Though I may have resigned from the Foreign Office, rumours of my demise as a diplomat are greatly exaggerated. Today I report as the new "Ambassador at Large" to the Court of St James: my first report is the traditional "First Impressions" despatch, titled "Yule Britannia"🧵
SUMMARY: The UK today is far removed from the "Cool Britannia" of a decade ago. Buffeted by crises and scandals, many self-inflicted, trust in the government is plummeting, even as the costs of Brexit become more apparent, and covid takes its toll on a fatigued and divided nation
ECONOMY: This year saw supply chain problems, empty grocery shelves, worker shortages, soaring fuel prices, pigs culled and crops unpicked. While covid played its part, and other countries faced problems, Brexit magnified the impact in UK, though the Government remains in denial.
The govt can claim success in securing a few new trade deals - but not nearly enough to offset the decline in EU trade. The UK-US deal is on the backburner, while US steel tariffs remain on the UK, some say as a warning to the UK over the NIP, though they were lifted on the EU.
Small businesses have been worst affected by Brexit. Troublingly many are reported to be completely unprepared for the new custom procedures due to come into effect on Jan 1st - which many in the govt-supporting tabloid media misleadingly continue to blame as "EU red tape"
Despite constant Govt efforts to downplay the impact of Brexit, the Govt's own fiscal watchdog, the Office of Budget Responsibility, has declared that the impact of Brexit on the UK economy will be worse in the long run compared to the covid pandemic, now in a deadly 4th wave.
SECURITY: On 16 March the UK released its "Integrated Review" of the UK’s Defence, Security, Development and Foreign Policy. Far-reaching and ambitious, it envisions an unshackled "Global Britain", engaged in Asia, harnessing technology to combat modern threats, a force for good.
Described by this correspondent in an earlier tweet as a "doughnut" strategy - superficially attractive, saying many good things, but with a hole in the middle where engaging with the EU should be. And further hollowed out by aid, diplomatic and military budget cuts.
The UK's declining impact exemplified by its inability to influence the US's decision to withdraw from Afghanistan. The flaws in its own evacuation efforts were exposed by a Foreign Office Whistleblower, while the then For Sec Raab remained on holiday. Russian crisis brewing.
DOMESTIC POLICY: Govt has made little to no progress on its much vaunted "levelling up" agenda, while forging ahead with a regressive set of policies designed to appeal to its hardest wing: the most obvious of which is tougher immigration rules, against surging migrant tragedy.
Govt also introducing measures to limit public protests, circumscribe judicial review, reject rulings it doesn't like, limit protests, amend the Human Rights Act, and force EU nationals, even those living here for decades, who do not yet have settled status to reapply to stay.
Meanwhile, the government has faced a series of scandals in the last few weeks, the worst of which included mishandling the Owen Patterson affair, and denying Christmas parties took place last year during covid lockdowns, insulting the many 1000s who lost loved ones at that time.
It is not that the sins themselves were so grievous in themselves (indeed, many Brits may have discreetly breached a rule or two in the past year). It is the PM's arrogant dismissal of concerns, blatant breach of the rules, and failure to even acknowledge any mistake which grate
This perception of "One rule for Them, One Rule for Us" was probably what led to the devastating election loss in N Shropshire, a safe Tory seat for almost 200 years. There is now a palpable sense that the tide has turned against the govt, and that the PM is on borrowed time.
Rumours swirl of potential leadership challenges to the PM; even his allies say he needs to get a grip. Many suspect his Brexit Envoy David Frost stepped down to distance himself from a failing govt. His replacement on EU matters, Liz Truss, is ambitiously positioning herself.
Above it all remains the Queen, a widely loved and respected figure, whose dignified presence at the funeral of her husband was perhaps the saddest image of the year, reflecting the losses of so many, but also providing the strongest contrast with the behaviour of the PM
As we look to 2022, the question for this government is whether it truly will "heed the message" of the N Shropshire voters, and be able to adapt course, or whether it will limp on, doubling down in its claims that Brexit is a success, and pandering ever more to its right wing.
Early signs are not promising. Truss has continued the tough rhetoric of invoking Art 16. Govt is still announcing gimmicks such as allowing champagne to be sold in pints. The govt has opted out of tough decisions on covid, despite the risk of overwhelming NHS.
And for the PM personally - will he continue to be the Lord of Misrule? Or will he sober up, literally and metaphorically, drop the wine and cheese, jokes and quips, which no longer amuse; stop being the Jester, and start being the Statesman? England can only wait and hope.
May I wish you all a joyous Christmas and festive season. Stay safe, stay well. I remain your ever humble and faithful servant....etc etc etc.
I'm going to add here, on reflection, and in fairness, recognition of a commendable effort on COP, impressive chairing by Alok Sharma, pretty good G7, and a genuinely impressive initial covid vaccine rollout. Follow through tbd.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with alexandra hall hall

alexandra hall hall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @alexhallhall

19 Dec
Very good analysis here on implications of Frost's departure. But what I can't imagine is how and with whom BJ replaces him whilst maintaining party unity: I call it "The Goldilocks Problem "🧵
2/ Another hardliner, or even more extreme successor to Frost will only exacerbate relations with EU [and US, if NIP threats continue], worsen business problems, and increase disillusion of even more voters about Brexit, whose results fall far short of what was promised..
3/ But a more moderate pragmatic replacement will alienate ERG rebels and stir up allegations of BJ "selling out". Too soft.
Read 7 tweets
15 Dec
My earlier tweets were really just limbering up for today's 🧵, dissecting Penny Mordaunt's speech at the Carter Centre in Atlanta yesterday...it's a bit all over the place, frankly, and I am afraid this is not my best effort either, but here goes... ...gov.uk/government/spe…
First: location: the Carter Center founded by Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter has a "fundamental commitment to human rights and the alleviation of human suffering; seeks to prevent and resolve conflicts, enhance freedom and democracy, and improve health"
Mordaunt makes barely a passing reference to the Carters or their work; instead focusing almost entirely on the UK & Brexit, pitching it as "a massive opportunity to anyone who believes in democracy and the power of trade as a force for good in the world."
Read 17 tweets
13 Dec
Amidst the row over the govt's perceived "One Rule for Us and One Rule for them" approach at home, I've been reflecting on the extent to which there's also a certain amount of "Do as I Say, Not as I do" in our international dealings as well..🧵
I thoroughly welcome focus in Govt's Integrated Review of Security, Defence, Dvlpmt and Foreign Policy on "championing human rights, democratic values, good governance, the rule of law, and open societies". I regard these as part and parcel of security: enlightened self interest.
In the FCDO's 2020 human rights report, Raab described "the mission of Global Britain as a force for good." Liz Truss's Chatham House speech last week, though heavy on trade, tech and security, also contained stirring words about supporting freedom loving countries and so forth;
Read 24 tweets
12 Dec
Actually, Truss's speech makes my blood boil: it's fine to have a strategic vision, but the bread and butter of foreign policy involves daily hard choices/tradeoffs: Saudi arms sales vs human rights, fighting corruption vs Russian money in UK, Uighurs & Tibet vs trade w China etc
Truss's calls for "the free world to fight back", harness the "power of economics and technology ", forming a "network of liberty" etc offer no practical guide for dealing with real live situations in Yemen, Belarus, Myanmar, Iran, Afghanistan, Venezuela etc....
She urges "it's time for us to be proud of who we stand for"; and proclaims "Britain is the greatest country on earth "
Read 4 tweets
11 Dec
Our dear leader shredded this morning on the US NPR comedy talk show "Wait, Wait Don't Tell Me": "The Brits first realised something was up with the party that wasn't a party when they saw pictures of Boris Johnson with his hair combed..."
"Why does he always look like he's been on a three day bender?". "Is that at the start or the end of the party?"
"Or do his parties always take place under helicopter blades?"
Read 5 tweets
7 Dec
I sometimes feel we are prisoners in a "heads you win, tails I lose" situation. Brexit is the will of the people, even if it isn't anymore. We must respect the 2016 refdm for all eternity - though Brexiteers felt no such obligation to respect the 1975 refdm to stay in the EU🧵
If the EU acts reasonably in negotiations with us, it means we are winning, and must push for more. If in fact they are out to punish us, and are not playing fair, then we must be even tougher. If they back down, it shows being tough was right.
We are committed to the GFA and no hard border in Ireland. If we keep asserting this, then it's the fault of Ireland/EU if a hard border needs to be erected, tho' the circumstances in which this situation arose was purely due to our decision to leave the EU, SM and CU
Read 17 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(