1/n In London, the Great Stink happened. The entire sewer system, such as it was, emptied directly without treatment into the open sewer that was the river Thames. In 1858, for 2 months, the odor became so unbearable that everyone who could remotely afford it fled central London.
2/n Just before the Great Stink, cholera — then a very *new* disease for 99% of the world — also happened in 1854 in London. And so did John Snow (as in the famous John Snow Memorandum johnsnowmemo.com/john-snow-memo…), who just removed a pump handle, & thereby slashed cholera right down.
3/n *Amazingly*, sense happened. Everyone said, we must build better sewers, maybe even better drinking water. And Joseph Bazalgette happened, & got the job of building a new sewer system. Astonishingly, he said "Bugger small limits", & built a system for >10x the then population
4/ Everything was **hunky-dory** for 25 years after completion of the new London sewer system. Not only did cholera diminish a lot, but also the age-old typhus & typhoid epidemics. The Americans looked at this & said, "We can't let the lousy Brits out-TECH us", so they copied it
5/ Everything was truly hunky-dory. Now dying horribly of cholera or typhoid became much rarer. Now no big stink in big cities.
And then: first real #polio epidemic in the US, Vermont, 1894. Then, in NYC *alone*, 9,000 cases of polio in 1916. And it kept coming back — in waves.
6/ Neither isolation nor quarantine stopped the "new" bug of epidemic polio. People started getting, naturally, *worried* about polio. Except, as I said before, polio is an age-old disease, which had previously been *endemic*, not epidemic. What gives?
7/ Polio epidemics became bad; in one in Denmark, in 1952, Bjørn Aage Ibsen invented the modern Intensive Care Unit (ICU, Intensivstation), for which we can all be very grateful today! But he invented it specifically for polio patients — & managed to lower deaths from 90% to 25%
8/ He accomplished slashing death rates from 90% to 25% through the age-old medical/academic wheeze of getting your students to do the grunt work. He enlisted them to manually pump O2 + air into patients' lungs, around the clock.
But hey. What works, works
9/ Now this whole thread followed on from my last one, linked below. And the whole point is: polio likes water, but only infects humans, & can't live all that long alone. Get it as an infant, 6 months to 5 years, you've a good 99.x% chance you'll be fine
@threadreaderapp unroll, thanks. cc. @BernieOCoimin, it's threadreaderapp you want, not threadreader. In a minute, Threadreaderapp will reply to this with the thread.
1/n And now, the kicker. Want to reduce polio death rates by up to 90% WITH THIS EASY TRICK?
Just make sure your children drink water contaminated with sewage from the minute they're born. Eventually, polio will become endemic again, everyone exposed.
2/n This thread follows on from my old thread, linked below. And it's true; if children drink water contaminated with sewage, in a place where polio exists, death rates will fall by up to 90%, because they'll all have polio before they're 5 years of age
3/n That must appeal to all antivaxxers out there, & those who worship the economy to the point of refusing taxes for new sewage systems.
Just a small drawback: typhoid, typhus, cholera, shigella, amoebiasis, E. coli O157:H7 will all kill FAR more children
New thread, continuing on from old thread. Next:
just how dangerous IS #polio? And I'm going to give y'all two separate, different answers. First off, we need the difference between CFR & IFR. Because especially with polio, people confuse these.
2/n ➡️ CFR: Case Fatality Ratio.
Out of all the people you document with an infection by a particular bug, how many of them die, the %.
I.e., CFR only measures the percentage of those who die among the infections you *noticed & documented*.
3/n ➡️ IFR: Infection Fatality Ratio
Out of ALL the people who get infected by that particular bug, including ALL the ones you didn't notice or document, what percentage of them cark it?
Apparently @umairh, who's a rather nasty nutcase, wrote the below snippet, in a blog post (eand.co/the-lesson-of-…) that he's now deleted, after virologists laughed at him
*sigh*
you can have either:
a/ Toby Young really doesn't understand statistics and causality, Example no.# 958,689,
or
b/ Toby Young actively peddles misinformation.
Whichever you prefer. But you must pick one.
oh, I see. At this time, 175 replies under that tweet of Toby Young's, every single reply (not kidding) telling him he's completely misread or wilfully dishonestly misrepresented the stats. He hasn't taken any notice, of course.
Actual report is written by Will Jones "Dr Will Jones is a writer currently focused on countering misinformation around the COVID-19 crisis. He has a PhD in political philosophy & a BSc in mathematics, ... an MA in ethics .. a diploma in theology."
At least 3 degrees wasted.
1/ New thread, from the old thread (below). What do you think the average denialist or antivaxxer would have made of polio today, if it came in a 'new' epidemic form (like it did from @ 1890)? The excuses to do absolutely nothing would come thick & fast.
2/ Taxes for a big global eradication? You know as well as I do what the usual denialists & antivaxxers would say.
"But it's always been around! It's everywhere! It's *endemic*!"
And you know what? They would have been right, even though wrong as excuse
3/ Universal vaccinations? Every denialist would scream, "But #polio only kills very few!"
And that was absolutely right, especially before 1920. Polio killed very very few. It crippled many more, but still "only a few".
Do you think the denialists really care about children?