I hope that I’m charming
I hope that I’m pretty
I hope someone asks me to dance
I hope that the man of my dreams will appear
And that I will merit a glance
I hope that the hormones will not make me sick
And surgery won’t make me die
I hope that the sacrifice, sorrow and pain are not for one soul-crushing lie
I hope that I’m strong
I hope that I’m handsome
I hope for a masculine stance
I hope that the boy who had felt up my chest will never twice spare me a glance
I hope that the hormones will give me the power
And surgery makes me more plain
I hope that nobody will treat me like women are treated again and again
2022 has had some incredible pieces on the state of transgender medicine. I say without irony that the following might be the most important thing written.
A young woman detailed her experience with chest masculinization surgery with Dr. Sidhbh Gallagher in Miami. In July, she mocked previous victims of reckless transgender surgeons and clinicians. In August, she had surgery. Her words follow. (do not contact her)
In July, she was mocking people who had bad outcomes with gender affirming care. She banters with her friends about how ridiculous the complainers are.
Why would a growing number of "nonbinary youth" not want to mature into either male or female bodies?
There is *obviously* something psychological at work here. These young people *obviously* have some development delay (as I did).
They aren't "innately" trans. They need help.
It is so clear and obvious on its face that this is a patient population that is suffering social and psychological distress, and the adults in the room are doing the medical version of handing a toddler an iPad for a babysitter. It's malpractice.
Emma says that he wouldn't like his body at all. He's only 11 years old, but he has been "affirmed" by his family since he was six.
He has no way of knowing whether he'd like his body at all, and it won't be until adulthood that he starts to grapple with these consequences.
If you're trans, and you're touched in a way that you didn't consent to, don't subject other trans people to carceral punishment or police brutality. Instead, use community-enforced accountability measures.
If you call the police, you are a fascist who cannot be trusted.
Trans people refer to non-trans people as “cis.” The laws and systems cis people follow are referred to as the “cishetero patriarchy.” Cis people are accordingly also called “cishets.”
This oppressive system is merely a replaceable social construct.
Anyone who has ever bothered to have a conversation with a detransitioner and who knows anything a out “ex-gays” knows that there is nothing in common. For people like Erin, I guess I ought to explain.
The “ex-gay” movement was almost singularly a religious movement. Groups like Exodus International promised gays and lesbians who were extremely conflicted a chance to be redeemed through Christian faith.
The ex-gay movement was also near it’s peak near the time of the height of the AIDS epidemic and at a boiling point in the culture war as conservatives were trying to shove down the movement for gay marriage.
The very "best" trans research shows:
* Pre-pubescent children will desist if not transtioned
* ... But they PERSIST if they are transitioned
* Modest improvements to mood in the short term
* ... But they are under constant care and attention, so it's hard to know the cause
* There likely ARE brain differences between pre-pubescents who identify as trans and who don't
* ... But this MIGHT be correlated with sexual orientation
* ... And it's easier to explain this as ordinary human variance, not innate transgenderism
* Adolescents who transition have a higher rate of "minority threat stress"
* Adolescents who transition also commonly have (often untreated) co-morbid mental disorders
* 10x greater prevalence of autism than in the general population
I transitioned 30 years ago. There's never been a time with greater public or government support for "trans people" like me. In fact, even the conservative SCOTUS ruled in favor of "trans rights."
And yet, trans activists claim we're in the midst of a "trans genocide." Perverse.
It is a perversion of history. I am of Jewish lineage. My father's parents left Krakow in the early 20th century, and an unknown number of my relatives surely fell to the Nazi pogrom.
Trans genocide? Preposterous.
It is a perversion of justice. There are many people on the margins of society who identify as transgender. They are in a state of poverty and often in a state of drug addiction and are victims of human trafficking.
And yet, the activists bandy about the term "genocide." Fools.