GMC counsel are Simon Jackson QC (SJ) and his junior Ryan Donohue (RD).
Dr Michael Webberley (MW) is represented by Rosalind Scott Bell (RSB). MW is not attending.
Chair: One of 3 tribunal members acting as Chair
We are back:
Chair is saying there is a later start tomorrow and a great deal of detail in the case and need to set thos out in the determination (D). Hoping for the D tomorrow or Wed latest and first expert to give evidence on friday
RBS: I need to liase with those who instruct me. I think it proper to indicate I oppose any application to proceed in absence
Chair: thank you. I'll come back to that
SJ: it actually bleeds into the point RBS has just raised....Should we just go back into private.
Chair: of course
I am back in the waiting area
We are back.
Chair: both of you made provisional submissions, do you have any updates
SJ: tribunal should proceed to deal with these individually. RSB says in any event we are going to be facing an app after the first one
RSB: I agree with SJ and would invite you to finalise written determination then proof of service and then move on to 'in absense'. I'll need another written D on that.
Chair: we will cross that hurdle when we come to it. We will consider the merits of it and if possible
Chair: we did discuss on provisional basis as to whether matters should be taken sequentially..in light parties agree on that, that's what we will do. It seems to us the decision to adjourn or proceed in absence are separate...
Chair: ..butbthere is an overlap between the two & should give assistance to MW to know our reasons of adjournament. We propose an update after 2pm Tues whether we can hand down written reasons, or if its on Wed, we'll let you know. If no other matters we will adjourn.
County Durham & Darlington NHS Foundation Trust has applied to suspend the management directions & adjourn the Darlington nurses tribunal, which is listed for 16/6- 4/7.
Regional Employment Judge Robertson has given us permission to attend the 10am remote preliminary hearing.
We are a volunteer collective of citizen journalists reporting legal cases on freedom of speech and belief.
Please subscribe to our stack (link in bio) for the media coverage and daily court reports. Paid subscriptions support our work.
#OpenJustice
We'll continue to report the Adult Human Female Filmmakers vs University and College Union (UCU) on @tribunaltweets today.
Welcome to the afternoon session of DAY 7 of ex-primary school teacher 'A' v Nottingham County Council
'A' claims victimisation for whistleblowing & unfair dismissal for refusing to 'socially transition' a pupil
1.45pm start
Find previous reports/info on our substack (link ⬇️)
'A' was formerly referred to as 'Hannah' in 2024 case - which collapsed after a panel member's social media content was alleged to indicate anti-religious bias. This was later confirmed after a judicial conduct investigation in August 2024.tribunaltweets.substack.com/p/hannah-v-a-p…
We are reporting via remote access and sound and visuals can be challenging.
Please note, there are further reporting restrictions on names of children, staff, witnesses & governors, so please bear with us.
We are live-tweeting (now over from the Tribunal Tweets 1 account) from the morning session, day 6 of the rehearing of ‘A’ v Nottingham County Council, starting at 11 am. Day 1 was a reading day. Note: The Claimant was referred to as ‘Hannah’ in the previous 2024 hearing.
This case was part-heard in March of last year before collapsing on day 6 when a panel member's social media content was alleged to indicate anti-religious bias. This was confirmed after a judicial conduct investigation. Full details of events in and press from 2024 are here: …
We hope to resume at 15:45 for the final session of Randall vs Trent College, employment appeal tribunal. The appeal has been agreed by consent and the case will be returned to ET for a full re-hearing of the merits. The afternoon discussion has been on costs.
Abbreviations
BR - Bernard Randall, former chaplain of Trent College
TC - Trent College, first respondent
JH - J Hallows, second respondent
JR - J Rimington, third respondent
JT - His Honour Judge Tayler, sitting alone
RF - Riaz Fetto, KC barrister for BR
PW - Paul Wilson, barrister for TC
We used 'RB' earlier for Paul Wilson as we did not have his name at the start. Apologies for any confusion.
We will return shortly to Fr Bernard Randall appealing his unsuccessful employment tribunal result following his dismissal as chaplain of Trent College.
RB is being used for the respondents barrister as we didn't have the name. Paul Wilson, the Mr Wilson from an earlier tweet, is RB.
We are waiting still.
NF - cites provision for paying pro bono costs.
Reasonableness, proportionality and procedure - proportionality is to importance, complexity and value. The value is now high, importance - he cannot work as a priest at all.
J - was any warning given as to extent of work?