FIRE would like to wish everyone a happy #Festivus. It’s been a crazy year for free speech. We’ve got a lot of problems with some of you, and you’re gonna hear about it! 🧵
Our airing of grievances starts with the 94 universities earning FIRE’s infamous “red light” rating for clearly and substantially restricting freedom of speech. /2
Especially you, @MinnStateEdu, for implementing a sweeping policy that helped cause an uptick in red light schools for the first time in 15 years. /3
We know it’s chilly in Minnesota, but that doesn’t mean you should chill speech. /4
Christmas is coming, but it’s a “Silent Night” on many campuses. /5
The First Amendment gives every American the right to air their grievances.
Thanks to FIRE, and a Festivus miracle, residents of Eastpointe, MI, have that right again. /6
The mayor thought it was okay to silence dissent, but after FIRE filed a federal lawsuit, the court signed an order reinstating every citizen’s right to criticize their elected officials. /7
And while we’re on the topic of censorship, why does the state of New York think it’s a good idea to penalize websites and apps that refuse to address online speech that someone, somewhere finds humiliating or vilifying? /13
@MIT’s faculty votes to adopt the “MIT Statement on Freedom of Expression and Academic Freedom”!
The statement – inspired by the gold standard for campus free speech, the Chicago Statement – broadly commits the institute to cultivating an environment that encourages freedom of expression. /2
It reads in part, “With a tradition of celebrating provocative thinking, controversial views, and nonconformity, MIT unequivocally endorses the principles of freedom of expression and academic freedom.” /3
1/ On Nov. 14, the Keller Independent School District board in Keller, Texas voted 4-2 to adopt a policy banning books in all public school libraries that reference 𝐠𝐞𝐧𝐝𝐞𝐫 𝐟𝐥𝐮𝐢𝐝𝐢𝐭𝐲.
Keller ISD’s new restrictions violate the First Amendment. 🧵
2/ Under @KellerISD’s new policy, books that merely discuss gender fluidity are banned, while books that depict “passionate” kissing, nudity, or sex scenes remain available. 🤔
This makes no sense.
3/ As one dissenting member pointed out, the school district — which earlier this year bumbled its way into pulling the Bible and Anne Frank’s diary from library shelves — has already adopted limits on books with sexual content.
It looks like @ClemsonUniv is doing the right thing by committing to free expression and making sure there’s adequate security for tomorrow’s Tigers for Life event with @KristanHawkins. But universities’ assurances that they will uphold free expression don’t always pan out. /1
Facing enormous pressure to cancel a controversial student-hosted comedy show, @Penn_State also defended free expression and said it had adequate security for the event. /2
Then, when a few of the hundreds of protesters became violent, the university canceled the event, and police failed to protect protesters’ own First Amendment rights. /3
With the recent rise in campus speaker shoutdowns (some violent), FIRE reminds public universities of their legal obligation to ensure events can go on. Students are already threatening and planning to disrupt expressive events at @UCBerkeley & @ClemsonUniv in the coming days. /1
At Berkeley, some students reportedly plan to play copyrighted Disney music as @MattWalshBlog interviews people on campus, in hopes the videos will be taken offline. /2
And students at Clemson reportedly threatened a pro-life student group for hosting an event with @StudentsforLife founder @KristanHawkins. They also hacked the group’s Eventbrite page and interfered with ticket sales. /3
1/ In 2020 the University of Tennessee, Knoxville announced it was creating “diversity action plans” as part of “a sustained push to advance diversity, equity, and inclusion.” The plans contained various objectives that threaten free speech and academic freedom. 👇
2/ Objectives included requirements that current or prospective faculty submit statements demonstrating commitment to #DEI, mandatory syllabus statements affirming DEI, DEI-based course assessments, and bias reporting systems.
3/ FIRE wrote UT Knoxville in September calling on it to eliminate the plans’ speech-restrictive components, or to at least ensure they are implemented in a manner that respects students’ and faculty members’ expressive rights.
FIRE is concerned by the recent spike in students disrupting campus events, including last night’s student-organized speaking engagement at @Cornell featuring conservative pundit @AnnCoulter. /1
Video shows students playing circus music and screaming at Coulter, with one student yelling, “We don’t want you to speak here. Your words are violence. They’re threats. You cannot be speaking here.” /2
We condemn those students’ actions.
Shouting down speakers and disrupting scheduled events is not free speech or peaceful protest — it’s an impermissible “heckler’s veto.” /3