1).
The straw man fallacy by Sergey Sumlenny
Mr. Sergey @sumlenny, a Russian political scientist; writer and journalist; Independent Eastern Europe Expert, former Regional Director Ukraine and Belarus at the Heinrich Böll Foundation living in Germany [1],
The straw man fallacy by Sergey Sumlenny
Mr. Sergey @sumlenny, a Russian political scientist; writer and journalist; Independent Eastern Europe Expert, former Regional Director Ukraine and Belarus at the Heinrich Böll Foundation living in Germany [1],
https://twitter.com/sumlenny/status/1561334515490082817
2).
creates a psychological profile of the infamous prof. Aleksandr Dugin based on an article by Marina Golubina. It is a Gnostic interpretation of the known – from what I can see, however, not for everyone – tales of the son of Abraham (Gen. 22:8-14) and the daughter of
creates a psychological profile of the infamous prof. Aleksandr Dugin based on an article by Marina Golubina. It is a Gnostic interpretation of the known – from what I can see, however, not for everyone – tales of the son of Abraham (Gen. 22:8-14) and the daughter of
3).
Jephthah (Judg 11:1–12:7 ) from the Old Testament. In the opinion of Mr. Sumlenny, it is peculiar apotheosis of children in sacrifice (especially daughters as emphasizes). It should be noted that the story about Jephthahʼs daughter is not taken literally by everyone;
Jephthah (Judg 11:1–12:7 ) from the Old Testament. In the opinion of Mr. Sumlenny, it is peculiar apotheosis of children in sacrifice (especially daughters as emphasizes). It should be noted that the story about Jephthahʼs daughter is not taken literally by everyone;
4).
St. Philaret [Vasily Mikhaylovich Drozdov] (1782–1867), just like Jewish scholars – Rabbi David Kimhi (1160–1235) and Levi Ben Gershon (1288–1344) have a different opinion than St. John Chrysostom (c . 347–407) [2].
St. Philaret [Vasily Mikhaylovich Drozdov] (1782–1867), just like Jewish scholars – Rabbi David Kimhi (1160–1235) and Levi Ben Gershon (1288–1344) have a different opinion than St. John Chrysostom (c . 347–407) [2].
5).
Mr. Sumlenny, in order to critique Dugin, do you have to „attacking a straw man”? Did you inform about what Dugin wrote about, for example, Poland? [3]. If so, I am sorry; Iʼm not following all your posts. If not, why do you avoid the essence of things? After all,
Mr. Sumlenny, in order to critique Dugin, do you have to „attacking a straw man”? Did you inform about what Dugin wrote about, for example, Poland? [3]. If so, I am sorry; Iʼm not following all your posts. If not, why do you avoid the essence of things? After all,
6).
there are scientific articles on the main ideologist #RusskiyMir [4].
If Dugin did write an article in which – like the worshipers of Baal and Moloch – he recommends the of the children in sacrifice, Mr. @sumlenny should include a link to it.
there are scientific articles on the main ideologist #RusskiyMir [4].
If Dugin did write an article in which – like the worshipers of Baal and Moloch – he recommends the of the children in sacrifice, Mr. @sumlenny should include a link to it.
7).
Admittedly, this is not Sumlennyʼs first „brilliant” Twitter comment. On March 7, 2021 posted a twitt about Stepan Bandera (1909–1959). Namely, he called the leader of the OUN-B „Ukrainian freedom champion”. I stress that I just mean this quote; I do not approve of
Admittedly, this is not Sumlennyʼs first „brilliant” Twitter comment. On March 7, 2021 posted a twitt about Stepan Bandera (1909–1959). Namely, he called the leader of the OUN-B „Ukrainian freedom champion”. I stress that I just mean this quote; I do not approve of
8).
the devastation of any resting places of the dead [5]. June 30, 2022 posted:
– „Germans should humbly shut up about Bandera at least, or (better and recommend) kneel and ask for forgiveness”.
Why? Because the Germans sent him to KL Sachsenchausen [6].
the devastation of any resting places of the dead [5]. June 30, 2022 posted:
– „Germans should humbly shut up about Bandera at least, or (better and recommend) kneel and ask for forgiveness”.
Why? Because the Germans sent him to KL Sachsenchausen [6].
9).
The immediate initiator of the Massacres of Poles in Volhynia and Eastern Galicia (1943–1945) [7] was former officer of the Battalion Ukrainische Gruppe Nachtigall [8] Roman Szuchevycz (1907–1950). In the order issued on February 25, 1944, he stated:
The immediate initiator of the Massacres of Poles in Volhynia and Eastern Galicia (1943–1945) [7] was former officer of the Battalion Ukrainische Gruppe Nachtigall [8] Roman Szuchevycz (1907–1950). In the order issued on February 25, 1944, he stated:
10).
– „In view of the success of the Soviet forces it is necessary to speed up the liquidation of the Poles, they must be totally wiped out, their villages burned... only the Polish population must be destroyed”.
– „In view of the success of the Soviet forces it is necessary to speed up the liquidation of the Poles, they must be totally wiped out, their villages burned... only the Polish population must be destroyed”.
11).
According to the most probable hypothesis, the decision to genocide Poles was made by a group of three people from the Volyn leadership of the OUN-B: Dmytro Klyachkivsky (1911–1945), Vasyl Ivakhiv (1908–1943) and Ivan Lytvynchuk (1917 –1952).
According to the most probable hypothesis, the decision to genocide Poles was made by a group of three people from the Volyn leadership of the OUN-B: Dmytro Klyachkivsky (1911–1945), Vasyl Ivakhiv (1908–1943) and Ivan Lytvynchuk (1917 –1952).
12).
Stepan Bandera, leader of the OUN-B, although he was incarcerated by the Germans at KL Sachsenhausen (1941–1944) during the Volhynia massacre – therefore he could not direct the genocide – it is a co-creator of the ideology that will lead to it [9].
Stepan Bandera, leader of the OUN-B, although he was incarcerated by the Germans at KL Sachsenhausen (1941–1944) during the Volhynia massacre – therefore he could not direct the genocide – it is a co-creator of the ideology that will lead to it [9].
13).
The scope of involvement of the Soviet secret services and the hypotheses regarding the Soviet inspiration cannot be resolved without access to the documentation of these services, which is in secret special collections of the Russian Federation. According to
The scope of involvement of the Soviet secret services and the hypotheses regarding the Soviet inspiration cannot be resolved without access to the documentation of these services, which is in secret special collections of the Russian Federation. According to
14).
dr. Grzegorz Hryciuk [10] and prof. Grzegorz Motyka [11], the hypothesis of Soviet provocation when making decisions about ethnic cleansing should, however, be firmly rejected. There is no documented case of an attack by NKVD disguised as UPA on any Polish village [12].
dr. Grzegorz Hryciuk [10] and prof. Grzegorz Motyka [11], the hypothesis of Soviet provocation when making decisions about ethnic cleansing should, however, be firmly rejected. There is no documented case of an attack by NKVD disguised as UPA on any Polish village [12].
15).
Prosecutor Piotr Zając from the Department @ipngovpl of the Chief Commission for the Prosecution of Crimes against the Polish Nation considers that the extermination command was issued in the leadership of the OUN-UPA, and an additional factor factor determining
Prosecutor Piotr Zając from the Department @ipngovpl of the Chief Commission for the Prosecution of Crimes against the Polish Nation considers that the extermination command was issued in the leadership of the OUN-UPA, and an additional factor factor determining
16).
the genocide was mass participation of agitated Ukrainians peasants by Ukrainian nationalism. As noted by prof. @TimothyDSnyder [13], a similar social and historical situation was in the territory of present-day Belarus, but there were no purges on Poles there.
the genocide was mass participation of agitated Ukrainians peasants by Ukrainian nationalism. As noted by prof. @TimothyDSnyder [13], a similar social and historical situation was in the territory of present-day Belarus, but there were no purges on Poles there.
17).
The difference was the nationalist ideology, which was not widespread among Belarusians [14].
At first I thought I was just dealing with Mr @sumlenny mistake [15]; well no one is omniscient. Meanwhile, it turns out that this is to oversimplify, and maybe something else?
The difference was the nationalist ideology, which was not widespread among Belarusians [14].
At first I thought I was just dealing with Mr @sumlenny mistake [15]; well no one is omniscient. Meanwhile, it turns out that this is to oversimplify, and maybe something else?
18).
Finally, I would like to stress itʼs not my goal to attack and discredit Sergey @sumlenny; his profile contains a lot of valuable and interesting information. I myself sometimes make mistakes, however, in such a case, I always try to post a the correction.
Finally, I would like to stress itʼs not my goal to attack and discredit Sergey @sumlenny; his profile contains a lot of valuable and interesting information. I myself sometimes make mistakes, however, in such a case, I always try to post a the correction.
19).
I am simply very critical of any content posted on the Internet. I am of the opinion that everyone should do the same to eliminate desinformation.
Greeting cordial from Poland 𓃠
Footnotes:
[1] de.linkedin.com/in/sergej-suml…
calvertjournal.com/contributors/s…
I am simply very critical of any content posted on the Internet. I am of the opinion that everyone should do the same to eliminate desinformation.
Greeting cordial from Poland 𓃠
Footnotes:
[1] de.linkedin.com/in/sergej-suml…
calvertjournal.com/contributors/s…
20).
[2] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jephthah
foma.ru/chto-proizoshl…
[3] fronda.pl/a/aleksander-d…
[4] cambridge.org/core/journals/…
mod-langs.ox.ac.uk/russian/nation…
abw.gov.pl/download/1/222…
docplayer.pl/66290134-Krzys…
[5]
[6]
[2] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jephthah
foma.ru/chto-proizoshl…
[3] fronda.pl/a/aleksander-d…
[4] cambridge.org/core/journals/…
mod-langs.ox.ac.uk/russian/nation…
abw.gov.pl/download/1/222…
docplayer.pl/66290134-Krzys…
[5]
https://twitter.com/sumlenny/status/1368626760892506113?t=VAaHTCBLzFZMCtU0rwRUBg&s=19
[6]
https://twitter.com/sumlenny/status/1542548026333532161?t=oqH4EQb8YDzMYT-9fYNUNg&s=19
21).
[7] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacres…
pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rze%C5%BA…
[8] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nachtigal…
pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batalion_…
[7] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacres…
pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rze%C5%BA…
[8] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nachtigal…
pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batalion_…
22).
The Simon Wiesenthal Center contends that between June 30 and July 3, 1941, in the days that the Battalion was in Lviv the Nachtigall soldiers together with the German army and the local Ukrainians participated in the killings of Jews in the city. The pretext for the
The Simon Wiesenthal Center contends that between June 30 and July 3, 1941, in the days that the Battalion was in Lviv the Nachtigall soldiers together with the German army and the local Ukrainians participated in the killings of Jews in the city. The pretext for the
23).
pogrom was a rumor that the Jews were responsible for the execution of prisoners by the Soviets before the 1941 Soviet withdrawal from Lviv. „The Encyclopedia of the Holocaust” states that some 4,000 Jews were kidnapped and killed at that time.
web.archive.org/web/2008021208…
pogrom was a rumor that the Jews were responsible for the execution of prisoners by the Soviets before the 1941 Soviet withdrawal from Lviv. „The Encyclopedia of the Holocaust” states that some 4,000 Jews were kidnapped and killed at that time.
web.archive.org/web/2008021208…
24).
[9] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepan_Ba…
pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepan_Ba…
przystanekhistoria.pl/pa2/teksty/801…
carlbeckpapers.pitt.edu/ojs/index.php/…
[10] pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grzegorz_…
ipn.gov.pl/download/1/255…
[11] pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grzegorz_…
polska1918-89.pl/pdf/antypolska…
polinst.kyiv.ua/storage/upa_ko…
zbrodniawolynska.pl/download/98/12…
[9] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepan_Ba…
pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepan_Ba…
przystanekhistoria.pl/pa2/teksty/801…
carlbeckpapers.pitt.edu/ojs/index.php/…
[10] pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grzegorz_…
ipn.gov.pl/download/1/255…
[11] pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grzegorz_…
polska1918-89.pl/pdf/antypolska…
polinst.kyiv.ua/storage/upa_ko…
zbrodniawolynska.pl/download/98/12…
25).
[12] pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fa%C5%82s…
[13] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timothy_D…
[14] pscourses.ucsd.edu/ps200b/Snyder%…
cambridge.org/core/journals/…
jstor.org/stable/3600827
[15]
[12] pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fa%C5%82s…
[13] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timothy_D…
[14] pscourses.ucsd.edu/ps200b/Snyder%…
cambridge.org/core/journals/…
jstor.org/stable/3600827
[15]
https://twitter.com/sumlenny/status/1508441140126748684?t=ZR-pe9-_IF8qDXr9sMryxg&s=19
https://twitter.com/lukachpp/status/1508825958224175108?t=aB8y9NkQBBC3IObvzjC0JQ&s=19
https://twitter.com/BrajanKot/status/1508894634847744004?t=aB8y9NkQBBC3IObvzjC0JQ&s=19
https://twitter.com/lukachpp/status/1508974725506154499?t=aB8y9NkQBBC3IObvzjC0JQ&s=19
26).
PS
PDF files can be translated using Xodo PDF Reader & Editor.
server.xodo.com
apps.microsoft.com/store/detail/x…
PS
PDF files can be translated using Xodo PDF Reader & Editor.
server.xodo.com
apps.microsoft.com/store/detail/x…
Please unroll @threadreaderapp. Thank you in advance 𓃠
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
