[🧵] Since #TransWomenAreConMen is trending, here's a relevant anecdote that I found while researching for a video.
In this court case from 2018, an applicant for a gender recognition certificate appealed against the panel's multiple decisions to reject their application.👇
The whole thing makes *VERY* informative and enraging reading, but here are some highlights.... /
/ The applicant, Jay, was a trans identifying male prisoner, divorced from his third marriage, who had been convicted of "obtaining explosives with *intent to endanger life*" 😬😬😬
"Who's life?" seems like a pertinent question? Sadly I don't have that info.... /
/ Dr James Barrett, the founding president of the British Association of Gender Identity Specialists, and current director of the adult Gender Identity Clinic at @TaviAndPort, had this to say about the likely veracity and sincerity of Jay's application 👇 /
/ The rest of the appeal is littered with scores of red flags of various kinds... nevertheless... *THIS APPEAL WAS GRANTED*, and Jay was issued with a full GRC in the female gender 🤦♂️
The "female" part of that equation may offend many of course, but in this case I'm more /
Long story short, he tried to blow someone up, appears to have misled if not lied on his GRC application, and now has legal protections going forward /
/ that will outright interfere with the admin side of attempts to look into his background, or at very least discourage people from doing so.
Shona Robinson: "I could point to the BBC poll conducted earlier this year, that showed support for this bill - particularly among women, actually - and *SUPPORT FOR REDUCING THE AGE TO 16*..."
Tonight during the #GRRBill debate, and prior to voting for the relevant amendments, @ShonaRobison told Holyrood that this BBC poll showed Scots *support* lowering the minimum age of applicants from 18 to 16 👇
Scottish parliament just voted 59 to 64 against an amendment that would have prevented registered sex offenders from being able to #SelfID under the proposed #GRRBill.
No democratic mandate whatsoever for any of this...
Shouts of *shame on all of you* from the gallery! 💪
"TherEs nO conNNecTioN beTweEn the TwaNs C0mUniTY aNd $eX oFfendErs!" we hear, over and over again, ignoring the anecdotes and evidence to the contrary, with varying degrees of credulity.
Why vote to make sure they can get a GRC then? WHY?
[🧵] Absolutely shameful #misogyny on clear display from Dr James Barrett. This man is as elite and respected as it is possible to be within the UK "gender medicine" establishment. @TaviAndPort
👆In a 2009 report, Barrett denigrated women prisoners who may object to the presence in their estate of a man convicted of killing his partner. This prisoner(AB) hid the corpse for 3 weeks.
5 days after release AB committed a violent attempted rape of a woman, which /
/ only stopped because of erectile dysfunction.
The parole board had 2 years prior identified risk factors of:
"anger and frustration..., thinking patterns and attitudes relating to violence and weapons, sex offending... and the risk to life and limb.." Para. 6. paraphrased
/
/
Nobody is being prevented from saying it.
No movement exists based around disbelieving it.
No university anywhere in the world has a "Water is dry" department.
Governments / policymakers etc don't appear to have taken any position on water's wetness or dryness.
/
/
Wish I could say the same about "trans".
You wanna see some consistency?
Get a "water is dry" law into the statue book.
Put it in schools curriculums.
Create a branch of academia founded around the precept "liquid is a social construct".
/
Wow. Serious questions for @MedicalBristol as to why one of your lecturers has given this presentation, riven with demonstrable falsehoods, vague notions asserted as fact and flat out activist propaganda. 🧵
Hartland went on to characterise the large number of as yet unseen questions that the presentation generated as transphobic and hateful, and posted an image of his own hand with visible nail indentations, claiming he´d had no choice but to do that to himself... to remain calm?
A clue as to why Hartland reacted this way to criticism lies in this 2020 paper about race within medical education and "white fragility" which was co-authored by Hartland and a 4th year student (Eva Larkai): bjgpopen.org/content/4/5/BJ…