European Union imports of Russian natural gas in 2022 will be down to around 60 bcm. The last time they were so low was in 1984. Here are some insights on where we go from here, using our latest @IEA#WEO2022 projections
What happens next with Russian gas is obviously uncertain, but as @tim_gould_ said at the WEO launch yesterday, we assume that there’s no way back for the EU-Russia gas relationship. That relationship was built up over many decades on the basis of trust. And that trust has gone.
In STEPS, we project a continued reduction in the EU's reliance on Russian gas. By 2030, imports are 90% lower. In APS, they are 0 before 2030. This is not easy; to avoid destructive demand reductions or price volatility, a huge scale up in clean energy (and LNG imports) needed
Wind and solar capacity has to increase by 600 GW by 2030. This is the major driver for a reduction in gas use in the power sector. Building retrofits accelerate and heat pumps need to be in one‐third of the EU building stock. A big dollop of hydrogen and biomethane also needed.
Europe also has to source more LNG and pipeline gas. The dilemma is whether to rely on the spot market or contract long-term supplies from either existing or new projects. Either way, anywhere from 70-170 bcm of gas needs to be bought in – even with rapidly declining gas demand.
That's a tough sell for EU gas buyers, who have huge near-term needs for more LNG but way less visibility on future demand. One way to resolve this is to shorten payback periods for new projects to 10 years (instead of 20), but this would raise the long-run cost of LNG by 20%.
Greater investment in clean energy to transition from gas is required, but this provides a big boost to energy security and ends up saving a lot of money. Cumulatively to 2050, the EU banks a $350 billion net saving compared to the STEPS, because of lower natural gas import costs
A lot of caveats come with this assessment - in practice, Russian gas can go to zero from next year. But the EU is already now pulling together the building blocks for a more resilient clean energy future.
And the loser over the long-term will be Russia. $1 trillion of lost income this decade, and no easy options to get its European gas to other consumers: in our projections, softening gas demand in China means the case for another large-scale gas pipeline is questionable, at best.
It was, as ever, a privilege to be part of the formidable #WEO team pulling together the long-term picture. Lots more gas-related stuff to unpick here (with awesome infographics!) iea.org/reports/world-…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Everybody is staring in disbelief at European #gasprices. If the gas market is broken as many have been saying, it would most visibly be seen in the TTF benchmark. Here are my two cents (warning, lots of correlations ahead!)
The main explanation for the much higher level of TTF is the fear premium brought about by Russia’s withholding of supply (pre-invasion), tight LNG markets and very low EU storage. But TTF really is off the charts. Fundamentally, is gas really worth the equivalent of $200/bbl?
The model I use to assess European gas prices says no. It’s a simple model that back-casts EU prices based on an US LNG export margins and a 6-9 month lag on Brent. The rationale is that gas prices in Europe should reflect a bit of oil indexation and the cost of spot LNG.
The focus of Europe’s gas supply crunch has mostly been on storage levels, Russian imports, and LNG. That makes sense, because the crisis is an acute one, and is mainly due to supply problems. But what about the longer-term? What can be done to reduce future vulnerability? 1/10
Recognising the importance of storage is of course crucial, and supply diversity is likewise essential for security of supply. But demand has been less of a focus, except when we hear about curtailed factory output or gas-to-coal switching in the power sector.
Insofar as we talk about the medium-term, it's mostly about gas' essential role as a dispatchable, flexible source of power generation (esp. as renewables grow and coal/nuclear come offline)
A thread on today's crazy high #naturalgas prices, with a few thoughts on long-term implications:
Gas prices have been on a wild ride of late. Several price benchmarks are sky-high. In Europe, the main spot price benchmark (the “TTF”) is a whopping €50/MWh ($17.5/MBtu). That’s never happened before. Various indices tell us Asian spot prices are above $15/MBtu, too. Yikes.
These spot prices are telling us markets are tight. Lots of reasons for this, from factory output rebounding in Asia to aircon use during heat waves to high European carbon prices pushing more gas into the power stack. Storage is low. Supply is gummed up here and there.
I’m trying to lose weight, which is kind of like trying to address #climatechange. I made a bunch of pledges to myself at my very own COP35 before Christmas 2019. But how can I do it, and will I succeed? 1/11
A diet is about finding the right balance between energy demand and supply. I can reduce my consumption, switch to healthier fuels (less ‘fossil’ varieties, more ‘greens’). I can also exercise, making everything more #energyefficient. Setting targets is also important. 2/11
But by golly, it’s hard to fit all this in when I also have to maintain a job, an apartment, pay bills, keep relationships… there’s more to life than fretting about the climate (um, I mean, my health). 3/11