In an enormous miscarriage of justice, a Peruvian judge has found against anthropologist Marcela Poirier in the defamation suit filed against her by twice confirmed sexual harasser Luis Jaime Castillo Butters. The penalty is a $48K fine and one year, eight months in jail.
The judge also suspended Marcela's lawyer, Brenda Alvarez, from practicing law on the grounds that she supposedly tried to delay the trial. Brenda will immediately appeal, of course. The judge dismissed the testimony of all of Marcela's witnesses, including me...
the reporter who initially investigated allegations of sexual #harassment against Castillo and found them to be well supported (as did the sexual harassment commission of Castillo's university, the @pucp, and @theNASciences, which ejected him from its ranks.
I had an interesting exchange with @MichaelWorobey today about the Covid-19 origins debate, in which he suggested that having a beer and talking might help to cool down passions which are clearly running high. I told him I would welcome having that beer and that…
We need to figure out why the debate, which ultimately is a scientific (epidemiological) question, has become so acrimonious. I also told him that I am neutral on the core issue of whether the lab-leak or natural origins hypotheses are correct, because I think there…
Is no real direct evidence for either scenario (including his own recent preprint on the distribution of cases in the Wuhan seafood market.) As I have said many times, I have been astonished and aghast at the behavior of many scientists and science journalists…
The debate centers on two main competing scenarios: That SARS-CoV-2 transferred to humans from an animal host, or that it leaked from a lab, specifically the Wuhan Inst of Virology, and then infected humans. The lab-leak hypothesis encompasses both genetically…
Engineered viruses and unaltered viruses that may have been cultured in the lab. Although Thacker is pretty harsh, I have to agree that Aldhous and BuzzFeed have pretty much manufactured a scenario that is not accurate: The idea that the lab-leak hypothesis has become…
ICYMI: Can we stop the next pandemic by seeking out deadly viruses in the wild? [A very good and timely piece. I think it's one thing to monitor viruses that could pass over from animals to humans, and another to manipulate them... vox.com/future-perfect…
Genetically in the lab, which both Chinese and U.S. scientists have done--especially if these manipulations make the viruses more dangerous to humans, so-called "gain of function work." And despite many millions spent on such programs, we were not able to avoid...
a pandemic that has now killed at least 6 million people around the world and probably many more. As @Ayjchan and others have pointed out, the SARS-CoV-2 virus has its origins in animals, probably bats, and how it got into humans is kind of a detail. Did it transfer...
It's extraordinary that the Editor-in-Chief of @sciencemagazine, @hholdenthorp, would write such a biased editorial about a legitimate scientific debate, and one that would show either ignorance of facts, dishonesty about facts, or both. #coronavirusscience.org/doi/10.1126/sc…
To continue to refer to those who are not satisfied with the natural origins hypothesis for Covid-19 origins, who include leading scientists and science journaists, as "conspiracy theorists" is truly slanderous and not at all in the scientific spirit.
To state that the "virus is almost certainly of zoonotic origin" is to state something that is not scientifically demonstrated, and to pretend evidence exists that does not. Neither hypothesis has any kind of smoking gun evidence behind it.
ICYMI: The settlement in the $18 million defamation suit Danielle Kurin filed against me for my truthful reporting on her misconduct is now null and void, but the lawsuit itself has been dismissed with prejudice. Kurin now has bigger problems. michael-balter.blogspot.com/2021/10/metoo-…
Will the Santa Barbara County Sheriff charge Kurin with violating the CA Health and Safety Code for failing to report her finding of human remains for 2 months? michael-balter.blogspot.com/2021/10/the-st…
By violating the agreement we had come to, in which I made a major concession to her in exchange for publication of a document that showed my reporting was right, Kurin has badly damaged her own interests, something she does habitually. This story is far from over.