets launched from Gaza during each of these wars are oddly missing.
3/
Umbrella terms like Ashkenazi, Sephardi, and Mizrahi, which literally signify geographical regions, should not be confused with what nusach someone follows. Even Yemenite Jewry can be considered an umbrella term as within you had Adeni Jews, Habbani Jews, Sana’ani Jews etc.
1/
*Some* of the unique differences that each of those communities had were developed as a result of where their communities were located in Yemen rather than being impacted by which tiklal (siddur) they used.
2/
A Yemeni Jew who follows a largely Sephardic nusach (shami) did not simultaneously adopt the history and lived experiences of Sephardic Jews and their ancestors. Their history didn’t involve being exiled from the Iberian Peninsula in the late 15th century.
3/
Phenomenal video of Yemeni Jewish poems that were written in the 16th and 17th centuries sung by Israeli Yemeni Jews. There are no English captions unfortunately for those who don’t speak Hebrew, however, I’ll add a few interesting bits of info below with the link at the end
1/
There are 18 poems in the entire 50 minute video. I’ve mentioned in the past that Shalom Shabazi is regarded as the poet of Yemen. 10 out of the 18 poems here are written by him, including the one in the clip from the first tweet.
2/
Another extremely well known figure who wrote the poem in this clip is Zechariah Dhahiri. He was one of the primary reasons for Kabbalah reaching Yemen as he travelled to the land of Israel and visited Yosef Karo’s Yeshiva.
Maybe comparing Mizrahi Jews to Trump voters isn’t exactly the best idea. Especially not if you’re trying to convince us we’re wrong in our perspective. This article also misses a lot of points regarding why Mizrahi Jews have zero trust in the left.
The socialist elite class were those who looked down at us and our traditions as “backwards.” They also have a habit of talking to us like they know what’s best for us, instead of actually listening to us and having constructive dialogue.
Also yes there is some racism too, I just last week dealt with a racist Israeli on the left who not only called all Mizrahi Jews liars, compared our grievances to fake news circulated by Qanon groups in the US, while referring to us as Arabs.
3/
Today is #JewishRefugeeDay where we remember the 850,000 Jewish refugees from the MENA region forced to flee after Israel won the war for its independence. In Yemen 16,000 Yemeni Jews were already in the camp set up near Aden by the time approval was given for their evacuation.
Once word got out that they were allowed to leave many Yemeni Jews dropped everything, took what they could and made the dangerous trek (largely by foot) towards Aden where evacuation was approved. Between June 1949-September 1950 over 350 flights helped rescue nearly 50k Jews.
Many died due to disease, starvation, and even attacks by robbers along the way to Aden. Even though they still experienced hardship in the early years inside Israel, with a few families even leaving back to Yemen (before civil war broke out), most deeply appreciated the help.
Since this is gaining traction it’s worthwhile to point out another document worth reading through thoroughly. Ben Gurion’s testimony to the UN in 1947.
“I understand the Arab case and I fully realize it. It is very simple. They state they do not care what happened, and nobody ought to care what happened fifteen hundred or two thousand years ago. We are here...”
2/
“Not one but many nations in the world did not accept that claim because they were faced with a unique case which is not as simple as that...the entire civilized world said that while the Arabs were liberated in various territories there was room for the Jews in Palestine.”
3/