Rapid FactCheck: The city's Daily Shelter & Occupancy Service Usage is "a daily snapshot of the occupancy and capacity of the system".
Specifically, on Dec 6 2021, Sinead Canavan, Project Director, Issues Mgmt for SSHA, speaking on behalf of General Manager Gord Tanner, said: 1/
"The actual capacity figures reported in the Daily Shelter & Overnight Service Usage report reflect the number of rooms or beds/spaces online in SMIS at 4:00 a.m. Rooms under renovation would not be included in this data, as they would be taken offline in SMIS."
2/
I have treated the numbers as only "online" beds were counted based on this written statement from a Shelter, Support and Housing Administration Director speaking on behalf of the organization.
Lie.
3/
In today's @TorontoStar, @_VictoriaGibson reports the City told her daily bed counts are “not a good reflection” of reality: it can include offline rooms - including decommissioned shelter hotels, rooms being cleaned, repaired, etc.
@_VictoriaGibson specifically asked about the Bond Hotel - where @BondResidentsTO have been especially vocal. The City told me in writing that those beds were not included in the official numbers a year ago but now it comes out those exact beds could've been counted all along
5/
@c_shadowspaces says: misleading numbers “sends the message that they have things under control, that if people did just really want services they could just call again and again … things are OK and it’s not a crisis, when it’s been a crisis for a long time.”
6/
This is why we fought for and the turn-away data to be recorded and made public in the first place.
But we don't just need data, we need action. @shelleycarroll's now the Chair of the ECDC - in charge of shelters. It meets in Jan. Approx 1/2 the non-family shelter system is closing by the end of April. Will they over evict 2500 people to nowhere? #NoClosures #HousingForAll
8/
The City of Toronto & Refugees in the Shelter: A Brief History 🧵
2013: Toronto passes a Sanctuary City motion “ensuring access to services without fear to immigrants without full status or without full status documents.” 1/ secure.toronto.ca/council/agenda…
City departments, incl. Shelter Support and Housing Admin (SSHA), implement “don’t ask don’t tell” around immigration status (unless required by law) (no source for this part – I just remember)
Oct 2017, Tanner, now GM of SSHA is contact person on "Managing the Flow of Refugees” report
Says top countries of origin of refugees in shelters are Nigeria, Eritrea, Ethiopia, & Columbia (i.e. racialized, esp. Black people) 3/ toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2…
RAPID FACT CHECK:
City Manager Chris Murray: The Saturday Debate: Should Toronto clear encampments?
He argued yes against @Fudbar and @djjohnso.
Murray's piece was mostly vague statements & light on facts. But, he made a lot of questionable claims. thestar.com/opinion/contri…
1. LIE: our collective effort to end homelessness
It is trying to end “chronic homelessness” by 2030. This means ending homelessness for folks who have been homeless for 6 months or longer by 2030.
1b They say “end homelessness” – along with groups like the Toronto Alliance to End Homelessness as part of a branding effort to convince people Housing First will work because Housing First is a neoliberal policy that requires no meaningful social change. toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2…
Rapid Fact Check
The City of Toronto put out this press release early this morning.
Not surprisingly, it is full of lies and misleading statements.
Here is a quick breakdown: toronto.ca/news/city-of-t…
LIE: “In 2020, Toronto Fire Services responded to 253 fires in encampments.”
It was “fire events” which include false alarms and pre-fire conditions. factchecktoronto.ca/2021/06/07/enc…
Misleading/LIE: “As of June 21, there have been 114 fire incidents at encampments this year, including nine in the past week.” This includes false alarms. False alarms are the antithesis of “incidents.”