#SexMatters in life & law and it shouldn’t take courage to say so.
But right now, a whole lot of courage, resilience & resources are going into unpicking the mess created by the law that allowed some men to become women for “all purposes”
🧵
Arguments are coming to a head in Scotland, where Nicola Sturgeon is pressing ahead with the Gender Recognition Reform Bill on an accelerated timetable, despite dissent and questions about how it will impact on the rights of Scottish girls and women.
2/15 thetimes.co.uk/article/jk-row…
Meanwhile, @ForWomenScot’s case against the Scottish Government’s current interpretation of the GRA is being heard.
We think the FWS position is robust and hope this legal challenge succeeds. If it does, the effects will ripple through the law more broadly.
But there also needs to be legislative clarity. It should not be this difficult to work out what the law means…
4/15
…and that is why we are pushing the question back to Parliament.
This approach is complementary to the FWS case, and is also a backstop against the damage that gender self-ID will cause if it is implemented in Scotland.
Sex Matters is a human-rights organisation.
We think that the human-rights framework is the way to answer the question of how society should accommodate people with gender issues, while also protecting sex-based rights.
9/15 sex-matters.org/posts/updates/…
A significant part of how we win the peace in the “TERF wars” will come through legal clarification. But a larger part will come through people talking, in ordinary everyday language, enabled by legal protection to do that.
10/15
“The gender mess and the freedom of speech mess are inextricably linked.” writes @HJoyceGender.
The way we resolve both is by refusing to be silenced, or to silence others.
I was excited to hear that a group of civil servants have launched an official staff network:
the Sex Equality and Equity Network.
They are “committed to the protected belief that biological sex is binary and immutable, that biological sex matters…
12/15
…for both women and men in our everyday lives, including for our rights and needs in the workplace, and that biological sex must not be conflated with, or replaced by, the concepts of gender or gender identity”.
Finally. World Toilet Day is coming up and we are holding a webinar with @rosegeorge3, author of The Big Necessity.
Toilets are one of those places where everyone needs to be included, with dignity, privacy, clarity, and with words and symbols that are understandable to everyone.
Rose has travelled the world looking at toilets.
I promise this is going to be fascinating!
This week, we at Sex Matters have been thinking about the plight of parents blindsided when their children declare a trans identity seemingly out of nowhere.
This has been happening for years, but from what we hear, numbers seem to have exploded.
🧵1/9
That chimes with data from the GIDS clinic at the Tavistock, which saw an unsurprising downturn during pandemic lockdowns, followed by an extraordinary rebound in the past year. 2/9
Our survey of secondary-school teachers found that four out of five of them have at least one trans-identifying child in school. In many schools there are dozens, with clusters in friendship groups. 3/9 sex-matters.org/posts/updates/…
“We’re seeing a linguistic sleight of hand in which what used to be called ‘protection’ is recast as ‘segregation’”, writes Sex Matters Advisory Group member Joan Smith @polblonde… unherd.com/thepost/the-at…
“No amount of support for girls’ and women’s sport can eliminate the fact that men are more muscular than women, while women are just over half as strong as men in their upper bodies and have about two-thirds as much strength in their lower bodies.”
“The obvious solution, which is to have women’s, men’s and open sports categories, is anathema to gender extremists because it doesn’t achieve the aim of eliminating single-sex spaces — sorry, I mean challenging the strict gender binary.”
From our live notes of the evidence of the Allison Bailey v Stonewall Equality Limited and Garden Court Chambers Case – cross-examination of Kirrin Medcalf, 10th May 2022
The Stonewall scheme is an authoritarian system of thought control that actively undermines the freedom of expression and self-determination of anyone whose beliefs differ from Stonewall’s, including lesbian, gay, bisexual and transsexual employees.
26% of Britons say they strongly agree “trans women are women, trans men are men”. 20% somewhat agree, 22% don’t know, 12% somewhat disagree and 18% strongly disagree.
More in Common asked the question vaguely, and it seems like what most people interpreted was "post op"