Collingwood 🇬🇧 Profile picture
Jan 7, 2022 26 tweets 10 min read Read on X
A THREAD about the #Hypernormalisation of Britain.

In his 2016 documentary film, HyperNormalisation, Adam Curtis explains that by the 1980s, Soviet leaders had realised that their vision for a socialist society had failed. They could not predict accurately and could not...1/n
...micromanage everything. However, they were so involved the system they had built that they could not think of any alternatives. So instead, they pretended that things were getting better as they traveled along the road to a socialist utopia. Aleksi Yurchak...2/n
...the Leningrad-born professor of anthropology at Berkeley, explained what it was like to live through this period in his book, 'Everything Was Forever, Until It Was No More: The Last Soviet Generation'. He wrote that the citizenry knew the leaders were lying; however, the...3/n
...people were themselves trapped in the system, and were therefore unable to imagine anything better. So they pretended to believe the pretending politicians. Society became fake, and Yurchak called this pretence 'HyperNormalisation'. In Britain today, we also know that...4/n
...something isn't right with everything. This feeling was probably sparked in the mid-2000s, when it became clear that our leaders had dragged the country into a bloody war in Iraq on a lie. Shortly after, the global financial system collapsed. Nation states saved the...5/n
...world economy from collapse by pumping vast sums of money into the banking system to repair their ruined balance sheets. Nobody went to jail for this potentially world-shattering catastrophe, just as nobody was punished for Iraq. And those reforms that were undertaken...6/n
...trimmed around the edges rather than questioning the assumptions upon which the systems were built. And then, George Osbourne and David Cameron imposed austerity on Britain, which they said was necessary to maintain the confidence of the markets. Nobody in power...7/n
...bothered to ask whether *we* should still have confidence in the *markets* -- a question every man and woman on the street was asking. It was as though, faced with two calamitous events that made it obvious that their understanding of reality was wrong, the politicians...8/n
...the media, the civil service, the financiers and the think tanks, simply ignored them and continued, like the Soviet Leaders, as though everything was fine. Now, we see such events everywhere and all the time. Nobody, left or right, thinks the government got...9/n
...its response to the pandemic right. It was clear that they were bumbling and bluffing the whole way. The migrant crisis on the South Coast continues even as the head of Border Force says he hates borders. Grooming gangs, which rape and press into sex slavery our...10/n
...most vulnerable daughters, remain at large in our cities. Drugtaking has reached epidemic levels, with the relatively tiny number of prosecutions making little difference. Knife crime and gang culture menaces the law abiding and wastes the potential...11/n
...of countless young men from poor backgrounds. Homelessness can be seen everywhere, and our country has recently been rocked by two child murders. Our leaders seem not only powerless to deal with any of this, but oblivious to it all. Yet, these are mere events. What most...12/n
...of us realise is that our whole structure of national management is broken. Our standard of living is only maintained by the acceptance of ever-greater levels of debt (state and personal). Even then, young middle class people find themselves unable to afford to buy a...13/n
...home, and as prices rise, it dawns on them that they are unlikely to be ever able to afford one. The working class shouldn't even bother dreaming. Our industry, which once provided decent, productive jobs, has disappeared. So much so that we cannot even manufacture...14/n
...PPE or glass vials for vaccines anymore. The British concept of 'fairness' has been replaced (in law) with the alien notion of 'equality', which itself moves toward 'equity', and has manifestly unfair, strange and damaging effects throughout society and its organisation. 15/n
Our education and training system is failing to the extent that universities must be forced to accept state school leavers for undergraduate degrees, and that we are reliant on foreigners to do basic skilled jobs like plumbing, building, HGV driving and even waiting tables...16/n
Children are considerably more likely to have a TV in their bedrooms than a father in the house. 50% of marriages are likely to end in divorce. And yet we know that being raised by two parents is a key metric for childhood, and thence adult, outcomes. Meanwhile, 50 years...17/n
...ago, being wealthy meant a bigger house, a fancier car and a holiday to a more distant destination. Now, it means living in a completely different world, detached from the existence of the rest of us. The response of our political parties has been Hypernormal. The...18/n
...mainstream left has made a weird and unholy alliance with big business and the holders of capital -- first, to encourage the type of individualism and self expression (diversity) that precludes the class solidarity needed for change; secondly, to encourage the...19/n
...importation of cheap migrant labour to hold down wages; and thirdly, to encourage Californian megacorporations to take increasing control over our political discourse. The mainstream right's response has been equally Hypernormal. Their argument for leaving the deepest...20/n
...and most successful free trade bloc in the world seems to have been that it would allow us to do more free trade. It has no concept that people voted for #Brexit (and them) because of the excesses of free trade and free movement of capital. It wails about the effects...21/n
...of 'diversity', and yet it shows no sign, with an 80-seat majority, of taking on the Blair-era Human Rights Act and Equality Act that make reform in this direction near impossible. It talks about family values, but further weakens marriage through legislation. It offers...22/n
...fighting talk on open borders, but takes none of the steps needed to stem the flow on the South Coast. Both main parties are just moving ahead as normal. No matter what they say, their actions are in fact those of people who believe the system should continue as it is...23/n
And We The People are so caught up in this system that despite seeing with our own eyes that something is wrong everywhere, we keep voting for the same outcome. We fear what might happen if we don't (the other side will get in) and lack the imagination to see an alternative. 24/n
But to paraphrase Aleksi Yurchak, Hypernormalisation is forever until it is no more. If we don't ourselves create a decent alternative soon, somebody charismatic well arrive and tell us a seductive story of a great future. But it won't be liberal, conservative, democratic or free
This thread is being widely shared again, so I thought I'd point you all to an excellent short film adaptation the talented @essdeewickett made of it. I was delighted with the result, and I think it's worth watching. Like and share to help Mr Wickett.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Collingwood 🇬🇧

Collingwood 🇬🇧 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @admcollingwood

Jul 8
This is a fascinating short thread that is instructive. Read it first. Essentially it argues that for many years politicians have prioritised economic growth on the assumption that that's what voters want, when this proposition isn't clear at all.

A thread in reply.

1/n
Mr Davies says he now believes that many people prioritise things other than economic growth; for example, on the left, equality, and on the right tradition and ethnic homogeneity. I think this is right, but it might be less apparent if there *was* economic growth. Since...

2/n
...the Global Financial Crisis (almost 16 years ago!), UK GDP growth has locked into a much slower trend. 1.2% seems to qualify as high growth. Further, GDP per capita seems to have almost flatlined (see chart), while sovereign, corporate and household debt has surged in...

3/n Image
Read 11 tweets
Jul 5
UNPOPULAR HOT TAKE (but I don't care, because now is the time social conservatives must speak the truth). Those decrying sectarianism in politics must think harder. What did we expect? That we could dump the world's cultures in forgotten and dilapidated council estates...

1/n
...and towns in large numbers, and produce by unknown magic Liberal Consumer Britons? That we could hand out passports as though they were pizza delivery menus and yet deprive these people of their say at the ballot box? That we could espouse the sort of liberal...

2/n
...individualism that precludes the solidarity needed to affect change, yet complain when Muslim citizens use the solidarity they have been encouraged to maintain (absent much sense of Britishness), to organise, work and campaign for their causes? That our elites could...

3/n
Read 10 tweets
Jul 1
In four days, we will likely wake to a new government. Recently, I wrote a semi-viral thread about the way Labour would govern. But what next for the Tories? And how will all this affect our politics & society? More badly than you think. This is a thread about THE DAY AFTER.

1/n
At first, whatever you think of their programme or their politics (and I am more concerned than most), Labour will be popular. All new governments enjoy a honeymoon period (even May got a short one), and the media and Civil Service will be delighted they're in power.

2/n
This means that scandals will stay covered rather than gleefully exposed; the Civil Service will cooperate rather than impede; and the media will report kindly on Labour's governance at first. Lee Cain, formerly of Vote Leave and Boris Johnson's Number 10 team, said in a...

3/n
Read 35 tweets
Jun 18
In November, long before #zeroseats, even as the media was reporting politics as usual, I wrote a thread on why the Tories were heading for an epochal defeat. Now that this is received wisdom, it's time for a new thread, forecasting how Labour will govern. Be very afraid.

1/n
The first thing to understand is that there is very little room for a stereotypical Labour spending splurge. In fact, it's more likely that @RachelReevesMP will have to engage in serious austerity. Sovereign debt is near 100% of GDP, and the 2023/24 fiscal deficit was 4.4%.

2/n
Image
Image
The Institute of Fiscal Studies recently reported that the fiscal outlook was the worst in 70 years. It said it would be "miraculously lucky" if growth bounced enough to save the Treasury, leaving three options: (i) cut spending; (ii) raise taxes; (iii) borrow even more.

3/n
Image
Image
Read 43 tweets
Jun 4
This is the problem. A sizable number of Tory MPs think that the whole 'culture war' is made up by the 'far right' (rather than a reaction of the average person to the excesses of the progressive-left after they *won* the culture war and consolidated their grip over every...

1/n
...node of power in the UK). This group of Tories (who have mostly accepted cultural defeat or were born into the post-defeat world and therefore know nothing different) cannot grasp why the 'Conservative' Party should be involved. I am sad to tell you that this faction...

2/n
...is *the most powerful faction within the Conservative Party*. After the election, it is they who will be favourites to win the inevitable power struggle for control of the Tory carcass -- supported as they will be by most of the legacy media and the Tory establishment...

3/n
Read 5 tweets
Jun 3
I'm unsure @montie has thought this through. The party dumped Feckless Boris for Liz Truss, a destructive fool. Desperate after the mess she made, it was forced into a stitch up to bring in Rishi. Voters would have rightly seen a third defenestration for a third unelected PM...
...as a democratic affront and, worse, a sign that it was amateur hour within the Tory Party. Further, there was *no* consensus candidate behind which the party could have swung, which would have necessitated another full blown leadership contest. Imagine the disgust of the...
...electorate as the Party played games while the country was crushed by economic stagnation and a cost of living crisis. Imagine the hay Starmer would have made. Finally, the favourite in such a contest would have been Penny Mordaunt, whose dyed-in-the-wool, Blairite social...
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(