That thread goes on to say "granted these stereotypes about goblins all predate her writing" but... they really don't. As someone pretty well pickled in fantasy juice over my life, goblins are always either tiny green guys with big ears who stab you, or Brian Froud muppets. ImageImage
And like, visuals can vary a little if we're digging up ancient mythological sources, and you MIGHT see some concept of "greedy" or something in the sense of like, oh this horrible little thing sneaking around stabbing me also just grabbed every shiny thing it saw on the way,"
they're not at all the sort of creature one imagines managing a stock portfolio. They're the sort of creature one might imagine managing a burlap sack full of bugs, poorly, they keep falling out holes in the sides or being eaten.

If you want some sort of fantasy banker, the most
obvious thing that comes to my mind is to have a bank run by some laid back dragon. You get to have a little scene where the protagonist is taken aback by a dragon both being real and not out terrorizing people, then you give the dragon a nice little smug speech about people just
voluntarily walking in and adding more gold to his treasure hoard. This writes itself.

Want to keep it humanoid? Keep dragons in the back pocket to play straight as scary monsters, or you're looking ahead to movie adaptations on tighter budgets? Leprechauns. Everyone understands
that leprechauns have pots of gold, and closely guard them, make deals with legalistic language needed. You'd maybe run a risk of unflattering Irish stereotypes if you're some kind of hack, but that clearly wasn't a concern when you're introducing the Weasleys in the next scene.
Yeah, this is the other thing!

She had no problem just making up her own weird whimsical things for a bunch of stuff where there was an obvious choice to pull from the monster manual, and then takes more commonly understood names and concepts, mashes them
together, and then makes it super racist. Elves, as understood by... literally everyone in the world, except whoever came up with Santa's workshop:
You've got tall mystical wise but haughty immortals.
You've got forest archers.
Either way, they're all always hot and high-femme. ImageImage
Then this bigoted hack comes along all, "hey, those things that like fix your shoes in the night, those are elves, right? Gonna have all the rich families have a bunch as personal slaves. But they're cool with it, and I'll throw in how idea of freeing them is a complete joke."
Hindsight is 20/20 and all but wow we really did let some some monstrously cruel bigot who doesn't even have a child's understanding of mythology and fantasy slap a bunch of words pulled at random from a D&D book onto grotesque racist crap and made her a billionaire didn't we.
AND then we let her just blatantly steal the name of the main character/series from a legitimately underrated 80s fantasy movie.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Secret Gamer Girl

Secret Gamer Girl Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SecretGamerGrrl

9 Jan
So it's been like 3 days now of everyone having this absurd little debate about whether J.K. Rowling presenting "goblins" with every horrible antisemetic stereotype there is is an indication of antisemetism, which is a really absurd argument to be having for two reasons.

First,
like I said- oh it was a whole 5 days ago (wow, time flies): Yes, that is absolutely what it means, it's so unambiguous the best defense anyone is even attempting to muster is this hail mary suggestion that hey, maybe there's centuries of British folklore
that also depict goblins using every possible negative Jewish stereotype. Sure none of them are able to produce a single example of such, but maybe she has the only copy of a book where someone collected all that folklore and then everyone who contributed to it was struck on the
Read 7 tweets
6 Dec 21
... Holy crap I just stumbled across the knowledge that the latest big funnymunny craze was sparked off by the stupidest person on the planet having a temper tantrum an absolutely no conception whatsoever of how video games work. polygon.com/22709126/ether…
So as a quick disclaimer, this has nothing at all to do with how this turducken of scams has actually played out since, where someone charges you a ton of money for a tinyurl but the tinyurl goes in the funnymunny registry so we have to burn down another rain forest to note it...
But apparently, this is the thought process involved in what the real vision was:
- A balance patch to World of Warcraft changed how this guy's favorite ability worked (and honestly I'm not even going to call it a nerf, it was changing a self-healing spell so it doesn't pull down
Read 24 tweets
25 Nov 21
It's really easy to make fun of blithering idiots with fantasies about colonizing other planets and hand-waving away insurmountable problems they don't actually have a solution for. It's also entertaining so keep it up.

But it's also easy and fun to pick on them for the obvious
flaws they've thought way too much about.

Like the basic fact that literally the only reason anyone has ever had or ever will have to set up a colony is to get access to the sort of cheap labor you can only get by enslaving or at least thoroughly exploiting native people you're
very cool with denying basic human rights for and killing now and then. The colony itself you see only has value because it's in a place remote enough that people with morals and legal jurisdiction and such can't see what you're doing and/or can't easily stop you from doing it.
Read 9 tweets
25 Nov 21
Hey everybody, see this patreon here? patreon.com/SFtheWolf

It's significant because it belongs to:
A- Someone I care deeply about
and
B- Someone who makes incredibly rad game dev middleware and music and such that subscribers get all of at no extra cost if I recall properly.
The production of said things is currently stalled out because she went heavily into debt on a new computer, sold the old one to help cover that, and then the new one proved to have a broken everything (video card, monitor, fans, USB ports) and funnymunny mines ruined the market.
So if, say, a whole bunch of people reading this were to kick in a bit of that patreon cash to her, even if just for like a month or two, you'd first off get access to a lot of currently existing rad stuff, and also help jump start her out of this debt hole to get back to work.
Read 6 tweets
21 Oct 21
This (and the rest of the thread) is a point I see brought up very often (because it is plainly true and basically impossible not to observe), but I feel like people (as I'm seeing in the comments of this thread) really drop the ball on where all this externalized self-loathing
comes from.

Way too often, people look at these pathetic wretches and go, "ah, I know why they seem to hate everything about being a woman! They're all actually trans men in denial!"

So, first of all, this is one of those things where I think we all learned the hard way that
things go really badly when you make the wild claim that all the people who hate group X are secretly members of it. This happened with being gay for a good long while, and it lead to a lot of "allies" making shitty gay jokes about right-wing lawmakers and religious cranks, and
Read 21 tweets
20 Oct 21
So I think I've touched on this a bit, but the attack being made fun of here is actually a bit scary in just how baseless it is.

The degree to which extreme bigots, and I always hate to use this phrase, control the media narrative on trans people is such that not only does their
hatemongering go completely unchecked, their straw men get to speak on behalf of all trans people.

The narrative being pushed here, which based on celebrity reactions is a pretty good recruitment tool, is that trans women are out in force trying to compel everyone to never use
the word "woman" again.

As people keep pointing out, that's completely ridiculous, clearly not happening, not something we'd be in a position to do, something that in fact goes very much against our collective interests, and is of course projection, because this is a hate group
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(