Dibyendu Nandi Profile picture
May 2, 2022 14 tweets 10 min read Read on X
Anatomy of a near disaster. What happened to @flyspicejet Flight 945 which resulted in severe passenger injuries and damage to the aircraft? I am a #SpaceWeather guy but here's a thread of my analysis on weather closer to home for @DGCAIndia + @JM_Scindia
hindustantimes.com/india-news/dgc…
Flight 945 took off from Mumbai around 5.00 pm en route to the Kazi Nazrul Islam Airport just North-West of steel city Durgapur (see gmaps 👇🏾). Whilst landing around 7.30 pm it was hit by what is being reported as extreme turbulence. Autopilot disengaged, all hell broke lose.
Below are flight tracker map of the Mumbai Durgapur air route taken by Flight 945 + thunderstorm archival data from the weather and radar app roughly corresponding to the time of landing of the aircraft. It flew straight into an intense localised storm, the famous Nor'wester!
There was a terrific wind rising associated with rapid pressure variations (👇🏾left) around the time of landing at Durgapur. In fact India Met Office anticipated severe lightning activity in that region.
Data (left) visualcrossing.com/weather-histor…
Data (right)
@Indiametdept
Nor'westers or Kalbaisakhi as we call them locally (they come in the month of Baisakh), are intense, rapidly moving storms accompanied by heavy rain + lightning + strong wind gusts. They bring relief to our summer scorched souls but they r also dangerous!
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nor%27wes….
You, never, ever should fly in to a Nor'wester. @flyspicejet Flight 945 did.

Recall again the flight path I reconstructed from the flight tracker, shown here in red. Was this a lack of weather intelligence, or ignoring the weather info, or prioritising fuel cost over safety?
Is there efficient coordination + flow of information from @Indiametdept to @DGCAIndia to flight operators and to pilots. Do they have clear operating instructions to avoid storms or do they have some leverage in taking a call, which they should not! Are they weather-wise?
In fact, my good friend @DipanjanOnline, co-founder and CEO of @hxkart was in another @IndiGo6E flight at the same time from Mumbai to Kolkata. That flight also was headed into trouble but the pilot decided to divert ro Guwahati. He says this.
What do the Americans do when they confront a similar localised but intense storm activity which are always associated with air turbulence. They go around it! See this cool tracker map. More fuel, higher operating costs but valuing life over money.
When I shared my analysis with @DipanjanOnline and we were trying to make sense of this, he said something which stuck (quoted with permission!). This is sadly the truth of living in a nation where lack of safety has no high cost associated with it for the corporations + govt.
Anyway I call for better coordination between @Indiametdept @moesgoi @DGCAIndia, various airline operators and pilots. i ask that you be weather aware and prioritise life and safety over a few extra hours or a few extra bucks.
@rajeevan61 @DrJitendraSingh
I see many news outlets have picked up on my tweets. I caution that a precise determination of what led to the severe turbulence impact on the @flyspicejet Flight 945 must depend on a more quantitative investigation by @DGCAIndia. So don't blame anyone before that concludes.
Remember that in the immediate aftermath of the crash of the Lion Air Flight 610 (Boeing Max 737), aspersions were cast on the pilots. Later it emerged the problem was with a malfunctioning sensor and the aircraft models' automated Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System!
That the spicejet flight flew into a major turbulence zone could have been due to a variety of factors which may or may not have involved human error, instrument error, insufficient weather intelligence or a bad operational choice. Only a serious investigation can isolate cause.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dibyendu Nandi

Dibyendu Nandi Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ydnad0

Jul 7, 2023
India readies for #Chandrayaan3 launch next week. The primary goal is to test our technical capability of landing a rover on the Moon 🌒 The mission costs about $ 82 million and is @isro s second attempt at a successful moon landing. What most people don't know is that...
+

#Chandrayaan1 and #Chandrayaan2 have made some cool scientific discoveries about the moon, including mapping its surface. While #Chandrayaan3 is not a science centric mission, its success would enable lunar science and exploration. The moon remains a hot target for humanity.
Here's some cool graphics and news from @WIONews
wionews.com/web-stories/in…
Read 5 tweets
Jan 18, 2023
Today I did something I have never done. I declined a grant. The reduced approval was inadequate to support the human resource and computational power necessary to sustain proposed research. Computational modelers in India suffer because agencies devalue local computing needs +
Supporting globally competitive & transformative modelling efforts from India require establishing local computational facilities. While much more expensive local experimental equipment is funded, computational needs continue to be undervalued = major reason India is held back +
More often than not we buy those expensive experimental equipment from abroad, equipment which has already catalyzed pioneering works from other shores; we become followers of that trend. Computational clusters are not unique in that sense but can sustain super creative work +
Read 5 tweets
Jan 17, 2023
This is misleading @xkcd. During solar maximum (when there are more spots on the surface) the total radiation output of the Sun actually increases, implying it is brighter (in common parlance). Because within weeks sunspots break apart giving rise to smaller brighter structures.
These bright structures associated with sunspots are known as faculae (or plage). They end up compensating for the dark spots and increasing the total solar radiation when averaged over weeks to monthly timescale. Here is an ☀️ observational image as evidence.
So bottomline is this was a good joke which people seem to have fallen for given the responses to this comic strip.
Read 4 tweets
May 2, 2022
Trying to upload documents and submit a Core grant to @IndiaDST @serbonline for an hour or so now. The site is barely crawling, not retaining profile information and biodata info, and simply is unworkable now. Deadline 5 pm. What do we do? @Sandeep_1966
This is what is going on!
Switched from chrome to Microsoft edge. No luck here. The main web portal itself is not loading. And am on same network as this mobile, so network here is not an issue.
Read 6 tweets
Jan 12, 2022
Government brings in regulation allowing students to pursue up to 50% courses from institutions other than the one they are enrolled in. Comments in this @ttindia report severely criticize this move. This criticism is 1D and biased in my opinion. Thread +
telegraphindia.com/india/iits-iim…
I do not believe the Government is forcing any institution or student to take online courses from other institutions. They are just making this option available which can be taken advantage of by academic organizations and students in certain circumstances +
This will allow IISERs and other organization's to share courses, balance the disproportionate work load of faculty in teaching intensive institutions (especially Universities) allowing them to spend more time in research and development activities +
Read 7 tweets
Jun 1, 2021
Has the #WestBengal #COVID19 (partial) lockdown been useful? YES!!! Future prognosis? A thread based on analysis by @cessi_iiserkol team 👇🏾
New daily cases have halved since May 15 (beginning of lockdown).
Left @covid19indiaorg data; Right: CESSI model projection versus data 1/n
The pandemic growth rate has dipped below zero during the lockdown and is in the negative which is desirable. The more negative is the growth rate, the faster is the fall in active cases. Negative growth rate needs to be sustained. 2/n
Test positivity (percentage of those who test positive) has almost halved over the #lockdown period and is around 17% as of May 31. Should be sustained below 2.5% to keep the #COVID19 pandemic at a manageable level and ideally should be 0%! 3/n
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(