Something that’s becoming evident in the current Turkish financial crisis is that since, say, the major financial crisis of 2001, which wiped out 10% of GDP, GDP has more than tripled.
In the process, the middle class has accumulated far more wealth than it had in 2001 (when many were forced to sell their real estate, cars, any hard asset to pay debts).
Some of that middle class wealth is held in hard currencies, and has actually risen by as much as 40% as a result of the lira’s depreciation. Additional wealth is held in gold, which has similarly gained value against the lira.
The expansion of household wealth over the previous two decades is unevenly spread, and there is evidence of widening gaps between classes. The poor are undoubtedly suffering greatly as they struggle with inflation.
But the broad middle class does not seem to be in a panic. Tonight, the upscale Zorlu Center shopping mall’s restaurants and stores were humming. In 2001, at a comparable venue, there was not a single car in a vast parking lot and the place was a ghost town.
This is a wealthier, more resilient Turkey than the one that endured 2001. The crisis is hitting different segments of the society in different ways and the political effects of that will play out over time.
None of the above should be read to excuse or minimize the economic mismanagement which has led a proud country of 84 million into a dark and difficult corner.
Addendum: interesting stats here on individual bank account holdings in foreign currencies (around 65%). These accounts are showing large gains, in lira terms, as a result of lira’s depreciation. That’s the cushion’ I spoke of. al-monitor.com/originals/2021…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
A tragedy is unfolding in Turkey. Any vestige of central bank independence has vanished: a further rate cut ordered by the President today sent the lira to 11.11/$ at one point (now 11.03). Another rate cut next month is expected, with the predictable Fx effect.
The Minister of Finance, who opposes the President's wrongheaded interest rate policy, is likely to be sacked. Leaked video of an AKP party caucus today made his isolation clear. The last remaining voice of sanity in ruling party circles.
Inflation is officially 20%, but actually at least 30-40% month on month. Hoarding of basic supplies has started: some markets are reported to be limiting customers to one bottle of olive oil per purchase, for example.
Many memories of 9/11, all vivid. Getting a call from a relative in the ITV newsroom in London after first plane hit: “what do you think ?” As we talked, second plane hit and I instantly told him. He shouted to the newsroom: “It’s f*cking terrorists !”
Waited hours outside an armory in Grammercy Park, to give blood for survivors who never came. Trudged home up Park Ave. South surrounded by ‘zombie’ people coated in white dust, heads down, utterly silent. Churches had tables set up with water, like a marathon.
Church the following Sunday (St. Ignatius Loyola, Park Ave.) was packed to the rafters. Emotional tension like I’ve never felt.
Spending time in another country that has struggled to preserve a semblance of democracy offers a refresher course on the basics. I've been reminded that:
1.Media matters. We suffer from partisan presentation of ‘news,’ and associated disinformation, but still have media capable of independent investigation and reporting. It’s impossible to resist encroaching authoritarianism without an independent press.
2.Judicial independence is indispensable. Despite legitimate concerns over GOP court-packing, the federal judiciary remains independent of the Executive, institutionally capable of resisting Executive or Legislative overreach (particular failures to do so notwithstanding).
More photos from Burgazada in the Princes Islands (Sea of Marmarma, Istanbul). First, some scenes from a morning walk.
Typical island architecture. These are mostly summer residences (May thru November), but many come at the weekend year round (only 45 minutes from central Istanbul). Stunning sea views, in most cases.
Greek Orthodox church of St. John the Baptist (right side photo), and the adjacent building which was the Greek community’s school (now apartments). There is still a remnant of this once prominent local community.