So let's follow up w/some more data related to #sbcreport. All publicly available @PRRIpoll data. In 2017, we see across groups, white evangelical Baptist men were disproportionately more likely to say recent reports of workplace assault/harassment were "isolated incidents." 1/5
In a 2018 @PRRIpoll survey, we see that across groups, white evangelical Baptist men were most likely to agree that "most sexual harassment claims are just the result of misunderstanding between women and men." In other words, not REALLY sexual harassment. Just a whoops. 2/5
Other surveys can't get us to #SBC folks, but we do see patterns among evangelicals vs. others. In 2018 @PRRIpoll data, evangelicals were the MOST likely to say the #MeToo movement led to unfair treatment of men & LEAST likely to say it helped address sexual assault. Also... 3/5
In that same @PRRIpoll survey, when adults were asked how well churches have responded to issues of sexual assault, evangelicals are by far the group MOST likely to say churches (assuming their own) have done very/somewhat well & LEAST likely to say "not well at all." So... 4/5
Combined with the original Tweet from last night, there are numerous data points suggesting evangelicals broadly were skeptical of #MeToo & overconfident in their own response, while WE Baptist men in particular are most likely to minimize/deny sexual assault/harassment. 5/5 #SBC
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Not a dunk. Sam's a smart guy. But here's quick 🧵 suggesting this claim ("it is the Republican party that has grown less white over the last several years") may be overblown. In absolute terms, yes. But alone? Nope. Or more than Dems? Nope. 1/4
First, thanks to @ryanburge for being a baller crunching quick numbers.
In terms of party ID, the % of white Democrats & Republicans dropped *identically* since 2015 (-4%). Democrats grew way more diverse since 2010. And it's Independents who REALLY got less white recently. 2/4
But what about actual voters?
Between 2016 & 2020 election, the % of folks who voted GOP who are white dropped 3%, Democrats by 2%. But look at the % difference between 2012 & 2020. White Dem voters dropped 10% to white Republican voters dropping 5%.
Folks seriously need to learn the difference between nationalism and patriotism. Here's George Orwell for your reminder: "Patriotism is of its nature defensive, both militarily and culturally. Nationalism, on the other hand, is inseparable from the desire for power."
Please don't applaud or promote "nationalism" when you're actually looking at "patriotism." Nationalism is the aggressor here. Patriotism is what's standing against it.
Here's a similar distinction that political philosopher Steven Smith draws in his book Reclaiming Patriotism. amazon.com/Reclaiming-Pat…
Let's clear this up. Unlikely John meant to convey Jesus beat humans w/a whip. The Greek is ambivalent. Some translations (e.g. NIV, GNB) clarify it's only animals. Contexts makes it clearer humans weren't whipped.
But authoritarians like Walsh LOVE a Jesus who hurts people. 1/4
The whip passage is John 2:13-16. The Greek in vs. 15 is ambivalent & some translations indicate that Jesus drove out everyone ALONG WITH animals. NIV here indicates only sheep & cows got the whip. Why? Because context, that's why. Look at vs 16. If Jesus already expelled... 2/4
...ALL THE HUMANS w/a whip, why are the dove sellers still in the temple w/their doves?
Cuz John's not telling us Jesus whipped all the humans out. Jesus drove out livestock w/the tool one would use (a whip), tossed coins/tables, & told dove sellers to get out w/their goods. 3/4
🧵 For 6 years I've taught online soc of religion courses to ~90 total students over winter & summer break. Shocking to me, even within that short time frame, how the proportion of "nones" in the class has grown. Now a majority. Combo of formerly-religious & never-religious. 1/4
I ask students in discussion posts to talk about their religious background & current religious involvement (to the extent they're comfortable). Haven't formally coded these, but the "leavers" often note hypocrisy, judgment, sexual ethic, & getting plugged in elsewhere. But...2/4
It's interesting that I almost never hear statements about national politics or political leaders. It's almost always negative personal encounters w/religious folks or church, combined w/finding some other group to plug into. Rarely an event, though. More often a drift. Now...3/4
First, there's a huge #ChristianNationalism propaganda machine that puts out misinformation about religion (Christianity) in American political history. Folks higher on Christian nationalism are more likely to consume this material. See @anelsona@kathsstewart@AndrewLSeidel 2/
Second, in another study we found folks higher on #ChristianNationalism got lower science scores, not because they're ignorant per se, but b/c when asked about contentious issues (e.g., evolution) they chose answers favoring subculture. @ParadoxOfBelief 3/ journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.11…