1/ Interesting things appear to be happening currently on the Kinburn Peninsula (often erroneously called the Kinburn Spit), south-west of Kherson. Although exactly what is still uncertain, it's worth taking a look at why Kinburn matters.
2/ The Kinburn Peninsula is the hook-shaped peninsula at the mouth of the Dnieper Estuary. It's about 40 km (25 mi) long and about 9 km (6 mi) wide. The Kinburn Spit is the narrow curving 'tail', 8.5 km long, that extends into the estuary at the far west end of the peninsula.
3/ The peninsula is flat and sandy, with many small lakes and salt marshes. It's partly wooded with oaks and pines. There are only four small villages on the peninsula with about 850 pre-war inhabitants. Oddly, the border between Mykolaiv and Kherson oblasts runs between them.
4/ Most of the peninsula is uninhabited. It's the site of a number of rare natural habitats, protected by the National Park "Biloberezhia Sviatoslava". Before the war, it was a popular place for hydrofoil trips from Kherson, beach holidays, camping and wilderness hiking.
5/ Sadly the peninsula has been badly affected by the current war. Large areas of forest have been burned, and fragile habitats are likely to have been badly damaged by military vehicles.
6/ The peninsula has always had strategic importance. Herodotus visited it in the 5th century BC, when it was known as Gilea ("Forest"). Its modern name comes from the 15th century Turkish fortress of Kilburun ("Beautiful Pole"), which was located on the spit.
7/ Kilburun/Kinburn Fort was fought over several times in the 17th century before it was captured by Russia in 1774. The Anglo-French fleet attacked and captured it in October 1855 during the Crimean War, and it was demolished under the terms of the subsequent peace agreement.
8/ Why is Kinburn so important? The strait between the spit and the north shore at Ochakiv is only 4km wide. As this map shows, it overlooks the entrances to both the Dnieper and to the Southern Bug river. It therefore controls access to Mykolaiv and Kherson ports.
9/ Another important factor is that the peninsula is the most westerly mainland point Russia has reached in its invasion of Ukraine. It's the nearest occupied territory to Odesa, 60 km away, and overlooks most of Ukraine's remaining routes into the Black Sea.
10/ For some reason Russia did not take control of the peninsula until around 10 June, three months after capturing the rest of Kherson oblast south of the Dnieper. It's not clear whether Ukraine had any forces there at the time.
11/ The Russian advance on Kinburn enabled it to launch missiles at Ochakiv port, capsizing the Ukrainian anti-submarine corvette Vinnytsia. The 81m landing ship Yury Olefirenko was filmed making a narrow escape under Russian bombardment.
12/ Russia soon turned Kinburn into a military base. Artillery, rockets and Iranian-made drones have all reportedly been fired from there. The peninsula and spit were fortified to blockade the strait and shell Ochakiv and the Ukrainian-held Pervomayskiy Island in the strait.
13/ The man in this propaganda video is mercenary commander Alexei Kondratyev, leader of the 'Don' Cossack Brigade of the Redut private military company. It appears that, at least in October-November 2022, Kinburn was held by Redut.
14/ Ukraine likely tried to probe Russian defences on Kinburn before the recent liberation of Kherson. Kirill Stremousov, the recently deceased head of the Russian administration in Kherson, claimed to have defeated a special forces raid in September.
15/ It's unclear what's been going on lately but unconfirmed reports and video appear to show amphibious armoured vehicles and/or boats crossing the Kinburn Strait at night, most likely from Ochakiv.
16/ Ukraine likely aims to stop Russia using the peninsula as a fire base. The fall of Kherson likely makes the peninsula untenable anyway, as it's now within artillery range from the Ukrainian-held north side of the Dnieper.
17/ What will happen next is not yet clear. Satellite images suggest that the Russians have set up new defensive lines at the neck of the peninsula.
18/ As @NLwartracker points out, though, the new defences are also within artillery range and the restrictive terrain makes movement difficult. So I would not expect these defences to last long against a determined attacker.
19/ It's possible, if the Ukrainians are feeling ambitious, that they could push further east to bypass the lines of defence that the Russians have set up in the rest of Kherson oblast. But that's speculation – we'll have to wait for official announcements. /end
1/ Hardline Russian nationalists and war supporters have reacted with hostility to the Dmitriev-Witkoff peace proposals. Igor 'Strelkov' Girkin's detailed critique is of particular interest, as it is likely representative of this powerful faction's views. ⬇️
2/ Girkin's comments provide an insight into the fine line that Putin is having to walk between reaching a settlement that he can accept and one that the hardliners will accept. Putin likely agrees with many of their objections, but knows that they are unachievable.
3/ Girkin says, in a letter from his prison, that a correspondent has sent him the leaked list of the plan's 28 points (which he says have not been published in the Russian media). He is aware that subsequent US-Ukraine talks have reduced them to 19 points, but observes sourly:
1/ Igor 'Strelkov' Girkin is sceptical of "the mega-crook Donald and his cronies" and is confident there won't be a peace deal soon. In a fresh missive from prison, he draws attention to the Zaporizhzhia front, but says that Russia is unable to exploit successes there. ⬇️
2/ Replying to an earlier letter from a friend, he comments:
"Now we have yet another “sweet expectation of a quick and inevitable deal” (that is, a “compromise”), inspired by the statements of the mega-crook Donald and his cronies."
3/ "Naturally, my assessment of the situation hasn't changed at all: I'm confident there won't be a fixed deal, as we failed to achieve successes during the entire summer-fall campaign that went beyond the operational (at most, in isolated areas, but mostly beyond tactical).
1/ Russian State Duma deputy and surgeon Badma Bashankaev boasts that wounded Russian soldiers enjoy a 96% survival rate. Russian warbloggers point out, however, that only the lightly wounded usually get treated; most seriously injured Russians die on the battlefield. ⬇️
2/ Badma Bashankaev is a fervent supporter of Russia's war effort and represents Putin's United Russia party in the State Duma. He has recently appeared in an interview with state news agency TASS speaking about Russia's ostensible success in treating wounded soldiers.
3/ Russian warbloggers, however, are sceptical. Ilya Ovsyannikov writes in his 'INSTRUCTOR'S NOTES' Telegram channel that: "These statistics only show that the seriously wounded are not being transported and that they cannot organize a mass evacuation!!!"
1/ While Russia is making incremental advances in the Zaporizhzhia region, Russian soldiers say that it's resulting in carnage among their units. Conditions at Stepnohirsk are said to be dire, with entire battalions virtually wiped out. ⬇️
2/ Russian soldiers fighting at Stepnohirsk on the road to Zaporizhzhia city have told the 'Brothers in Arms' Telegram channel that "the situation there is, to put it mildly, dire."
3/ "The battalion has been practically wiped out. Only company and platoon commanders, sergeants majors, and clerks remain. The rest are reinforcements who arrive, complete the training ground, and immediately go on to storm Stepnohirsk."
1/ Igor 'Strelkov' Girkin warns from his jail cell that Ukraine and the EU have no reason to accept the Dmitriev-Witkoff proposals to end the war, because Russia is currently incapable of inflicting a strategic defeat on Ukraine, despite local tactical victories. ⬇️
2/ The imprisoned Girkin has posted a lengthy analysis of the context of the 28-point plan (he says that he has not yet read the full content of the points, "which our media modestly remained silent about").
3/ In a perspective which likely reflects that of powerful factions within the Russian security establishment (with which he has been closely linked), he sees the situation as overall negative for Russia, with the fiasco surrounding the plan hurting its own people's morale:
1/ Russian soldiers are complaining that if they fall foul of military regulations in any way – such as having only 1 litre of water in their car instead of 2, or wearing a non-regulation patch – they face being arrested by the military police and forced into an assault squad. ⬇️
2/ The notoriously corrupt Russian military police have been hated and feared by Russian soldiers throughout the Ukraine war for their brutality and larceny. To the soldiers' frustration, they are now reportedly dragging men off to die in assault squads for petty infractions.
3/ A correspondent writes to the 'Vault No. 8' Telegram channel:
"Requirements for military drivers at the border (Rovenki checkpoint and others), what must be in the cabin:
- 2 litres of bottled water.
- Engine oil.
- Regulation winter uniform for military personnel."