Great convo started by PV. If you want to be a great #mtg player long-term, you will grow much better learning from playing the “best” deck. However, you’re NOT the best player. So if you want to spike this tournament, you probably should min/max luck, including matchups. 1/
It’s the tricky thing about competitive #mtg: today versus tomorrow. There are upsides to “going rogue” for building a brand because the crowd thirsts for something new constantly, but innovations almost always fail to what already exists. 2/
Case in point: when I started MakingMythic.com it was to highlight how I play #mtgarena: focused on going Mythic each month with a unique deck. What you don’t see are dozens of tweaks and discarded piles. That’s natural in deckbuilding, but it’s not sexy. 3/
The best deck is the best deck for a reason: it has survived because it has shown it is powerful. Sharks are older than trees for a reason: a sleek underwater biting machine only needs minor tweaks over time to keep competing. You probably can’t beat it. 4/
That said, life is short. You’ll improve at #mtg listening to PV, but the “correct” choice is playing whatever deck makes you the happiest. To improve, get reps with a great deck. To spike, take an angle shot you know well and hope. Or play Krark’s Thumb and flip some coins. 5/
And props to @lucasfaley for bringing this thread to my attention. Twitter is garbage for in-depth discussions, but I appreciate his take and @PVDDR for starting an important convo. The community is lucky to have them! /end
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
“Reserve list” chatter is still good for getting #mtg players riled up. Let’s talk about a different, but serious, game building challenge I call “Schrodinger’s Goyf…” 1/
#mtg players want to open expensive cards that are “worth money.” It’s exciting to find a chase card, and the idea of turning that card into currency to pay for your hobby feels good. You see this when folks like @TolarianCollege try to go infi’ with box openings 2/
But players ALSO want the game to be “accessible.” When not talking ADA, that universally means “cheap for me to buy the things I want when I want them.” So… 3/
The #mtg Reserve List convo has bubbled back up. My stance as it was when I was #wotcstaff: you can’t abolish it for legal reasons that would bankrupt the game. But you don’t need to… 1/
You can smash it by just printing improved versions of the cards. Make a Black Lotus that sacs for CCCC. Make Mox that gain you life when they ETB. But a better solution to solve the problem is a design like: 2/
White Lotus 0
When <CARDNAME> ETBs you gain an emblem with “If you would cast or have cast a card named Black Lotus, you lose the game.”
Tap/sac: add 3 mana
3/