Itihasika Profile picture
Nov 14, 2022 16 tweets 6 min read Read on X
(1/16) Glorified by some & vilified by some. #Nehru's legacy is complex. Read on for a data centric report card. Sorry no spicy stories Edwina/Padmaja Naidu. We're professional not personal. If bhakts & kambhakts fight over #Nehru in ur whatsapp groups share this thread with them
(2/16) We evaluate the KPIs of 16.7 years of strictly PM years with report card in last tweet. We assume that a person that spent 10 years in jail & was a relentless freedom fighter won't have bad intent. But the road to hell is paved with good intentions–read on
(3/16) Nehru was undemocratically imposed by Gandhian veto but was PM from 1947 to 1966. He inherited an India ravaged by colonial excesses. Fair comparison would be how he fared in the economic/HDI/security vs other equivalent countries with similar numbers & colonial baggage
(4/16) Let's clarify 3 definitions first to avoid confusion. 1) GDP growth=Total GDP growth of a country 2) GDP share of world=what % of the world's GDP belongs to the country c) GDP per capita=How much money does an individual have on average. Related but different indicators
(5/16) Pictures below from source ourworldindata.org with multiple sources says it all. So does the famous Angus Madison study. India's numbers abysmal in Nehru years even when compared to countries like Philippines, Malaysia & Burma
(6/16) Look at India's foreign reserves & imports vs exports. Both hug the X axis through Nehru's time period. Abject failure of trade & manufacturing. The socialist 5 years plans & grand openings of PSU were not helping. His PSUs were ultimately loss making & toxic for taxpayers
(7/16) Nehru once told Raja Rao: "Enough of Rama, Krishna. 3,000 year of deities got us slavery, poverty" Look at the 2000 year economic history. It's clear that India's share of world GDP was highest when we were worshipping "Rama-Krishna". Nehru got it wrong
(8/16) The graph shows that through the literacy rate went from approx 10% to 20% it was way behind even equally poor country like China. A basic check for other south Asian countries will also show how they surged while India lagged. But he set up IITs & AIIMS right? Read on
9/16) Nehru did not create IITs. Dr BC Roy, CM of West Bengal, set up first IIT in Cal in 1950. Soviet Union set up IIT Powai; US set up IIT Kanpur; Germans set up IIT Madras. And he did not start "scientific temper" either. Look @ picture below – all started before him.
(10/16) No he did not start AIIMS either. It was completely the brainchild & hard work of Rajkumari Amrit Kaur the first health minister. PM just happened to be Nehru. Amrit Kaur was not even his choice for cabinet ministry. She was a Congress Critic.
(11/16) But Nehru revolutionized agriculture isn’t it? Sadly no. Green revolution was started by Shastri after deviating from Nehruvian policy and white revolution even later in 70s. Nehru had little or nothing to do with Indian food self-sufficiency
(12/16) Foreign policy complete disaster– Lost 1/3rd India to Pakistan between 1937 to 1947, lost 2/3rd Kashmir by going to UN, lost Aksai Chin, lost China war, lost Gwadar, lost Balochistan, imposed Article 370, rejected permanent UN seat & Muslim personal law board
(13/16) Soft Power – Unspeakable mess – Tried to stop Somnath, tried to sell snake charmer image, thought of himself as "carryover saheb", mocked low GDP growth as "Hindu" rate of growth, created conflict via linguistic division of states
(14/16) Perhaps the only shining light in the long list of blunders is his genuine empowerment of democracy. In 1947 barely 16% could vote so he could have easily attempted to become dictator. But he was a Fabian idealist & in 1951-52 brought in Universal Adult Franchise
(15/16) Nehru is not just a man but a "spirit" – the "spirit" that symbolizes a colonial continuity. Whether India survives or not in its current cultural form depends on whether Nehru spirit is implanted in next gen mind. Which makes it critical to spread this tweet.
(16/16) In summary the score is D-. However Nehru was shaped by his circumstances and personality type. In a democracy the PM is merely a manifestation of the people's collective consciousness. Nehru was democratically elected 3 times. Hence ultimately it's the people's fault

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Itihasika

Itihasika Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @itihasika

Jun 18
Toxic food & sedentary life in North America & urban India causes obesity & related diseases

We all know about coke, candy & chips being bad but you’ll be shocked how junk is masked in regular everyday eatables

Don’t miss this thread if value your health & want practical tips Image
Seed oils - This one is a killer that hardly anyone is aware

Did you know that till few decades ago vegetable oils that today is commonly used in home and restaurant cooking was considered industrial waste? Image
Sunflower, corn, safflower oil for cooking also found in all packaged food will ensure early death for you

You need to take special effort & replace this with extra virgin olive oil,
avocado oil, organic ghee or beef tallow

Makes world of a difference Image
Read 18 tweets
Jun 13
Dire civilizational warning - if you read one thread today let it be this one. Your future is on the line & honestly it doesn’t look too bullish for Hindus in India.

Using a real life anecdote from today I’ll show you how situation is no different from elections of British India in 1937 & 1946

Save this tweet for 2029Image
A childhood friend who’s now a successful businessman was in town & we met for a quick 20 mins

He’s very involved with BJP & close to one candidate who had been given an MP ticket as he had a good track record of winning MLA seats. This particular MP constituency had approx 5 MLA constituencies with one M majority area.Image
Because of his track record BJP candidate assumed easy victory.

And surprise - He lost.

Why? In 4 areas he did get higher % of votes but in the 1 M area the % against him was so overwhelming that his gain in other 4 areas was fully erased. Image
Read 14 tweets
Jun 12
This thread is unique & different from our regular ones

A list of existential questions. Would appreciate if you can provide a logical, spiritual, faith based (any faith) or scientific answers to these

If possible please keep answer simple enough for avg brain to process Image
If there is a creator then who created the creator?

If someone fled then where does chain end?

If no one did then how does creator exist? Image
Why did the creator create?

How would it have been any different if nothing was created & there was pure emptiness?

What was the compelling need to design samsara like a karmic points based video game? Image
Read 8 tweets
Jun 3
Every Hindu who thinks you'll automatically survive forever just because your dharma is "sanatan" (timeless) should read this unmissable thread

A brief history of Parsis (Zoroastrians) who once held sway over an area almost as big as India but near extinct today

Learning lessonImage
1700 BCE: Origins - Zathurashtra (founder and prophet of Parsis) imparts the principles of Zoroastrianism in Central Asia, believed to have occurred between 1700 and 1000 BCE.Image
550 BCE: Expansion - Cyrus the Great establishes the Achaemenian Empire, promoting Zoroastrianism as its predominant faith, leading to its unprecedented growth and territorial expansion.Image
Read 13 tweets
May 24
1/14 What's the fundamental difference in organized Abrahamic faiths vs Hinduism?

Why did Hindus lose 50% land & mind share but didn't die out?

Don't miss this thread that combines history, human psychology and philosophy to answer basic civilizational questionsImage
2/14 Most influencers, handles or narratives present a unidimensional view of history and human interactions i.e. the group they identify with is all good and adversarial groups are all bad.

But in reality history is multi-layered & humans are multidimensionalImage
3/14 Humans if left without a domineering framework will pursue self interest first

For example a lot of Hindus allied with Mughals. Sikhs on occasion have allied with British & Mughals have fought Afghans, Christian armies have fought genocidal wars etc.Image
Read 14 tweets
May 22
Why did Marathas & Sikhs not join hands against Afghans & British?

History is shockingly complicated - Don't miss this thread

Mughal empire was demolished by 1717

By 1750 Marathas ruled India & Sikh misls controlled Punjab.

Why didn't they join hands?Image
Mughals were Maratha vassals but still retained revenue rights over Delhi

There was a Mughal governor called Adina Beg who was struggling against invading Afghans under Ahmedshah Abdali

We think of Sikhs Marathas as mortal enemies of Mughals but truth has layers and nuancesImage
Yes on a broader spectrum Mughals were enemies for both Sikhs and Marathas.

However at local levels there were complicated equations and power struggles

Adina Beg was once supported by Sikh generals Jassa Singh and Vadbhag Singh against the Afghans and got a temporary respiteImage
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(