This #TransAwarenessWeek let's talk about dehumanisation and how it works. It starts with what might seem like a mild proposal. That a certain group of people are different and should be excluded. Not hurt, just excluded.
The difference then needs to be justified. An easy way to do this is to point to some aspect of that person's physical body. That's just nature right? No judgement involved just a natural category. But they're definitely different.
Some people protest at this, why should we exclude people because of a characteristic they can't change? So a second justification is brought into play, that these people are a threat. They point to members of the group who have done bad things.
But some protest - those are just individuals. The rest of the group isn't responsible. So then a third reason comes into play. That the group have a powerful controlling cabal, who have a plan to take control. Finally the waverers are convinced. It's clear the group is a threat
The group of people are now other, and any treatment of them is justified. We must eliminate them from society for everybody's protection. They threaten everybody, especially children.
You probably recognise this process that has played out numerous times over human history. But we seemingly never learn from it. We should, and we should stop repeating it.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It's difficult to understand why, if their aim is prisoner welfare, organisation such as KPSS are campaigning on the single issue of trans women in prison when there are multiple threats to women prisoners safety and wellbeing. kpssinfo.org/whats-the-prob…
Evidence submitted to Parlaiment by Keep Prisons single sex, includes testimony by Rhona Hotchkiss, a former governor of Cornton Vale Prison.
That sounds shocking, and we can understand Ms Hotchkiss's position, but it's hardly the only problem Cornton Vale prison faced. Just this year there was a sudden death. news.stv.tv/west-central/w…
Our worst convicted serial rapist raped men - 159 known victims. Men are twice as likely to be murdered as women. The most likely victims of street violence are young men. And men attack other men in prison.
Gay men and trans women are particularly susceptible to rape in men's prisons. That's why putting all trans women in men's prisons doesn't stop raoe. That doesn't mean trans women who pose a risk to women should be in the woman's estate given free reign it means risk assessment.
At the moment a cis woman who poses a risk to other women prisoners goes to a woman's prison. Most prison violence is cis prisoners attacking cis prisoners. To say only trans people present a risk or make prisoners are safe is ridiculous.
We're very committed to the principles of 'robust democratic debate' @Womans_Place_UK . Are you? Are you prepared to discuss the harm done to women by telling us our role in life is childbirth? Or not?
Are you prepared to discuss how biological essentialism of this type props up the patriarchy? Women are people, some want to be parents and we support them completely, we also support women who don't. We think that support needs to last a lifetime, it doesn't end at birth.
Are you prepared to discuss how it can ever be justified to say women's lives are mapped out for them by their reproductive capacity? Or saying anyone's life is mapped out for them by an accident of our birth?
Some are admitting the links between trans exclusion and the far right without addressing the reason the movement appeals to the far right - it allows repressive views of gender to be misrespresented as feminism. There is no left/feminist justification for anti trans activism
It is justified in terms of women's trauma and women's autonomy without acknowledging both these can be respected without attacking trans people. The anti trans movement will harm all women the more it is allowed to flourish. It's essentially conservative.
A narrow focus on trans exclusion conveniently allows the real problems of male violence to be ignored. The anti trans movement exhorts us to 'keep prisons single sex' without questioning the conditions in prison or why women are in prison at all.
We are women who do not believe trans people threaten women's rights. Our feminism's aims are reproductive freedom, an end to gender based violence, economic equality, bodily autonomy and freedom from oppression for all people
Claims trans people threaten womens rights allow anti feminist groups to hijack feminism for anti women agendas. Patriarchal, essentialist definitions of women are used by anti trans groups who also oppose reproductive freedom to falsely claim they support women.
Anti trans groups and individuals do not speak for women or feminism, our feminism is about liberation, not oppression. We oppose calls to limit transition, healthcare and remove existing legal rights as an attack on trans peoples human rights.