Candidates for #NEET #MDS approach #SupremeCourt urging the seats allocated to them in Karnataka be recognised as valid. They contend that they are victim of circumstances and that Karnataka was responsible to issue the counselling schedule within the #DCI’s stipulated timeline. 
Sr Adv Shyam Divan: I think the ASG is supposed to respond.
ASG Nataraj: The govt considered this but rejected. It will not be possible to make fresh admissions. Many MDS seats are lying empty through the country, if one request is entertained it will open a floodgate.
ASG Nataraj: The govt considered this but rejected. It will not be possible to make fresh admissions. Many MDS seats are lying empty through the country, if one request is entertained it will open a floodgate.
SC: What if state govt has alloted seats in Dec?
ASG: That the state govt has to deal.
It is a very dangerous trend that institutions are coming under A32 which is not available to them.
Adv Gaurav Sharma(DCI): The prayer is not to regularise those after cut of date.
ASG: That the state govt has to deal.
It is a very dangerous trend that institutions are coming under A32 which is not available to them.
Adv Gaurav Sharma(DCI): The prayer is not to regularise those after cut of date.
Dr Charu Mathur: We are for students, we've filed impleadment application.
SC: We are not entertaining the petition under 32. Let the state engage with centre.
Divan: It's a catch-22 situation. GOI and DCI has said. SC said that they are hard rules
SC: Let the state work out..
SC: We are not entertaining the petition under 32. Let the state engage with centre.
Divan: It's a catch-22 situation. GOI and DCI has said. SC said that they are hard rules
SC: Let the state work out..
SC: the equities because the state had made the admissions.
Divan: If you could have a look at this note. There is only one govt dental college-15 seats in Karnataka and 34 pvt colleges.
643 seats were allotted by Dec 2021.
I've given you individual breakup.
Divan: If you could have a look at this note. There is only one govt dental college-15 seats in Karnataka and 34 pvt colleges.
643 seats were allotted by Dec 2021.
I've given you individual breakup.
Divan: See Regulation 9(3)- counselling to all dental colleges...shall be conducted by the state or UT govt.
There is nothing the colleges can do. The entire responsibility is of the state govt.There is a series of communication by is pointing out that date is quickly approaching
There is nothing the colleges can do. The entire responsibility is of the state govt.There is a series of communication by is pointing out that date is quickly approaching
Divan: You can have a certain quibble about seat matrix. But after NEET common exam and counselling centralised, there is no option.
SC: We are not closing the door. We'll record our previous order. We'll say we're not inclined to entertain petitions by the institutions.
SC: We are not closing the door. We'll record our previous order. We'll say we're not inclined to entertain petitions by the institutions.
Divan: They are self financed institutions that are running. They'll have empty seats for three years. State govt slacked despite knowing the deadlines. Please use your discretion and extend. If you do that GOI will consider and do extra classes and all.
AAG Nikhil Goel, Karnataka: I don't want to go into allegations made against the state without a reply. It's not as simple to say fix everything to the state.
The date itself was extended till 20/11/21. That's when classes started. It was not in October as stated.
The date itself was extended till 20/11/21. That's when classes started. It was not in October as stated.
AAG: This is not a scenario, 21/12/21 the centre rejected our request. To say that admitted students maybe regularised
SC: Why did you not challenge GOI rejecting your application?
AAG: Technical issues, there were vacations and-
SC: What is this Mr Goel?
SC: Why did you not challenge GOI rejecting your application?
AAG: Technical issues, there were vacations and-
SC: What is this Mr Goel?
SC: You file an affidavit here and tell us what happened. How many applications?
AAG: 633
SC: 633 will be left hanging.
We want the Secy of Health Dept in Karnataka to file an affidavit. We want to know why is the state govt doing this?
AAG: 633
SC: 633 will be left hanging.
We want the Secy of Health Dept in Karnataka to file an affidavit. We want to know why is the state govt doing this?
Adv Gaurav Sharma: The state govt didn't even bother to show. Someone has to be held responsible for not having the counselling on time.
SC: In the order of this court dated 3/1/22, this court has noted that though the deadline for completing admissions for MDS for 2022 courses was extended from 10 to 20 November by UOI. Karnataka carried out first round of counselling from 4-18 December and 2nd round from 18-21.
SC: Mr Shyam Divan submitted that state was responsible for carrying out counselling. It was the state that delayed counselling beyond the date given by Union govt. 633 students have been admitted by Karnataka albeit beyond the cut off date. If they arent regularised, Karnataka
SC: colleges won't have students for three years.
ASG and Adv Sharma submitted that Karnataka was aware of the deadline.
AAG Goel said that application for extention of time was rejected by UOI.
We direct the P. Secy in Ministry of Health to find affidavit explaining how
ASG and Adv Sharma submitted that Karnataka was aware of the deadline.
AAG Goel said that application for extention of time was rejected by UOI.
We direct the P. Secy in Ministry of Health to find affidavit explaining how
SC: Karnataka failed to meet the 21 December deadline.
We'll keep it for next Friday.
Dr Charu Mathur: I had filed an IA.
SC: The matter has seized now. Next friday.
We'll keep it for next Friday.
Dr Charu Mathur: I had filed an IA.
SC: The matter has seized now. Next friday.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
