We need to think openly about Putin's outrageous policies. The main reason for his aggression against Ukraine, which has already cost thousands of human lives, is that he wants to stay in power in Russia to repress & steal as he loves to do. This must not be allowed.
Rather than talking to Putin, the West should sanction him and his ilk, reveal and freeze his billions abroad. There is no reason to treat Putin better than the ayatollahs in Iran. He should be declared out of bounds as the lawless terrorist he prides himself of being.
In the same way as the world could not get any peace until Hitler and Mussolini were dead, the world is likely to suffer one threatened disaster after the other until Putin is out of power and Russia transformed to a nice democracy as Nemtsov & Navalny aspired to.
Putin's and Shoigu's lies today crossed the crucial line between leaders that you can talk to and those that you can only condemn. There are no US military contractors in Donbas; the US is not playing with chemical weapons there. Shoigu was just lying. Condemn him!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Strangely, on Russia & Ukraine, Washington is divided between Putin appeasers (worst of all Tucker Carlson) & realistic knowledgeable Russia specialists, such as @AmbDanFried@JohnEdHerbst@ARVershbow@SpecRepUkraine@general_ben & the NSC seem to turn to the appeasers.
So far, the White House has failed to formulate its own agenda on Russia. @McFaul has presented the best proposals I have seen so far. Also @Nigelgd1, @KeirGiles & @john_sipher have argued well. What should the US agenda be?
1. No more negotiations about Ukraine without Ukraine at the table = no more Putin-Biden summits to reward Putin for aggression!
The US should demand that the OSCE is being restored as the main frum for Russian-Western negotiations.
Today @washingtonpost has published two articles favoring appeasement to Russia. That would hardly have happened if Fred Hiatt were still alive.
David von Drehle wants to give in to Kremlin military extortion, promising to keep Ukraine out of NATO.
"It may be possible to give Putin a portion of what he wants without substantially altering the U.S. position, and thus defuse a dangerous situation." washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/…
He continues: "the United States and its allies must recognize Russia’s interest in a neutral Ukraine."
No! Russia attacked Ukraine, when it was neutral. Neutrality is dangerous as Benelux experienced in WWI & WWII & Denmark & Norway in WWII.
The question is persistently asked: Why is Putin threatening with war against Ukraine now? A few ideas: 1. Russia's relative military strength will never be greater than today given stagnant economy & declining technological development.
2. Putin needs a small victorious war, or corresponding Western concessions, to stay in power. His various ratings are at an all time low, and Putin cares greatly about his ratings (popularity, trust, electability).
3. Since February 2021, President Zelensky has seen the light and realized that he cannot talk with Putin. 4. In 2021, Ukraine has cleaned up its military commands & got an excellent defense minister in Oleksii Reznikov.
What is @ZelenskyyUa up to? 1. He appears to maintain his partnership with Ihor Kolomoisky pursued in the US, UK & Israel, but not in Ukraine. 2. Yanukovych's top lawyer Andriy Portnov returned with Z but was now sanctioned by the US.
3. In September 2019, he appointed a friend of his, Oleksandr Gogliashvili, deputy minister of Interior, but he was just revealed to be a Russian citizen. 4. He has protected his deputy chief of staff Tatarov from prosecution for corruption.
5. The Pandora Papers show that Z & three colleagues received $41 million in their offshore company from Kolomoisky. Z has refused to answer any question about this unreported & untaxed transaction.
After a seemingly successful video call Biden-Putin, many things have gone wrong. Biden allows the conversation to focus on Putin's aggressive demands. It is Biden, Ukraine & the West that should make demands to Putin.
1. Withdraw offensive forces from Ukraine's border, Crimea & Donbas! Return to prior transparency & preannouncement of military exercises of size! Why has the West let up on those standards?
2. Russia is the main source of destabilization in the former Soviet Union. Demand that Russian troops withdraw from Donbas, Transnistria, Abkhazia & South Ossetia! Russia has repeatedly made international agreements that it will not violate national borders. Hammer that in!
Outstanding 20-minute lecture by Dmitri Muratov.
"The practice of torture in prisons and during investigation is also alive and well in today’s Russia."
End: "I want journalists to die old." nobelprize.org/prizes/peace/2…
"Criminal cases in our country are often based on false accusations and political motives. Opposition politician Alexei Navalny is being held in jail based on a false accusation from the CEO of the Russian branch of a big French cosmetics company....
...The accuser was somehow not summoned to the court or neither pleaded to be an aggrieved party. But Navalny is behind bars. The cosmetics company chose to step aside hoping that the odour from this case will not harm the scent of the company’s products."