The most common problem faced by day-traders and it's easy solution which is extremely difficult to implement.
A thread.
( uses concepts I have discussed many times before in separate threads)
Problem : I have a good system, I understand charts and/or price action, but I simply can't make money. I hold my losses too long or ( this is most common) I get out of profitable positions too fast and cannot sit for the whole move
At many firms at NASDAQ, day-traders are seen as elite sportspersons playing in a difficult taxing game. That's why, they have regular sessions with sports psychologists. They are advised to follow the basic routine of sportspersons.
Train ---- Play tournaments --- Rest
The cycle repeats
We retail day-traders here neither rest nor train.
Rest = taking time off markets
Train = trading in markets in training mode
Understanding REST is easy, simply take time off markets and spend time with family or do something you love
But what about training ?
Paper trading or trading on a simulator is never good training as it never gives you the same psychological issue while actual trading. Deep down you know this is fake, you are not making or losing actual money
As you are never making or losing money, you will not be able to be in the same psychological state / pressure which comes in actual trading. Your decisions while paper trading or simulated trading will be vastly superior or actual trading
The solution:
Trade 1 lot ( I am speaking about intraday options trading, cash traders can do this with a simple share of any stock) following your system/process for one month. This sounds easy, right?
Try implementing this, you will understand the massive psychological discipline and strength it requires. Majority fail to do this over a month and go back trading their normal volumes and thus face the same issues all over again
If you are in a trading slump for long and aim to claw back, give yourself 3 months.
First month = 1 lot
2nd month = 2 lots
3rd month = 4 lots
4th month = follow money mgmt/position sizing with a small bet per trade
I have used this "one lot" rule twice in my trading career to resolve my psychological issues while trading. In my time on twitter, have advised this method to probably hundreds and thousands of traders over the past few years.
So far, very few traders ( around 5 or 6) have followed this method diligently as I have outlined and come back to me with the results. Not surprisingly, all of them were profitable to various degrees
There is no short-cut solution is you are facing the same problem. No guru, no webinar/seminar/handholding/setup/system will be able to solve this issue.
As one of my students rightly said " when we go to a gym, the trainer can show us all the moves. But it's us who have to appear at the gym everyday and do the exercises if we have to improve our body"
Same with trading. Best of luck ! 🙏
Anthony Saliba, the only options trader to be interviewed in the first Market Wizards book was the original one lot trader. Indian fintwit has nicknamed me also as one lot, what a great title ! Thanks
BNF showing long liquidation while NF showing long buildup. In my experience, whenever the two indices shows divergent behavior, it's very difficult to cleanly trade the indices. We are probably starting a time-price correction
Traders will do best if they let this scenario resolve over the next few days before trying to trade the next trend move. Everyone makes money in a trending move but majority give back during this congested times. So, I will stand aside and give time to markets .
Some excellent responses to this thread on how people manage risk. Let me outline my process. I will write it step by step, break it down and explain my logic. Not necessarily these are iron rules, feel free to understand and then add/modify what suits you.
So let's repeat the scenario again. You are with an overnight position, the market opens huge against you ( long or short does not matter). What do you do then?
Step 1 : start the relaxation technique as outlined in earlier thread.
Now these are your choices : 1. Double the position, averaging with hope that a slight favourable move will reduce your losses 2. Totally reverse the position, say from long to short 3. Cut the full position 4. Cut half ( "when in doubt, cut half position ") 5. Keep holding
Grab a cup of coffee and read on, I hope this will be a very interesting topic to discuss.
What do you do when you have a position over night and the market gaps significantly against you?
( you are looking at significant M2M loss)
I have faced this scenario quite a few times in my life, which is normal when you are in the markets for 20 years. 😃 When this happens, this is what I felt : 1. Heart starts racing ( your heart beat actually increases) 2. Body tenses up 3. You start breathing fast
There is a physiological explanation for this. Humans are genetically programmed to get into fight or flight mode when in danger.
More here : health.harvard.edu/staying-health…
Had a M2M loss of around 4.75 lacs( large positions in TaMo and ITC). As usual BNF came to the rescue and losses got covered. Now much more managable. Might even close for the day, a bullet dodged
I don't show my positive M2M as a policy. Shared this just to show that even with the best analysis, one may get trapped and lose. Important is to keep losses in control
Oh, some in TaMo PE too. Sqed off the backspread when I gave on twitter, at 474. Bought 490PE naked , that also worked out