This is my best effort at summarizing the opposition to the "Vaxxed and Done" philosophy.
Any attempt to summarize a viewpoint you don't entirely agree with is a risky thing.
But the purpose of this piece is neither to endorse nor explode the Vaxxed and Done ideology, but to recognize its emergence as a really important phenomenon.
I think there would be more room for a larger third category—"Vaxxed and Cautious Until Omicron Burns Through and Then Prepared to Be Done"—that would be larger if more people had confidence that many COVID precautions (eg in schools) weren't de facto indefinite.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Four big ideas from the global evidence: 1. It's milder (different than "mild"). 2. It's fast. 3. It's a big problem for the unvaccinated + hospital systems. 4. It's worse in the US.
1. It's milder (different than "mild")
The virus's upper-respiratory replication combined with immunity from vaccines and natural infection seem to be responsible for the global evidence of a divergence between case growth and deaths.
An argument I see a lot on here: ~Web3's problems are the same ones email and mobile Internet had, which means Web3 *is* the next mobile Internet!~
No. Just bc two things share the same failures doesn't mean they'll follow the same success path.
It's "analogy by failure."
"Analogy by failure" in Web3 debates doesn't prove Web3 will fail. It doesn't prove anything. It's just a fallacy.
If I tape dung to a cup and say it's a radio, that's a failure too. I can say "you idiots, email also failed once" but that doesn't change that it's cup-dung.
It's really the proving too much fallacy, but I've found pitiful engagement on citations of PTM, and I think we should just rename it for the Internet something more intuitive, since "My thing is failing in all most auspicious ways" is the way this argument typically appears.
Feat.:
- supersonic travel
- carbon removal
- SpaceX's big fat cheap rocket
- the first cancer vaccines
- flying cars
- unraveling the mystery of proteins!
It’s impossible to ignore the fact that the Omicron wave—and the reactions to Omicron from officials—has emboldened a group of Americans who were never really Anti-Vax but are now very, very Vaxxed And Done With All Of This.
It’s not like the Vaxxed And Dones were born yesterday. This group has simmered, flared, maybe tipped the VA election.
But I’m getting the sense that Omicron is going to be an inflection point in ppl demanding an overturning of COVID coverage, attitudes, and policy.
I’m not sure I’d count myself among the Vaxxed and Done. But I’m not trying to endorse or criticize their position here.
My larger point is the Omicron wave seems to be deepening a wedge within the pro-vax (and largely Democratic) cohort, and that’s interesting and important.