The Pension Hawk™️is once again circling the carrion that is Treasury Board and Finance to bring you today's announcement.
The @aimcoinvests Board used to be a pest house for PCAA connected appointees. Ah, the good 'ol boys. #AbLeg
Did they have Alberta's best interest at heart? Maybe. Were they the best for a multi-billion dollar pension fund? Nope.
Board member selection for AIMCO has certainly evolved. You wouldn't know it because Travis has not publicly talked about anything to do with it. #AbLeg
It is bad to have a board that is deeply connected to the politics of AB investing the retirement savings of workers. This process needs to be non-political.
When Rachel became Premier the Board Chair of @aimcoinvests (Mac) offered to resign. #AbLeg For example.
The AIMCO Board is now supposed to recommend potential Board members for Travis to appoint. But that process is opaque and still subject to whim.
Jim Keohane was recently appointed. He is a super qualified pension expert. Why did it take so many years to get a pension expert?
I think the Board's psychology in the past was weighted heavily towards The Heritage Fund. Here are the good ol' berta (mainly) boys helping the GOA invest its money. But that narrative was false because most of the money was pensions that are not the GOAs. #AbLeg
All of these misalignment problems stem from the fact that @aimcoinvests is wholly owned by the GOA. And, Travis has overstepped by ordering the trustees of these assets to use AIMCO regardless of return or other issues. #AbLeg
Here is one more quote from Dr. Bob to brighten your day where he again reviews how Travis destroyed any trust that remained by calling retirement savings "public money". #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is your daily pension announcement: As the decomposers set in on the last of Jason Kenney's government The Pension War Room™️rejoices that more Annual Reports are out! LAPP for instance. #AbLeg lapp.ca/page/annual-re…
LAPP is now 124% funded! After the good year @aimcoinvests this spells contribution rate reduction! For once in its 13 year history @aimcoinvests exceeded the return target of LAPP. Hopefully it doesn't take another 13 years for it to happen again. #AbLeg
LAPP paid @aimcoinvests $542 million to manage the investments. Almost double what they paid the year before.
This isn't necessarily a problem, as I have explained many times, the narrow cost only argument of Travis and Athans is disingenuous and wrong. #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️continues to act in place of a hog manure pump. AIMCO total return was 14.7% last year and ATRF returned 15.6%.
Yet these numbers tell us very little about performance.#handsoffmypension
Short time periods are unreliable, as well we need to separate out the skills of the portfolio manager from the movement of the general market. We would do this by looking at the 10-year value add above the benchmark return (think index fund). #AbLeg
The 10 year value add at ATRF is 0.8%.
The 10 year value add for AIMCO's balanced fund (mainly pensions) is 0.5%.
Most pension funds have a value add target of around 0.7% to 0.85% depending on risk. This is the information that should have been in the "business case". #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️will begin a deep dive into the @aimcoinvests Annual Report that was released quietly before a long weekend. No press release. No huzzah from Treasury Board and Finance. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
I do want to reiterate that we are forced into having Twitter accountability for AIMCO since pension plan members are in NO WAY represented on the Board. In stark contrast with practice in the rest of the country, AIMCO is wholly owned by the GOA. #AbLeg
The first concern: lying. To quote the Annual Report,
"Attracting world-class investment professionals allows for AIMCo to continue to deliver top-tier investment performance with 69% of our clients’ assets managed internally," #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️will begin analyzing the @aimcoinvests Annual Report. Here is a piece addressing the last year and their efforts to rebuild trust. #handsoffmypension
I take umbrage with “A combination of factors had undermined trust between AIMCo and some of our clients,”
It wasn't "SOME" of your clients, it was MOST of your clients representing MOST of your assets under management. #AbLeg
Details are important.
In fact, @ewsiddall has not even met with @albertateachers , one of his major clients. In trying to rebuild trust I would think this would be a requirement. #AbLeg
Here is the Annual Report for your education and enjoyment. More to follow. aimco.ca/insights/aimco…
The Pension War Room™️has returned from the wilderness to bring you the latest Heritage Fund Annual Report! Get your copy ⬇️⬇️. An interesting read by any account. Invested by @aimcoinvests and a great 1-year return. alberta.ca/heritage-savin…
Earned an 11.8% one year return against a benchmark of 7%. Which is great by any measure. Also, one year returns don't mean much, but encouraging nonetheless.
Almost $20 billion in size now; next to the pension funds this would be a "small" fund. #AbLeg
@aimcoinvests investment cost was 0.90% (90 bps) both last year and the year before. This is a bit shocking. Asset mix is different than ATRF so a direct comparison is not warranted (bonds cost less to invest than other assets for ex). #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement! Happy Canada Day from The Pension War Room™️. I just want to let you know that we are looking forward to an active year in the pension landscape! We will continue to be **here** for you with analysis and salty commentary. #AbLeg#redouble
That paragraph snip above is from the @aimcoinvests "business case" for destroying a top quartile investment manager here in good ol 'berta. I think it is the paragraph of complete 💩🐂that put Travis over the edge. #AbLeg
Why would Kevin (CEO at the time) do that? Well he and his executive team stood to gain millions in compensation as the assets under management increased. #ABLeg
So looking forward to the @aimcoinvests Annual Report. It will be significant in both good ways and bad.