I am glad Ukraine is not in that situation and that they are getting weapons and supplies to defend themselves and their people. I just wish we had the same ability. It's hard not think of how different it all could have been now that you've shown us how easy & possible it is.
That's really the whole thing with the situation in Ukraine. It's shed a light on so many possibilities. It's possible to humanise refugees. It's possible to support a nation defending its self from aggression. It's not all complex or difficult suddenly to understand a conflict.
It's possible to say "there's a good guy and a bad guy" and not play both sides too. Which...as someone who has spent her whole life hearing about "both sides"...wow is it a breath of fresh air. It's always been possible. We were just exempt from it all.
It's silly to say I'm jealous because I know exactly what Ukrainians are going through right now...because I went through it all and I know the fear and pain and suffering they are experiencing . Nonetheless, I feel a bit envious for the way the world has reacted to their pain.
& I am trying to sit with those feelings while also being scared for both Ukrainians and the entirety of Balkans and while also feeling incredibly triggered and yet unable to stop myself from looking away and trying to help refugees in any way I can and also feeling envious & sad
It's a lot. I feel like I've spent my entire life working diligently to close the massive wound that was left due to the Bosnian genocide and I was so close to getting there, to having it healed. & it's like someone poured a gallon of salt over it and it's ripped wide open again.
Anyway, I'm just a bit in my feelings. Thanks for listening. & thank you for not allowing Ukraine to become another Bosnia. I'm so thankful the world is not choosing to look away this time.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Chomsky specifically said that a concentration camp in which thousands of Bosniaks were forcibly imprisoned in, raped, tortured, and killed and then put in mass graves was "a refugee camp in which people could come and go as they please".
He fell for the Living Marxism propaganda at the time and never did his own research. Living Marxism accused Fikret Abdic, a survivor of the concentration camp whose photo was taken by British journos when they uncovered the camps as a "fake". They were sued by ITN for libel.
The people who spewed that propaganda are now some of the worst ultra-right wingers in the UK. The magazine has been reformed after the lawsuit they lost into Spiked Online which spews incessant far-right bs and propaganda constantly. That's what Chomsky was defending.
Today's @Europarl_EN FAC was massively dissatisfying. They allowed Milorad Dodik to spew such hatred and racism so openly:
"In Europe, they must understand Muslim nationalism. Do they want to have a Muslim country, which will be/part of all terrorist attacks around the world."
He went on to only refer to Bosniaks as "Muslims", he went to on to paint the Bosniaks of Bosnia and Herzegovina as wanting to created an Islamic State, he said that every terrorist attack that's happened has been connected or done by Bosnia's Muslims. Disgusting.
His buddy: Dragan Covic also joined in on the Islamophobia today during the @Europarl_EN in claiming that Bosniaks are trying to establish "a unitary Islamic state".
Meanwhile, Komsic and Dzaferovic highlighted that Covic & Dodik are both highly connected to the Russian regime.
The people who come to mind with awareness and a certain kind of approach are Susan Sontag in Sarajevo and Ed Vulliamy, Penny Marshall & Ian Williams who stood up to Karadzic's lies in Prijedor and uncovered the concentration camps.
Susan Sontag staged a play during the Siege of Sarajevo, involving local actors and collaborating with local writers. The word about the play spread through word of mouth as once before they had announced a different event, Serbs shelled the place. It was impactful.
Ed Vulliamy, Penny Marshall and Ian Williams went to Prijedor to uncover the concentration camps. They spoke to the people imprisoned. Their coverage resulted in the shut down of the camp...which saved thousands of lives, really. They listened to the locals.
Some people may think that I am overtly critical of "war tourists" and that people who go into war zones to "cover the war" are just so brave and phenomenal. The reality is that war tourists, whether certain types of "journos" or public figures like BHL are protected.
There are war correspondents, of course, who are there to do their jobs and simply report as objectively as possible. Kudos to them. But many are not there for the right reasons and are protected in a way that the regular civilians simply never will be in a war zone.
Additionally, it's always bothered me how the journalists, writers, activists of the country being bombed get silenced in favour of the Western reporters who come to tell their stories without facing the same level of risk.
If you are an individual, an organisation, a private enterprise, or anything in between and you want to actively help Ukraine right now a good rule of thumb is to ask yourselves the following before doing something absurd:
"Does this materially benefit the Ukrainian people?"
If it does, then proceed. If it does not and it only serves to benefit your own ego and make you feel validated in the competition of who will be the best ally to all these people suffering under a war of aggression...do not proceed.
Words of support and solidarity are all good and dandy, extremely necessary in the fight against propaganda especially.
But what is more important are all the things they need right now: food, supplies, weapons, access, security.
The same people that have been lecturing genocide survivors on how to respond to our perpetrators and policing our conversations to ensure that we always highlight #NotAllSerbs are the same people that are perfectly fine with punishing every single Russian for Putin's actions.
There has never been a genocide event in which I have not seen a genocide survivor from Bosnia or Cambodia or Rwanda or even the Holocaust have to highlight that they do not hate every single member of the genocidaires ethnic/national group b/c otherwise people are uncomfortable.
Every single event I have been to and I have both been to and organised thousands of these types of events at this point...has had genocide survivors highlight #NotAll members of that ethnic/national group participated in the genocide...and yet suddenly?