A short reply: the proof that my debate tanked Graham Hancock's support in his fandom is everywhere
No rational people think his ideas are plausible after seeing us
So the only response he had was to make it seem I lied. A ridiculous and cheap ploy
/1
The claim I lied is ridiculous for several reasons
First, not a single professional archaeologist agrees with him. We disagree for many reasons because the archaeological evidence against an advanced Ice Age civilization exists everywhere in all the archaeology we do have
/2
Second, Hancock's claims that I lied have nothing to do with the two core disproofs that I focused my time presenting to Joe Rogan
The evidence for Ice Age hunter-gatherers on coasts, underwater, and in deserts
The evidence for the development of agriculture around the world
/3
OK, I've now seen this video. I will reply in this thread to the defamatory accusation here, made both by @Graham__Hancock and @dedunkingpast, that I somehow "conned" Graham Hancock and @JoeRogan
/1
First off, Graham Hancock has written several books, hosted a Netflix series, and given 100s of talks on the topic of a global civilization from the Ice Age with advanced technology
If I conned him using published evidence, then he's admitting he doesn't know much about it
/2
Which is true. He admitted directly to Joe Rogan that there is "no evidence" for his proposed civilization
I am annoyed with the editors of Archaeological Prospection and the media and how it handles this Gunung Padang controversy
Nobody has gone and talked with local Indonesian archaeologists. None provide the correct date of the monument nor even stated it's not a pyramid
/1
Misinformation and disinformation is successful because it fills up the internet with wrong information and overwhelms correct information
This retraction by the editors at Archaeological Prospection is not enough
Local archaeologists know about the site. They've excavated it
To learn more about the site, I reached out to Dr. Lutfi Yondri and @harrysofian
Why?
Because I couldn't trust what was on the internet. Wikipedia provides some wide range of dates. No article, blog, podcast, or youtube video provided an accurate date
I recently learned the teaching of ancient languages at Cardiff University (@cardiffuni @CUHistArchRel) is under threat: Latin, Ancient Greek, Hebrew & Sanskrit
SIGN AND SHARE this petition created by ancient history and archaeology students 1/7
From its foundation 130 years ago, the teaching of languages - including Welsh, Latin, and Ancient Greek - has been a central emphasis @cardiffuni
Multilingual inscriptions around campus can be found, but future students might not be trained to read those in ancient languages
/2
The students note, 'We should be working to bring these languages outside of private education to make them accessible to everyone who wishes to learn & expand their knowledge of the ancient world'
His rhetoric sows distrust in experts, and #Atlantis conspiracy theories promote white supremacy
Buckle up, it’s time for an #ARCHAEOLOGY THREAD 🧵
/1
This thread will examine
1)Hancock's lack of evidence
2)How Hancock’s narrative recycles 19th century ideas on #Atlantis
3)The rhetorical tools Hancock and similar conspiracy theories use
/2
Why trust me?
No idea. I’m just a dude who won’t pay for a checkmark
But I am a real archaeologist. I’ve excavated at sites spanning tens of thousands of years of human history & prehistory
Trust my credentials or don’t. But I’ll present real evidence why this show is crap
/3