OK - in Day 3 of 3 hiatus in #GhislaineMaxwell trial, now another sexual exploitation case, Columbia's "Dirty Doc" Hadden. Inner City Press has reported on it innercitypress.com/sdny29straussh… and will live tweet, thread below
Judge Berman (joining the proceeding after a meeting): If you want to have some additional argument, I'm happy to hear that.
Defense lawyer: We believe an evidentiary hearing is appropriate. There was been more than normal cooperation between the two prosecutors
AUSA Kim: Defendant has failed to justify any sort of evidentiary hearing. It's all speculation. There are numerous cases where there has been a Federal prosecution after a state case.
[Uh, like US Attorney Alex Acosta sending Epstein case back to the state?]
Judge Berman: I'm far along with my draft. I'll include today's comments. I can have a written ruling by 4 pm today.
[Inner City Press will report on that as well.]
Hadden's 2d lawyer, Federal Defender Deirdre D. Von Dornum: We would like oral argument on our motion to suppress.
Judge Berman: I could hear it right now. I have the time.
Von Dornum: Some of it should not be public.
[Oh, that again.]
Judge Berman: In January we have a lot of pre-trial scheduling to accomplish. We start our trial on March 28. For the moment there are only a limited number of court room where jury trials can take place.
[Because COVID. Hadden has a call-in line. Why not Maxwell?
Judge Berman: We have another request, that came in yesterday, requesting a jury questionnaire.
AUSA Kim: We oppose the questionnaire, and believe the Court can effectively preside over voir dire. We'll filed by Tuesday, Dec 21.
Judge Berman: I'd thought Monday
Judge Berman: We'll need an hour at least for oral argument. It'll be January 5. And jury selection March 28.
Adjourned.
Soon podcast and stories on InnerCityPress.com and patreon.com/MatthewRussell…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
OK - it's US v. #GhislaineMaxwell trial Day 12, defense arguing to keep their case open until Monday for a final, 81-year old witness. Inner City Press is reporting on the case and will live tweet, thread below patreon.com/posts/60022486
Judge Nathan: I'm letting in the documents about residence versus ownership. If I weren't, you might have a point. Is this deposition transcript new to you?
Maxwell's lawyer: She was deposed in a slip and fall case.
Judge Nathan: You'll provide the transcript.
Judge Nathan: I have a rule, you have your next witness or you rest. If otherwise the case closes today, it closes today.
[Couldn't Maxwell's lawyers just do super-long direct examination? And what about the 3 day hiatus?]
OK - now US v. #GhislaineMaxwell trial Day 11, afternoon thread. Maxwell's lawyer want to put in "prior inconsistent statement" of survivor witness Carolyn, after they finish the paid memory decay expert Loftus. Inner City Press will live tweet, thread below
Judge Nathan: What else?
Maxwell's lawyer: The US' rebuttal expert, I'm prepared to file something if they actually call the expert.
Judge Nathan: Hamilton?
Everdell: We reached him, he can do WebEx tomorrow.
Sternheim: Because of his condition, we haven't spoken.
Jury entering!
Maxwell's lawyer: Dr Loftus, are you aware of image enhancing memory distortion?
Loftus: It makes people feel better about themselves.
Maxwell's lawyer: I asked you about C.V. So I move into evidence your C.V.
AUSA: Objection.
OK - Now Trial Day 11 of US v. #GhislaineMaxwell, Inner City Press is reporting on the case including 3 day (DC) hiatus and will now continue live tweeting the trial day(s), thread below patreon.com/posts/59982178
Judge Alison Nathan, who yesterday in DC forwarded her nomination to 2d Circuit Court of Appeals, takes the bench & just begins ruling on the filings that built up over the 3 day hiatus (request for call in line amid Omicron and all flight logs still UNacted on)
Judge Nathan: About Doctor Loftus' testimony. The US seeks to exclude 2 aspects, her testimony on leading questions and therapists' techniques. I have ruled that these are generally admissible. I deny the government's motion to preclude.
Now @SDNYLIVE, case against Robert De Niro, whose lawyer is threatening to seek sanctions against plaintiff Ms. Graham Chase Robinson. Inner City Press has reported on the case innercitypress.com/sdny25bparkerd… and will live tweet, thread below
De Nero's lawyer wants to do a 14 hour deposition of the plaintiff. Judge asks why.
Lawyer: There are 2 defendants here, Mr. de Nero and Canal Productions.
Judge: I don't think you are entitled to 14 hours.
De Nero's lawyer asks to move the deposition - now whittled down to 7 hours - from Friday to Monday. Judge orders it so, telling Plaintiff take make herself available absent some medical emergency.
Judge: I expect the defense not to engage in speaking objections
OK - now Jan 6 defendant Cleveland Grover Meredith is being sentenced by DDC Judge Amy Berman Jackson, in a proceeding that UNlike US v. #GhislaineMaxwell has a public call-in line. Inner City Press will live tweet (while in transit to @SDNYLIVE), thread below
Assistant US Attorney: The way the case law is, Mr. Meredith did not even have to act on the threat, just make it. The government believe that over four days, Mr. Meredith accelerated his interest in engaging in violence and narrowed in on who to do it to.
Meredith's lawyer: The AUSA is mostly talking about my client's words... To show his mindset, he said, That's why they call me Double Oh Dipsh*t... Social media is chit-chat, not serious type language. This has to be taking into account.
OK - it's US v. #GhislaineMaxwell Day 10, jury finally seated, jurors being directed to binder of sealed non-public exhibits. Inner City Press is reporting innercitypress.com/sdnytrial39max… and will live tweet, thread below
Assistant US Attorney Rohrbach: The government calls William Brown of the NYS Dept of Motor Vehicles.
AUSA: Are you aware how people receive ID cards?
Brown: Yes.
AUSA: Please pick up the folder next to you, [sealed] government exhibit.
Judge Nathan: I will admit these exhibits under seal.
AUSA: Look at Defense Exhibit LD3A, it's in the front of the binder. How old in 1996 was this person, born in 1985?
Brown: 11 years old.
No cross.. Next witness.
AUSA: The government calls Annie Farmer.