SCBA vice president Pradeep Rai: Justice Gupta' father was arrested in 1992 for being RSS chief, had opposed govt policies.
Later when ban lifted, FIR was quashed.
Justice Gupta is very hardworking, leaving his work many times he would research for others.
Rai: Fee was never a consideration for him. Has delivered many criminal law judgments, his friends remember him as one of the best human beings and aa a fitness freak. His aerobics trainer is now in Tripura.
Rai: Has been noticed for his bold judgments and interest in travelling and gardening. I do not know if his fitness freak nature is still there but earlier he used to go the gym everyday. He was part of first fully paperless bench. He speaks what he believes in
Rai: His wife will now be waiting for him in Chandigarh. Sir you have to enjoy your life, golf. You will have a wonderful life, we are grateful and happy to give you this farewell.
AG Venkataramani: I don't think we can hid farewell to any judge any point of time. Their moments are cherished, they enter with great expectations from us. I never thought I would be giving leave to a judge. But we have gathered here for that today. We always have our day in...
AG: his court. Must share with you a recent gift he gave me, I cherish that gift. In a temple administration matter, both sides aggressively fought. When matter came up for final hearing, we all were prepared for big battle like WWW.
AG: Matter was letter settled and compromised. Later one of the people working in the temple told me after i became AG, sir you served in the temple now God has served you.
AG: Honour and glory of our profession lies in extending our warm hearts to serve every part of this section. All of us are together in being soldiers and parts of this temple of justice. This collective effort matters. Thank Justice Gupta, look to him to keep being with us.
SCBA president Sr Adv Vikas Singh: it is a privilege for me to bid farewell to Justice Gupta, aan of extraordinary wit, substance, knowledge who is loved by the Bar.
Singh: Justice Gupta for a small place in the annexe of his family home to begin his practice rather than stay at his father's official Bungalow. That was his humble beginning.
Singh: He's very helpful, has maintained his original group of friends from school. His work never interfered in the personal bonds that he created. He is known for his hard work, erudition, will be deeply missed by the Bar. I know he will be there to guide us.
Chief Justice of India Uday Umesh Lalit: Many things came to my mind, when advocates said things before we rose. What Justice Gupta is feeling today, maybe three weeks later I will feel the same.
CJI: What makes Justice Hemanth Gupta even to go into the smallest details. Makes the best of whatever is there before him.
He was on the Bench with me and Justice Indu Malhotra, he was the only one using the laptop or whatever the device was. I am technologically challenged..
CJI: But Justice Gupta no wonder was digitally advanced and part of paperless courts. We have commonality that ends with coming from laywer families. He is far far greater than anyone of us including me.
CJI: What AG said is true, we do not bid farewell to judges. He will always be with us in his contributions. Woah you all the best Justice Hemant Gupta.
Justice Hemant Gupta: I no longer have any files to read or judgments rto dictate. I had a long journey that was enriching and challenging. Law is a challenging process, have learnt every day. Have had my share of lows, but am satisfied that ...
Justice Gupta: i have performed to the best of my ability without dear or fervour. Have not hid from deciding any matter. Decided lengthy matter of Kandahar hijacking.
Justice Gupta: One cannot be discharging his duties as a judge by trying to please people. I was harsh, blunt would sometimes lose my cool. I am not perfect, i may have erred. It was wholly unintentional. My future and third innings is still undecided but will remain in Delhi.
Justice Gupta: I thank my team of clerks and researchers, they would present their points happily. The common saying is there is a lady behind every successful person, for me that is my wife. She has supported me for 37 ... Sorry 35 years.
(Begins tearing up) It's hard to ...
Justice Gupta: Bid goodbye but it has to be done. Thank you everyone.
Justice MR Shah led bench to shortly hear the appeal filed by Maharashtra govt against the decision of the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court, acquitting former Delhi University professor #GNSaibaba in an alleged Maoist links case
In its appeal, the Maharashtra government has contended that the case was decided by the High Court on the procedural lapse without going into the merits of the evidence #GNSaibaba
Sr Adv Kapil Sibal appears for WhatsApp, ASG N Venkatraman for CCI.
Sibal: if a Constitutional court finds that my policy is okay and consistent with the law, this cannot go on. PDP bill is coming, SG told Constitution Bench to hear privacy policy matter in January.
A Varanasi Court today will pronounce its order on a plea filed by the 4 Hindu worshippers seeking directions to the Archaeological Survey of India to conduct 'scientific investigation' of Shiva Linga reportedly found in #GyanvapiMosque premises
Follow this thread for updates:
District Judge AK Vishvesha had reserved the order on October 11, after hearing the submissions filed by the Mosque Committee objecting to the plea moved by Hindi Worshippers' for 'scientific investigation' of the alleged Shiva Linga found during survey of #Gyanvapimosque
On October 7, the Court had sought clarification on certain questions, which are:
1) Whether Shiva Linga (reported to be found) inside #Gyanvapimosque premises is part of suit property or not?
2) Does court have power to direct 'scientific investigation' of alleged structure?
Chief Justice of India Uday Umesh Lalit sitting with Justice Hemant Gupta today. It is Justice Gupta's last day in court today.
Sr Adv Mukul Rohatgi: On behalf of the bar we wish Justice Gupta a very happy and successful second inning which will be in Delhi and Chandigarh. I wish lordship keeps coming to court and we have coffee
CJI UU Lalit: we are two senior most judges in this combination in terms of age. I will be in the same situation shortly.. parting is inevitable but it all depends on how you play when at it. I have known #JusticeHemantGupta since last 13 years and played a straight inning
#SupremeCourt hears a plea seeking a pre screening committee for web series
CJI UU Lalit: This court has been consistent that there is no pre-censorship. You have to say that the existing regime has censor certificate for cinema etc and whether it applies to OTT or not
CJI: For OTT Satellite transmission is from other countries and not this one even though viewers may be here. Post exhibition redressal mechanism is different. What is being said in this plea that what is being shown in OTT or over sattelite should also be under this scheme
Adv: Now the Mirzapur series is coming again
CJI: It was already broadcasted in October 2020
Adv: They are again coming with Mirzapur showing a city which is adulterous