"They seem fine to me". I work with many parents whose children are really unhappy at school. The pressure on them to pretend to outsiders that everything is 'fine' is immense. 1/
These parents often feel shame. Shame that their child isn't fitting in and 'doing well', shame because schools often suggest that they must be doing something wrong, and shame because 'everyone else seems fine'. 2/
Shame because they have often felt forced to do things they would never have chosen, like bring a child to school in their pyjamas, or leave them screaming at the door of the classroom. Shame because every morning and afternoon is so hard. 3/
Shame means that they don't talk about their experiences freely, for fear of judgement by others. Not many things say 'bad parent' (in the eyes of society) more than having a child who is refusing to go to school. 4/
This means that often everyone else remains totally ignorant that this is happening, even close friends and family. Other parents don't see the problem and teachers doesn't realise the level of distress, particularly if a child appears to be 'fine' once at school. 5/
This is how shame operates in our society. It helps maintain social norms. It renders invisible those who do not conform. 6/
Sometimes people think that just because we don't often talk about school-related distress in day to day conversation, that means it isn't there. 'The kids seem fine to me' they say. 'They don't seem traumatised by their experiences'. 7/
But that is how shame works. It hides distress, difference and non-conformity and maintains social norms. When parents get together with others who share their experiences, it's like the mask falls off. 'We thought we were the only ones', they say. 8/
What's my point? Never assume, just because something isn't routinely talked about, that it doesn't exist. Look for the things we can't mention, for fear of judgement. You won't notice shame because that is how it work. It is invisible, and it makes non-conformity invisible. 9/
Many children are unhappy at school and we need to challenge the social norm which says that this is either because there is something wrong with them or it is their parents' fault. This prevents us from acknowledging what a big problem this is. 10/
If we could see the scale of the problem, and if we listened to young people and their parents, we'd see that we have to change the system so it works for many more young people. We'd see that forcing them in does more harm than good. 11/
We could then explore other ways to learn, because school is not the only way to get an education.Children do not have to be forced to learn &if we could move on from that idea we could start to become a more compassionate society, starting with the way we treat young people.12/

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Naomi Fisher

Naomi Fisher Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @naomicfisher

21 Oct
This is not the case and @tes I think an editorial comment should be added to make this clear. Cognitive science does not show that teacher-led learning is best. 1/
@tes I assume she is referring to the #cogsci models which are theories of information processing. The models themselves are silent on the question of how that information is provided and the context. 2/
@tes Many have extrapolated from the #cogsci models to claim that particular education techniques are based on science, but the evidence for this extrapolation is nothing like as strong as the basic model, as the EEF review by @TWPerry1&colleagues shows. 3/educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/news/new-what-…
Read 13 tweets
17 Oct
I often say that feeling a lack of control over your life contributes to poor mental health - and recently several people have asked for my evidence. It's such a well-established finding in psychology that I hadn't realised that it wasn't well known in the wider population.1/
This comes from many psychological theories - one I use is cognitive theory, which suggests that particular thoughts and beliefs about the world (like, I have no control, or I can't change anything) underpin and lead to emotional responses such as depression. 2/
It is also very well backed up with evidence. The research talks about control in many different ways, but one important way is agency - the belief that you can make choices and decisions to influence events and have an impact on the world. 3/
Read 22 tweets
16 Oct
This podcast is packed full of information, neuroscience and paradigm shifts. I’ll put a few thoughts below to whet your appetites. 1/
Mary Helen thinks we need a paradigm shift in education as fundamental as Copernicus - who first realised that the earth went around the sun and not vice versa. 2/
Early scientists looked up from the earth and tried to predict what was happening with the assumption that they were at the centre. It kind of worked, but there was lots that didn’t fit. 2/
Read 26 tweets
1 Oct
Cultural capital and #cogsci. Cognitive scientists sometimes say that deprived children lack the background knowledge that other children acquire at home, and so the aim of education should be to even this out. 1/
One efficient way to do this, it’s said, is by explicitly teaching a body of facts which are said to make up the common knowledge that as as a culture we expect ‘well educated’ people to have. 2/
@DTWillingham suggests that this should be the back ground knowledge necessary to read a broadsheet newspaper or books written for the ‘intelligent layman’ on science or politics. This,he says, is the information which will have the greatest cognitive benefit.3/
Read 18 tweets
29 Sep
It is strange how many seem to believe that if we didn’t send children to school, they will remain in early childhood forever, playing, running around and exploring. 1/
School teaches that it is essential, and it seems we grow up to believe that. We can’t imagine how otherwise a person can develop into an adult. 2/
It is particularly strange because in many countries in the world today, lots of people do not go to school, and yet they grow up and become functioning adults. 3/
Read 14 tweets
6 Sep
Such an interesting episode on the science of learning with neuroscientist Samah Karaki and ⁦@teb_logan⁩. I had to listen to it twice. I’ll put some of my thoughts below. podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/fut…
1/ Dr Karaki starts by saying that she’s a neuroscientist by training, but she’s aware that it’s only one perspective. Her aim is to bring together ways of thinking about learning from biology, psychology and social science.
2/ She points out that education often ignores the fact that brains always exist in a cultural and social context, that learning does not happen in a vacuum. Experimental studies remove people from their context and so reduce learning to a technical process.
Read 22 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(