Phil Cunningham Profile picture
Apr 19 15 tweets 10 min read
CCTV FOLLIES (a thread)
April 20 news
The early AM report uses the broken Irpin Bridge as background. Scenes of war damage are limited, never graphic, but narration and chryons are telling:
-This is what US wants
-NATO adds fuel to fire
-RU/UKR "conflict" wrecks global economy ImageImage
CCTV parades the usual suspects on camera.
Russian "friends" get the most air-time and can speak in their own voices.

Rare clips of Zelensky are typically voiced-over.

Putin: "Western sanctions are an utter failure"
Lavrov: New stage of East Ukraine "advance" is underway ImageImage
Duma Vice-Chair Tolstoy Petr Olegovich gets a sympathetic sit-down interview, addressing CCTV's concerns that the US has been bullying Russia for a long time.
"They are trying to ruin us! They have declared war on us! Ukraine is their proxy!"
@polijunkie_aus ImageImageImage
General Shoigu says the Russian Army in the Donbas is implementing plans in an orderly fashion
Does he protest too loudly? Possibly a preemptive hedge against war crime accusations?
Both Russia and China claim the Bucha massacre was 'fake news' but maybe it unnerves them anyway. Image
As usual, CCTV enjoys access to a wide range of Russian Defense Ministry video rolls, but nothing gritty or graphic. Scenes are selected to impress. High production value shots showing missiles of immense destructive prowess and modern aircraft is typical. ImageImageImage
The results of such firepower are not pretty, but sometimes an aerial bombing run makes it into the news clip, without any detail or context offered. ImageImage
Lest the scenes of Russian military prowess create the politically incorrect impression that a war of invasion has taken place, CCTV segues to the Pentagon to heap blame on the US and UK for providing weapons and training for the Ukrainians. ImageImageImageImage
In another tip of the hat to the social media mavens at #TheGreatTranslationMovement, CCTV selects translates some little gems from Western social media @TGTM_Official

Quotes cherry-picked here support CCTV's thesis that most Europeans are against economic sanctions on Russia. ImageImageImage
That "the people" hate sanctions but they are imposed by unfeeling Western "governments" is a common theme on CCTV, and Germany gets special attention, because it is dependent on Russian gas and has shown some signs of resistance to EU solidarity. ImageImage
April 20 news cycle (update)
Russia Defense Ministry spokesman assures viewers that the "special military operation" has entered a new stage.
@polijunkie_aus @TGTM_Official ImageImage
Russia is opening up humanitarian corridors. ImageImage
Russian report: Many foreign mercenaries have been obliterated. As for those foreign fighters still hiding out in the Azov Steel Factory, they are not in good fortune.

(helicopter footage of "liberated" Mariupol provided by Moscow-based RIA Novosti) ImageImage
A typical CCTV two-shot.
The conceit is that all China cares about is peace, Ukrainians not so much.
-UN head Guterres says there must be cease fire and negotiations
-Ukrainian representative says it's hard to say when negotiations are likely to resume ImageImage
Not only are US and UK providing more military aid to Ukraine, but they want war and the media love the war
(unfortunately for Western war-mongers this is only a 'Special Military Operation')

CCTV, not prone to cliche or cant, is careful to source its sweeping generalizations: ImageImage

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Phil Cunningham

Phil Cunningham Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jinpeili

Apr 25
CCTV-1 News pop quiz for April 26

What gets the young people of Beijing whipped up into a frenzy the likes of which haven't been seen since the Cultural Revolution? Image
Panic-buying? Well-stocked supermarkets?
Fresh vegetables? All good guesses. A cloud of fear hovers over Beijing, fearful of getting the Shanghai treatment.
Close, but not quite. Image
People's University students expectantly line the road to campus hoping for a dream come true. ImageImage
Read 24 tweets
Apr 25
AMERICA'S DARK HEGEMONY
A brief summary of CCTV's WORLD WEEKLY documentary, re-broadcast on April 25.
It's got some current Ukraine news, but it goes deep, buttressing CCTV's anti-US editorial line with history tidbits and a firm belief in the imminent demise of "peak USA." Image
The show is a cut above the nightly news for two reasons. The host had a role in writing it and he tries to put things in context.
Shui Junyi is a journalist. Famous in the 1990's for covering the Gulf War and other foreign conflicts, he also hosted the popular show FOCAL POINT. Image
During the Sochi Olympics in 2014, intrepid roving reporter Shui Junyi secured a prestigious journalistic "get" when he scored an interview with president-what's-his-name. Image
Read 15 tweets
Apr 24
CCTV FOLLIES: April 25 am

The news on Ukraine today starts out with a threat:

Russian Defense Spokesman Igor Konasenkov offers stern warning.

-Russia will continue to attack NATO weapons supply points wherever they are, as was done in Odessa.

@Byron_Wan
#TGTM #China #Russia Image
-"Russia is within it's legal right to do so." Image
Russia says there will be "untold consequences for NATO, and the US, if the supply of weapons to Ukraine continues." Image
Read 11 tweets
Apr 23
CCTV FOLLIES: April 24
A relatively light news day for CCTV purveyors of the Kremlin line on Ukraine, but toxic anyway.
It's still a conflict with no context, and no blame on Russia for invading.
It's still a military operation, not a war.
"Fighting intensifies in East Ukraine." Image
The CCTV weekend news reader presents reports of Russian progress unironically, even though the pictures are at odds with the "good" news from the front with the pacification of Mariupol. Image
Mariupol sees life "return to normal," (正常化) as street life returns and shopping is possible again.

(note: every building is charred, all but one vehicle is torched.) ImageImage
Read 10 tweets
Apr 22
CCTV FOLLIES: April 23 AM

Putin gets a double win in China's telling of the day's news. On the one hand, his special military operation has succeeded in "restoring order" to Mariupol, on the other hand he's protecting Ukrainian citizens. Image
Putin moves the goalposts. Again.
First he said he had no intentions of taking territory. Then it was just the Donbas. Now he says he'll take the south of Ukraine in addition to the Donbas. Is Odessa next?
Anything else? Image
Unmasked invasion enthusiast has his facial features carefully blurred, while the masked soldier is presumably sufficiently anonymized. Image
Read 5 tweets
Apr 21
CCTV FOLLIES, April 22
The top world news story of the day is the "liberation" of Mariupol by Russian forces.

As per previous practice, CCTV shows Ukraine as an amorphous mass without borders. Image
In trying to unpack CCTV's weird borderless Ukraine map, it's helpful to look at what Google Maps provides for the same terrain. Crimea gets a dotted line, it's not an agreed upon international boundary, and the Donbas gets no recognition at all.
@DemesDavid @polijunkie_aus @Dimi Image
If we go back to the same kind of map before the Russian invasion of Crimea --this one from February 2014, just weeks before Russia unilaterally changed the "map"-- there is not as much as a dotted line.

Crimea is shown on this map to be an integral part of Ukraine. Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(