Don't compare Trudeau with Putin...or either with Hitler.
Those are silly comparisons.
Trudeau is a run-of-the-mill progressive who thinks the power of the state is bad...unless HE is in power.
Putin is a thug and dictator.
Hitler...is Hitler.
Trudeau is harder to define and attack because of that nuance. I bet if he wasn't in power, he'd oppose some of the measures he is now using...especially if the partisan leanings were flipped.
This ultimately gets down to the question is how much free expression are we going to guarantee?
Clearly violent protests should be shut down quickly; that is the lesson 2020. We delayed acting because of fear of overreacting, and were worse off for it.
The Canadian event is FAR worse. I agree that people should not be able to block off any public area. I think its a crime. I think the police have the power to act in that regard.
But the Canadians have overreacted.
The fact they are now saying ANYONE whose face they can identify at the protest can see their bank accounts frozen, etc? That is LUDICROIUS. That is basically the elimination of all due process.
It also goes to the point that free speech is connected to money, ALWAYS.
Citizens United largely got it right.
If you have a govt that can punish you by taking all your assets, without due process, simply because of your political view?
You do not have the right to free speech.
So Canada has significantly fallen backward on the simples of liberal rights, as understood by the Western Democracies. The convoy should have been shut down, but the actions of Trudeau have been incompetent and over bounds in a free society.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
New York City parents pulling their children from public schools in record numbers hotair.com/jazz-shaw/2022…
These numbers are NOT BLIPS:
"Manhattan’s District 2...down 17% from two years ago. They lost 2,500 of 16,400 kids. Brooklyn’s District 15 (in AOC’s home turf) dropped 16%. Enrollment at Chelsea’s PS 11 fell by 170 students, a plunge of 17%. Other examples abound."
Lets note that voucher opponents have long made the argument that losing 10% of students to private schools would be devastating to public schools.
Well...if you believe their rhetoric...then these schools are doomed. Right?
Lets also note that there is no vaccine mandate here.
This is simply a health care system focused on evidence based results, and providing the vaccine as quickly and easily as possible...and a public that trusts them enough to take the shot.
Trudeau et al are exceptionally stupid. They knew the convoy was coming long before it showed up.
Even after they got to Ottawa, they could have physically removed them. It would not have been painless, but it would've been defensible.
Their actions now are not defensible.
Lot of Americans may not realize this...but public sentiment of Canadians are with Trudeau. Even the majority of truckers support shutting down the convoys.
But somehow, someway, Trudeau is still losing the fight.
If the government can shut down your income, your banks, your saved wealth, and financial assistance because the politicians don't support your message...you don't really have free speech.
You just have the mirage of it.
Free speech means you defend SPEECH YOU DON'T LIKE.
Again, this is all so stupid.
If Canada wants to remove the truckers, forcibly...remove them. They absolutely have the legal right to do so.
They simply are too cowardly to pay the 'political costs' involved.
"The Emergencies Act outlines four different types of emergencies: public welfare emergencies, public order emergencies, international emergencies and war emergencies. If the legislation is invoked this week, it will likely be under the 'public order' category."
"Again, the criteria here is strict - lawful protests do not qualify.
Instead, the situation must be considered a threat to the security of Canada, as defined by the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act."
Mandates made sense when: 1. Vaccines obviously save lives, which is still true today. 2. Vaccines virtually stopped transmission...WHICH IS NOT TRUE TODAY.
Point #2 really is important, and Fauci/Walensky don't want to answer it.
Lets stipulate point #1. There is no question that vaccines save lives, and everyone should choose to get vaccinated for their own sake.
Agreed?
Here is the problem: the real benefit of mandates, as stated by Biden himself, is to protect SOCIETY.
But in the age of Omicron, that isn't really the major benefit of vaccines. Vaccinated individuals were only marginally less likely to get infected and transmit the virus.