Thread: The article and its headline claims that anti-Asian hate crimes in the US are "fueled by misinformation"...a bizarre way to explain racist hate crimes...and the claim lacks evidence in the article. edition.cnn.com/2022/01/29/us/…
For instance the article notes several attacks but doesn't provide evidence the perpetrators had read any "misinformation"...more likely the attacks were motivated purely by hate and the privilege that these perpetrators have in thinking they can attack one community.
One thing the article, which discusses New York a lot, doesn't ask is the identity of the perpetrators. And that might reveal something that we don't want to ask about, sort of like we don't want to ask about antisemitic attacks. Because it may not be just a simple story.
It's easier to put this up to "Covid misinformation"...without doing a survey or interviews with the perpetrators. Is it really because they listened to a podcast or read something online and then push a woman into an oncoming train? Or is there more going on here,outright racism
We live in an era where we want simple stories about racism, for instance defining racism as only being by one group against another...we don't want to see the elephant of racism in the room and attacks on minority groups by other minorities, for instance. .
So there are rising anti-Asian violent attacks, like violent anti-semitic attacks...and to put it down to "misinformation" fueling it...I think is highly doubtful. I think we have a lot of racist hate that becomes violent due to privilege...the privilege that was given to haters.
We have instances in NY where there are violent hate crimes and attacks and the perpetrators aren't prosecuted or immediately get released. That is privilege. And it's not "misinformation" that drives this...it's the feeling some have that they can "randomly" attack people.
The assertion that if we just give the violent folk some "good information" then they won't randomly attack people, push people into trains, bash them while they leave their house, attack their small businesses...shout at them...come on....let's be honest...
The idea that if we just say "hey, you got bad information...before you push a person in front of a train, can I share a better podcast about Covid with you"...that's not what is going on. It's about racist violence...and a violent society driving this, impunity and privilege
Are the rising attacks driven in part by the pandemic...yes maybe...but it's the violence you have to focus on. People don't get misinformation and become violent...they are already violent and they feel impunity to use violence. That's what has happened.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Thread/I am open to the theory that Ankara and Israel might indeed try limited reconciliation.
What I think is an enduring myth is that Israel and Turkey will cooperate against Iran...because I believe Ankara works with Iran.
The reason for Turkey-Israel reconciliation has to do with other things, I mean why not try it again...but the idea that some of the Iran hawks have that the US, Israel, Turkey or whatever will work 'against' Iran is a huge nonsense. There is no such thing.
Turkey does not want to be dragged into some kind of tensions with Iran. Why would it? Turkey gains nothing by heating up tensions with Iran. We heard this nonsense during the Trump era as a reason to support Ankara's operations in Syria...that one day it will confront Iran.
This is shocking...Some of Ankara's media was antisemitic and the leadership knew this...and for years did nothing. Now trying to push for Israel president's visit, the leadership is like "ok, let's stop the antisemitism for a few weeks"...call Israel "Israel"...amazing truth out
Imagine if you'd heard about a country that was openly pushing anti-Black racist articles and then to prepare for Barack Obama's visit was like "Ok let's stop the racism"...you'd be shocked by this admission the government controls the racist narrative and can stop/start it...
Literally there was an Ankara regime that controls the media that can turn off and turn on the antisemitism at a whim...the media in Ankara didn't feel any embarassment about pushing antisemitic stories...it had to be told by the government to stop...
I don't understand the critique of my critique of those who support Turkey-Israel reconciliation. The assertion is that one article at Daily Sabah was slightly critical of Iran for some minor gas issue...and therefore I'm wrong to assert that Ankara gets along with Iran...
Second the assertion is that the UAE has done outreach to Iran...so therefore my observation that Ankara gets along with Tehran is sort of like saying "so what, the UAE also talks to Tehran"...
Let's address this piece by piece. 1. There is NO evidence that Ankara has bad relations with Tehran. Consider all the high level meetings and declarations and lack of critical coverage in pro-government media. A few small "bumps" in the relationship is not evidence of break
🧵 The criticism of the Abraham Accords talking point about “autocracy” or “dictators” is ridiculous. The Iran Deal was signed with a dictatorial regime…are we now to argue the US shouldn’t negotiate with Iran because it’s not signed with the average people?
The ONLY situation in the Middle East or globally where a peace or normalization process is criticized is when it comes to Israel…with the misleading talking point that “dictators” or “autocrats” can’t make peace…
YET EVERY OTHER country in the world has relations with autocrats in the region…literally EVERY country has relations with the UAE, Qatar, Egypt, Saudi, etc…and no one says “well you shouldn’t have relations, they are autocracies”….literally NO ONE argues this with Qatar
Let's note that Ankara announcing Israel's president would visit Turkey was PURPOSELY done by Ankara to embarrass Israel as Israel's president was preparing the trip to the UAE. It was trying to force Israel's hand. It wasn't coordinated with Israel, it was designed to harm.
Every step of the way Ankara uses fake "reconciliation" as a way to harm Israel...when it heard the US was against the East Med pipeline, it celebrated and trotted out 'reconciliation'...last year it detained Israeli tourists and talked 'reconciliation'
Ankara's "reconciliation" narrative is always under the guise of anti-Israel actions. It even tried to send an envoy to Israel who was openly anti-Israel...at every juncture it uses reconciliation to try to harm Israel and Israel ties with Greece, UAE etc.