Few important things going on in #agedcare lately:
1) Bupa ANZ continues to top our list of worst-performing aged care providers, with 39 sanctions & penalties in the last three years - and an underlying profit of $407m in FY2021 #auspol#agedcarerc theaustralian.com.au/nation/politic…
Those playing along at home will know Bupa has been besieged with abuse scandals, sanctions, and care failures. Its homes keep being reaccredited. Occasionally its funding is frozen. It does "apologise" every time, though, so there's that. #auspol abc.net.au/news/2022-08-1…
It's also been trying to offload its NZ #agedcare homes, with Macquarie Capital sounding out investors including EQT and a Japanese firm - but there were no takers. There's been chatter about it dumping its Australian homes in the past too #auspoltheaustralian.com.au/business/datar…
Then there's today's news: a new research report from StewartBrown indicating that 67% of the 1300 aged care homes it surveyed across the country are operating at a loss. SB has called for (yet another) emergency funding package #auspol#agedcaretheaustralian.com.au/nation/emergen…
(SB has also called for older Australians "who can afford it" to contribute even more to their cost of care, beyond hefty accom deposits and care fees. How is this tested? Should this involve making a spouse still living in the community sell their home, etc? I digress) #auspol
But point being: providers are again seeking more emergency funding, claiming they are at risk of collapse. And, as @SquigglyRick reported, providers are also being advised to "avoid" high-needs residents who cut into their profit margins #auspolthesaturdaypaper.com.au/news/politics/…
It's worth noting that the way that aged care subsidies are calculated and funded changed on Oct 1 to the AN-ACC model (an outcome of the Royal Commission) - which will likely ease pressure on providers as funding better reflects individuals' needs #auspolafr.com/wealth/persona…
But as always, the conversation about #agedcare is dominated by money. How can providers become profitable. Who ought to subsidise care. What standard we can afford. Very little emphasis in the policy discourse about our obligations to older people, and their rights #auspol
So important things are slipping through to the keeper, like malnutrition. Unfathomably, the Albanese government has left nutrition off its new set of quality indicators. 1 in 3 homes continues to spend less than $10 per resident per day on food #auspol theaustralian.com.au/nation/politic…
Improving nutrition standards in aged care was one of Labor's five key areas of aged care policy focus during the federal election. It's highly disappointing that that splashy announcement hasn't at minimum resulted in the introduction of a nutrition standard #auspol#agedcare
I understand (and felt) the optimism that with a change of government, there might be a different approach to aged care. But the government doesn't get a free pass on something as important as aged care nutrition standards. This is a quality of life issue for residents #auspol
It's important to return the conversation about aged care reform to the key question of the human rights of older people - which should not be subjected to the unedifying spectacle of politicians and economists squabbling over "what we can afford." #auspol#agedcare
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Ok, here goes. The election's tomorrow. Somehow there are still undecided voters out there. A definitive measure of any politician's leadership is how they care for our most vulnerable citizens - so let's look at Morrison's track record on aged care. Thread #auspol#ausvotes
When Morrison came to power, he inherited a raft of recommendations to fix aged care from past inquiries, including staffing ratios, pay raise, better regulation & more financial transparency. Rather than implementing these, he called a Royal Commission #auspol#ausvotes
The Royal Commission's interim report, handed down in October 2019, recommended 3 areas of urgent action that needed to be resolved imminently: clearing the home care waitlist, young people with disabilities trapped in aged care, and chemical and physical restraint #auspol
It's important to urgently clarify what the Royal Commission recommended re: Registered Nurses being on-site in aged care facilities 24/7, what the Morrison govt said in its RC response, and the different claim Anne Ruston made yesterday. Short thread #auspol
The RC made two key recommendations re: staffing. The first was a requirement of a minimum number of care minutes per resident per day, with a proportion of those to be delivered by an RN. The second was that an RN should be on-site in all aged care homes 24/7 #auspol#agedcare
Different types of nurses work in aged care, including enrolled nurses & RNs. The RC recommended RNs on-site 24/7 in particular because RNs are highly trained, can administer pain medications, and their presence reduces hospital transfers & enhances palliative care #auspol
16 Sept 2018: Morrison calls Royal Commission
31 Oct 2019: Interim Report, "Neglect"
1 Mar 2021: Final Report. PM holds press conference, but gives journos no time to read it
11 May 2021: Government buries its "response" to Final Report on budget day #auspol
Feb 2022: More than 3 years after Morrison called the Royal Commission, and almost a year since the final report, the sector is in the worst crisis in its history, Colbeck apparently still has no idea what's happening in his own portfolio, and the PM is off washing hair #auspol
Morrison called the Aged Care Royal Commission not because he wanted to, but because he was in damage control mode the day before a searing @4corners episode was about to air. His motivation for calling the RC was as shallow as his commitment to fixing the sector's issues #auspol
Re: @Senator_Patrick’s calls for a Royal Commission into Australia’s COVID response:
We’ve just had a $120m+ 3 yr RC into #agedcare. Morrison is yet to front a presser & answer questions about its recs. Reform-wise, the govt has cherry-picked easy fixes w/ no scrutiny #auspol
The thing about RCs and inquiries is they’ve got to produce systemic change. Otherwise they’re expensive fact-finding missions that tell us what we already know.
Look at all 17 major inquiries into aged care preceding the RC. All identified the same issues and made similar recs.
What’s the Morrison govt’s score card in implementing major reforms after its own RCs?
Abysmal.
Banking RC? More than half Hayne’s recommendations abandoned or not implemented. Aged care RC? Major recs like on-site nurses 24/7 rejected. Not even a presser from the PM. #auspol
The Commonwealth's response to the aged care crisis over many years has been to roll out successive "funding boosts."
The sector needs a complete overhaul, not a $10bn payday. Where is the federal government's commitment to a new Aged Care Act? #auspol#agedcarerc
It's been two months since the #agedcarerc's final report.
The totality of the Morrison govt's response to the report has been an initial announcement of a circa $452m "funding boost," and now this leaked preview of the budget, with a further $10bn "funding boost". #auspol
So the minister who had NO PLAN to prevent outbreaks in aged care, made PPE training voluntary, put no policy in place regarding hospital transfers, and didn't even know the numbers of deaths, is now pointing fingers.
- Put no national plan in place for COVID in aged care
- Couldn't even say whether he'd briefed Cabinet about the Royal Commission's interim report
- Did not know the number of aged care deaths in Senate hearings - not once, but TWICE
- Implemented no meaningful changes after the fatal outbreaks at Newmarch House and Dorothy Henderson Lodge
- Failed to consider how the existing failures in aged care would exacerbate the threat posed by COVID outbreaks
- Failed to provide expert infection control to facilities