Modi govt has carried out the most SWEEPING changes (yet) in school textbooks 📚 since it came to power in 2014!
Starting today, @IndianExpress will take you through the GLARING deletions in NCERT's history, pol science & sociology textbooks for Classes 6 to 12. #Thread (1/n)
👉The first part of our investigation (out today) focuses on changes made to the content related to contemporary India 🇮🇳
👉The most significant of them is the deletion of references to the 2002 Gujarat riots from TWO ✌️textbooks.
(2/n)
👉Two pages on the riots have been dropped from the Class 12 pol sc book. These pages provide the chronology of events -- a train full of karsevaks set on fire followed by violence against Muslims -- & refer to the criticism of the state govt in failing to control violence.
(3/n)
👉The 2nd reference has been removed from the Class 12 Sociology textbook. This is a paragraph that cites the example of Gujarat riots & anti-Sikh riots to describe how communalism drives people to "kill, rape, and loot members of other communities."
(4/n)
👉Content on public protests (that turned into social movements) in contemporary India has SHRUNK, drastically.
3 chapters on protests including those spearheaded by Narmada Bachao Andolan, Dalit Panthers & Bharatiya Kisan Union are now dropped from pol sc in Classes 6
to 12
👉Among other deletions on protests & social movements is an 'exercise box' (in the Class 12 sociology textbook) that asks students to discuss the recent farmers’ protests against the three farm laws passed by the Parliament.
(6/n)
🚨 Interestingly, the 'Emergency' has been whitewashed.
DELETED: A BIG section on controversies surrounding Emergency & excesses such as the arrest of political workers, restrictions on media, torture & custodial deaths, forced sterilisations in the Class 12 pol sc textbook
DELETED: A paragraph on the draconian impact of the Emergency on people & institutions in the Class 12 sociology book👇
(8/n)
👉Content on democracy has suffered the deepest cuts.
FOUR chapters about democracy & making of Indian democracy have been deleted from political science & history textbooks on the ground that similar topics have already been covered in other classes.
(9/n)
Among other redactions:
🚨A section describing the arbitrariness of colonial law through the example of sedition is no longer part of the Class 8 political science book.
Interestingly, this was the ONLY reference to sedition across ALL pol science & history textbooks
(10/n)
The above section (deleted from the Class 8 pol sc book) also carried the following exercise for students: "State one reason why you think the Sedition Act of 1870 was arbitrary? In what ways does the Sedition Act of 1870 contradict the rule of law?"
(11/n)
MORE: Former prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru’s quote on Emperor Ashoka (in Class 6 history) & the Bhakra Nangal Dam (in Class 12 sociology) dropped.
(12/n)
ALL references to Naxalism & the Naxalite movement have been deleted across ALL history, political science & sociology textbooks of NCERT.
The most glaring 👀of them are the deletions pertaining to Mahatma Gandhi's assassination
DELETED 👉: Ban imposed on the Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) by the union govt after Gandhi's death dropped from Class Political Science textbook
(see pic for deleted sentences)
(2/n)
EXHIBIT B:
Sentences on how Gandhi's steadfast pursuit of Hindu-Muslim unity provoked Hindu extremists have been removed from the Class 12 Political Science textbook
Not sure why everyone is suddenly outraging over deletions pertaining to Mughal rulers from NCERT textbooks that happened a year ago! 🥴
Anyhoo, using this opportunity to re-plug our investigation from June 2022 detailing ALL deletions from NCERT's social science textbooks
(1/4)
The 1st part of the series focused on changes made (in NCERT textbooks) to content related to contemporary India The most significant of them was deletion of references to the Gujarat riots.
Remember the Institutions of Eminence (IOE) scheme & the political firestorm over Jio Institute's selection?
5 yrs on, @IndianExpress decided to check on Modi govt's promise of autonomy & global standards for 20 institutions of higher learning.
Here's what we found:
🧵 (1/n)
We investigated official records, visited IOE campuses across country & interviewed university personnel & govt officials to find a sharp divide between public & private institutions selected for the 'eminence' status — and a❓mark on the future of the IOE scheme itself
(2/n)
Clearly, money promised under IOE scheme has made a difference, but the assurances of autonomy & cutting red tape largely remain on paper.
The latter assumes significance as Modi govt is now making similar commitments on autonomy to foreign univs to attract them to India
The govt is currently drafting a new curriculum doc (aka National School Curriculum or NCF). The exercise is being led by a 12-member panel headed by former ISRO head K Kasturirangan
The new NCF will be the FOUNDATION for new NCERT textbooks.
(2/n)
The Kasturirangan committee is being assisted by 25 focus groups constituted along different themes (eg: environment edu, arts edu etc.)
In other words, the inputs of these 25 focus groups will feed into the larger NCF document.
The ruling establishment's view that our history glorifies invaders at the cost of other kings has found an echo in how school textbooks have been reworked.
In the penultimate part of the investigation, @IndianExpress takes you through the deletions related to Muslim rulers.
We found that most of such changes have been made in ONE textbook. Before we jump into that, there's something we'd like you to show you.. (contd)
(2/n)
... the NCERT, curiously, replaced a table on changes in the Class 7 history with a new one (on its website) this week.
The new table doesn't reflect at least three deletions pertaining to Islamic rulers in the Class 7 history textbook ‘Our Past – II’.
(3/n)
In the penultimate part of the investigation, @IndianExpress takes you through the deletions related to Muslim rulers.
We found that most of such changes have been made in ONE textbook. Before we jump into that, there's something we'd like you to show you.. (contd)
(2/n)
... the NCERT, curiously, replaced a table on changes in the Class 7 history with a new one (on its website) this week.
The new table doesn't reflect at least three deletions pertaining to Islamic rulers in the Class 7 history textbook ‘Our Past – II’.
(3/n)
So what are these changes that the NCERT removed from its website? 🤔
First, a reference to Mahmud Ghazni of Afghanistan (in Chapter 2), who invaded the subcontinent & raided the Somnath temple, has been tweaked. The title “Sultan” has been dropped from his name...
(4/n)