🧵Thoughts from Kyiv -afternoon Feb 28
From Mychailo Winnyckyj, 🇨🇦-🇺🇦Acadamic, Kyiv Mohila Academia
1. Much going on at the moment:
- residential districts of Kharkiv and Chernihiv under Grad attack
2. - significant areas of southern Ukraine occupied by Russians, but local residents continue resistance and civil disobedience
- Kyiv is defiant and (in my opinion) invincible.
3. The above conditions make the peace talks launched today in Belarus highly problematic. The Russian delegation will try to gain concessions (or even capitulation) from the Ukrainian side. The Ukrainians will tell the "Russian ship" exactly where to go.
4. Even if a cease fire is agreed, there is no chance that it will hold. Putin will continue to escalate.
5. Given the nuclear threat voiced by the 🇷🇺 president yesterday, escalation is scary not just for Ukraine, but for the world. Hopes for a Kremlin coup or mass demonstrations in Moscow (in my opinion) are just that-hopes. War is going to get much worse before it gets any better
6. As to the eventual outcome for Ukraine, I remain highly optimistic. I simply cannot imagine Ukrainians agreeing to Russian occupation, and so even if the country is overrun by tanks and equipment, and.....
7. ....even if supply lines are cut, the Russians will be faced with an unprecedented insurgency that will have the support of the entire civilized world. We will win this war! The question now is, how many lives will be lost in the process?
8. The sad part of this story is that Putin started this war because he genuinely came to believe his own propaganda. While the West believed Russia could be deterred with sanctions or that the discourse on NATO and geopolitics was genuine, Putin was always very candid.
9. He stated outright that in his mind Ukraine is an artificial country with no separate national identity and no right to exist. Now ordinary Russian soldiers and valiant Ukrainian defenders (i.e. the entire population) are paying the ultimate price.
10. According to the latest poll approval ratings for President Zelensky have sky-rocketed above 90%. Meanwhile the Russian rouble has become junk currency, and even Switzerland (!) has declared that it cannot remain neutral in this conflict.
11. The Kremlin's initial overconfidence and total miscalculations have now become public. The state-owned RIA-Novosti website mistakenly published an article at 8:00 am on Feb 26 proclaiming Russia's victory over Ukraine (2 days after the start of invasion).
12. Its author Pyotr Akopov proclaimed the establishment of a "new world" and the "final solution of the Ukrainian question" (echoing another "final solution" author). Article was immediately deleted after publication, but saved by Google cache (link below)
13. Obviously Putin was not expecting the Ukrainians to resist. Indeed, reports of Russian troops currently on Ukrainian territory being surprised that they are not being met with open-arms are commonplace.
14. They too believed the official Kremlin propaganda that Ukrainians seek liberation by Russia. That said, it may not stop them in the short term.
15. As the excellent operational publications by military analyst Tom Cooper show (please follow him on FB - don't request friendship unless you know him personally), the Russians may not be advancing as fast as they had planned, but they are nevertheless advancing.
16. The strategic plan seems to be to isolate Ukraine's main fighting force on the left (eastern) bank of the Dnipro river. Key strategic targets for this to happen are Dnipro, Zaporizhzhia and Cherkasy.
17. This means the advance on Kyiv may in fact slow during the coming days. Russian forces are massing on the territory that they have already wedged into from the north in preparation for a final push on the capital, but that may not happen before the south is fully secured.
18. Obviously, the Russians will be met with fierce resistance in Kyiv from both the Armed Forces and civilians. I cannot imagine any other way for them to control Kyiv than mass genocide of the city's population.
19. The primary and immediate threat to Ukraine (and to the world!) continues to come from the air: Iskander and Buratino missiles and aerial bombardment.
20. Apparently a no-fly zone is seriously being considered in western capitals, but if it only covers right-bank Ukraine (west of the Dnipro), that will be a sell-out. Please continue the pressure on your governments dear friends!
#Ukrainians deserve a #noflyzoneoverUkraine
21. Here the link: Kremlin's plan for "Final Solution" in Ukraine. Jewish, Roma and others will recognise that solution. web.archive.org/.../20220226/r…
English Translation of above 👆 in Ukrainehttps://mil.in.ua/en/news/brave-new-world-of-putin-an-article-by-the-propaganda-publication-ria-novosti-which-was-to-be-published-after-the-occupation-of-ukraine/?fbclid=IwAR2WZjExJLp6yPloHbRxROZmAfJJpmo042URHjRm6zghMaNtCOks9hLOlN8

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tamara Krawchenko

Tamara Krawchenko Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @T_Krawchenko

Mar 2
🧵1. Who am I? I am Ukrainian Canadian. I have Scottish hair from my mum and high cheekbones from my Tato. My family's history is one of oppression--from the Tsar to Soviets, Nazis and Fascist Russia today.
2. My father just sent me the letters that were saved from when his father and their family were ripped from their home in Ivanivka and shipped to northern Siberia - to a work camp, to die.
3. My great Uncle Vasyl Krawvchenko wrote a poem for his mother on the date of that eviction: March 5 1930. This is for her memory.
Read 13 tweets
Feb 28
🧵Update from Professor Mychailo Wynnyckyj, Kyiv Mohilo Academia.
Thoughts from Kyiv - evening Feb 28

1.Air raid warning means time to think and write in the basement. Family is safe. Planes flying overhead but no explosions nearby.
2. Two valuational/behavioral contrasts that strike me as worthy of analysis in this war:
hierarchy vs. heterarchy (spontaneous teams)
passivity vs. agency (collective and personal)
3. When Russian soldiers entered Ukraine (and as they continue to invade) they were following orders. The hierarchy told them to move in, so they moved. That's the way things work in an army
Read 17 tweets
Feb 27
🧵Thoughts from Kyiv - afternoon 27 February
From Mychailo Winnyckyj, 🇨🇦-🇺🇦Acadamic, Kyiv Mohila Academia
1. Kyiv survived another night. The Russian invaders continue their forward movement from the north, but their reconnaissance groups are being stamped out like cockroaches.
2. Civillians are stopping the advance of tanks and armored vehicles with their bare hands. The heroism and valour of ordinary Ukrainians is both moving and nothing less than amazing.
3. Russian losses are mounting. At 9am the Deputy Minister of Defence reported over 4200 KIA and wounded, 27 downed jets, 26 helicopters, 146 destroyed tanks and 706 armored vehicles. The list of losses goes on.
Read 14 tweets
Feb 26
🧵Thoughts from Kyiv - afternoon Feb 26.
From Mychailo Wynnyckyj, Kyiv-Mohyla Academy

1. According to unconfirmed reports, Putin was handed a report of Russian losses this morning that showed 3471 dead. This number matches official reports from the Ukrainian Ministry of Defense
2. They have also counted over 100 destroyed enemy tanks, over 500 armored vehicles, 14 Russian fighter jets, 8 helicopters. Ukrainian losses are 20-25% of those of the invader.
3. Obviously, the Russian advance is not going well. According to western intelligence, the Kremlin had planned to topple Ukraine’s duly elected government by now, and Russian television was supposed to be showing Ukrainians welcoming their “liberators” with flowers on Sunday.
Read 17 tweets
Feb 26
🧵Thoughts from Kyiv - 2 days after Feb 24.
From Mychailo Wynnyckyj, Kyiv-Mohyla Academy

1/ Listening to analysts from the West, one gets the impression that Ukraine's fate was sealed the moment Putin attacked on 3 fronts two days ago.
2/ On the other hand, reading reports from Ukraine (including from eyewitnesses and event participants), one can only conclude that Putin's planned "victorious" military escapade is turning into a complete disaster. Why the difference?
3/ As a social system Russia represents the epitomy of hierarchy, as embodied in autocracy. In this system, the voice of the individual does not matter. Soldiers are sent into battle without knowledge of
of their objectives.
Read 20 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(