2/ We looked into Spotify’s subscriber and revenue numbers in the US and found a null boycott effect: Spotify’s subscribers continued to grow at a rate statistically indistinguishable from the pre-controversy trend.
3/ We discuss similarities and differences between the Goya and Spotify boycotts and important future directions of research in the political consumerism domain in this rejoinder: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cf…
4/ We thank Yphtach Lelkes @ylelkes, JP Dubé @jdube6, and Bart Bronnenberg @BartBronnenberg for their thoughtful commentary on our Goya paper that inspired this rejoinder. As well as Dan McCarthy @d_mccar and @earnestresearch for facilitating access to Spotify subscriber data.
Here are the commentaries on the original Goya paper:
1/ Is more privacy always better in digital advertising ecosystems?
Evidence is rapidly accumulating, suggesting that stricter privacy controls exacerbate inequality between large and small businesses.
Quick thread on recent papers that highlight this asymmetry
2/ @garjoh_canuck, Scott Shriver, and @samgarvingold find that stricter privacy controls hurt small vendors disproportionately, increasing market concentration and, thus, benefiting large players.
3/ In another paper, same authors show that small firms’ recorded revenue losses due to stricter privacy controls are about double those of large firms. This is due to starkly lower cookie consent rates among small firms