At @PENamerica we coined the term the #EdScare to capture the unprecedented and multifaceted efforts to intimidate teachers, legislate prohibitions on classroom discussions, and ban books. Here’s what this all looks like right now in one state:
Florida.
The spotlight has rightfully been on the #DontSayGay bill and its ban on “instruction” about sexual orientation and gender identity. But the Sunshine State has become a hotbed for all kinds of education censorship. /2
First, there’s the “STOP WOKE Act” (HB 7) which has cleared the legislature and is now on its way to DeSantis’s desk. The bill will ban educators from teaching certain concepts related to race in schools & colleges. /3 floridaphoenix.com/2022/03/10/gop…
Then there’s HB 1467, also en route to DeSantis. It will increase scrutiny on ANY and ALL books in schools and give parents greater ability to contest curriculum and reading lists. It mandates a centralized list of banned books be circulated by FL DoE. /4 wtsp.com/article/news/p…
Then there’s also HB 1305, which would prohibit educators from giving ‘harmful material’ to minors and give school districts free reign to remove ‘obscene’ books. Anyone convicted for violating this bill would be guilty of a third degree felony. /5 orlandosentinel.com/politics/fl-ne…
The climate of censorship in the state is having ramifications at the ground level. Look at Jack Petocz, suspended for giving out pride flags at a school protest of the #DontSayGay bill. /6 news-journalonline.com/story/news/edu…
And just last week, the Indian River County school board banned 5 books after Moms for Liberty proposed 156 books to ban. Polk County provisionally pulled 16 books while they review them, including “Two Boys Kissing” by David Levithan. /7 abcactionnews.com/news/region-po…
Organizations like @FLFreedomRead have emerged in response to these gag orders and book bans, rallying to protect the fundamental right to read and bringing awareness to what's happening on the ground. apnews.com/article/entert…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The K-12 bill (HB1467) mandates public websites to search all books and instructional materials used in schools -- meaning: anything & everything students might see: textbooks, reading lists, manipulatives, electronic media, learning laboratories... wtsp.com/article/news/p…
But the higher ed bill (SB7044) is similar! Others have focused on how it threatens tenure & accreditation.
But it *also* directs all FL colleges & universities to create public searchable websites listing ALL instructional materials for ALL courses. 👀tampabay.com/news/education…
HB 1467 in FL now heads to DeSantis. Supporters say it "increases transparency" in the selection of books and instructional materials. But as with the whole "transparency" movement, you have to wonder what the bill ACTUALLY does... 🧵 wtsp.com/article/news/p…
The bill establishes term limits for school boards, but the real emphasis is on policies to strictly monitor access to books in schools, in curriculum, libraries, classroom libraries, heck, even on reading lists. flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2…
First it establishes that every school board must have a policy for a parent or "resident of the county" to object or contest to any book/material in a school or on a reading list. They can object to anything, based on two grounds:
If you think it's crazy to fathom educator FIRED for reading the book "I Need a New Butt" to 2nd grade kids... wait til you read about the banning of the same book, along with "Freddie the Farting Snowman" in a public library in Llano, Texas. burnetbulletin.com/news/banned-ll…
In Llano, the public library's board has also closed its meeting to the public and continued to remove books like Robie Harris's "It's Perfectly Normal". dailytrib.com/2022/03/04/lla…
You may remember Llano from the time they shut it down to review all the content of children's books in December... the result appears to have been -- shocker -- more bans kvue.com/article/news/l…
Mississippi will be the 11th state to sign an educational gag order into law, with the passage of SB 2113 by the House. Similar to a bill in Idaho, this is the 2nd state with a bill that explicitly targets academic instruction in higher education. #EdScaresupertalk.fm/anti-crt-bill-…
It reads: "No public institution of higher learning, community/junior college, school district or public school, including public charter schools, shall teach a course of instruction or unit of study that directs or otherwise compels students... legiscan.com/MS/text/SB2113…
... to personally affirm, adopt or adhere..." to certain tenets regarding race, sex, ethnicity, religion or national origin.
The bill also prohibits these institutions from making any "distinction or classification of students based on account of race." Vague what that means.
The #DontSayGay Bill in FL moves to the senate floor Monday, then likely to DeSantis. The legislation is draconian, banning conversations in schools about LGBTQ+ lives.
In TN, HB 800 is under consideration. It would outlaw school materials and textbooks that “promote, normalize, support, or address” LGBTQ issues. Even just "addressing" them! It receives another committee vote on Tuesday. /2 tennessean.com/story/opinion/…
In KS, HB2662 sounds like a pretty standard educational gag order targeting graphic content. But the bill defines “sexual conduct” as anything relating to homosexuality. "Depicting" a same-sex couple could land you in a Kansas courthouse. /3 slate.com/news-and-polit…
After a year of "review" Leander ISD in Texas has now banned 11 books from its optional book club reading lists -- and will be proceeding to ensure no student has access to them in classroom libraries. A profound shame. #FReadom
Some of these banned 11 books are still accessible in school libraries in Leander; but Machado's 'In the Dream House' and Hutchinson's 'Brave Face' are not in the library collections, so they're effectively inaccessible in the district now. docs.google.com/document/d/1UD…