Sometimes there isn't a perfect answer to your discomforts. Sometimes things don't work out how you'd hoped. That can be devastating, but it doesn't need to be life-ending. In a world that viewed TGD with respect & care, we'd have the resources, information, and support to cope.
When I decided I needed to detransition, I was shocked by the absolute lack of resources. There was little info on what I could expect. Most 'communities' were oriented around self-hatred and/or anti-trans ideologies, not support or mutual uplifting.
I decided to do it alone.
The real or perceived taboo around detransition in trans spaces made me fear rejection if I talked about it.
Detransitioning was a very lonely experience. I was the fraction of a fraction of a fraction. It sometimes felt like I was the only person in the world going thru this.
I know that's not true. I get comments & DMs of people who've gone thru de/retransition and felt the same way I did. It's comforting to know I'm not really alone, but I can't help but feel upset that others had to go through something so difficult & painful entirely on their own.
I don't talk about my detransition because I want to distract from potential benefits of transition, or to inflate the number of people who detransition. I talk about it because I don't want people to go thru this the same way I did. I don't want people to feel hopeless & alone.
I want us to have information and options available, no matter where our transitions take us. I want us to have support networks that focus on our own self-development, wellbeing, and needs, alongside other TGD people. I want us to build and fight for those things, together.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Here's what I want people to be aware of on detransition:
- Much like trans identity, the way we conceptualize our detransition and current gender varies widely from person to person. Some of us still ID as trans, NB, or some form of gender diverse. Some of us ID as our AGAB. There's no singular "detransitioner experience."
- Political/ideological detrans is only a small portion of detransitioners. Don't assume that we're all GCs or anti-trans, this can be very alienating & stigmatizing. A lot of detransitioners say they fear the reaction from trans friends if they talk about detransitioning.
There's an assumption that because I'm detrans, I must support restricting trans healthcare. This comes from both pro- and anti-trans folks.
While I understand why ppl think this, not all detrans ppl are pro-gatekeeping.
here are some things I want, as a detrans person..
- research into health post-detrans. what to expect after medical/surgical detransition, short and long-term
- legal protections & resources for TGNC ppl
- safety to talk about de/retrans experiences w/o fear of harassment, or fear that our stories will be used w/o our consent
- not feeling medical/surgical transition is necessary to be "truly trans," whether from community or medical system
- respect for transitioned bodies & TGNC identities
- accessible, affordable, and QUALITY healthcare. doctors who actually care about our wishes & wellbeing.
If we were to survey incarcerated women on the issues that concern them the most, I'm fairly confident that "trans women in female prisons" would not be very high on the list.
Incarcerated women have higher rates of mental health issues, substance abuse, unresolved trauma, history of abuse, STIs, breast and cervical cancer, preterm birth, miscarriage.. Their health is failed by the prison system.
Why are we not talking about that?
Why are we not talking about decarcerating women on drug and property crimes? Implementing family sentencing alternative programs? Prioritizing rehabilitation over punishment? Ending social benefit bans for convicted ppl?
Why are we instead obsessed with trans women in prisons?