1/25 Since it’s that time of the year, here’s some (maybe all) of the books I’ve read or listened to in 2022, roughly in chronological order 📚👇🏽
2/ Exact thinking in demented times, by Karl Sigmund. A fascinating, lyrical, vivid, and deeply researched history of the Vienna Circle. Takes a while, but repays handsomely. uk.bookshop.org/books/exact-th…
3/ Piranesi, by Susanna Clarke. How she conjures such a vivid and magical world with just words I have no idea. It is a world I did not want to leave. Read it, and then listen to Chiwetel Ejiofor read it to you. Wonderful. uk.bookshop.org/books/piranesi…
4/ When we cease to understand the world, by Benjamín Labatut. A unique mix of fiction and nonfiction, of big ideas, and of madness and creativity. A mind-expanding read. uk.bookshop.org/books/when-we-…
5/ Children of time, by Adrian Tchaikovsky. An acclaimed sci-fi novel involving terraformed planets, intelligent spiders, and an ambitious portrayal of the vastness of time and space. I found it hard to get into, but it stayed with me uk.bookshop.org/books/children…
6/ East west street, by Philippe Sands @philippesands. A prize-winning detective story, family history, and legal thriller, set in the Ukrainian city of Lviv. I recommend listening to @philippesands’ narration (with David Rintoul). Then try The Ratline. uk.bookshop.org/books/east-wes…
7/ In consciousness we trust, by Hakwan Lau @hakwanlau. Lau – a leading neuroscientist, colleague, and friend – explains his take on the neural basis of consciousness, & on consciousness science in general. Highly recommended (see also #Bewilderment, 22) uk.bookshop.org/books/in-consc…
8/ Bittersweet, by Susan Cain @susancain. The follow-up to her all-conquering #Quiet, Bittersweet is a beautiful exploration of this most mysterious and contradictory of emotions – and there’s even a soundtrack (Albionini’s Adagio in G minor💓) uk.bookshop.org/books/bittersw…
9/ Lincoln in the bardo, by George Saunders. One of the most creative novels I’ve ever read. Magical realism? Surrealism? Who knows – but it is moving, transporting, hilariously polyphonic, and deeply meaningful. The audiobook is a joy. uk.bookshop.org/books/lincoln-…
10/ The man from the future, by Ananyo Bhattacharya @ananyo. An insightful, informative portrait of the genius John Von Neumann – one of the greatest intellects of the 20th Century. It’s a riveting story too. Great stuff. uk.bookshop.org/books/the-man-…
11/ This is your mind on plants, by Michael Pollan @michaelpollan. The follow-up to #HowToChangeYourMind – with essays on opium, caffeine, & mescaline. I gave up coffee for much of 2022, so there was much to resonate with in this brilliant book uk.bookshop.org/books/this-is-…
12/ The ministry for the future, by Kim Stanley Robinson @ksrinfo. Transcends the genre of disaster fiction to deliver a clear-eyed view of the catastrophe of climate breakdown, and what we need to do to avert its worst consequences. Sobering. uk.bookshop.org/books/the-mini…
14/ Exponential, by Azeem Azhar @azeem. Things are changing increasingly rapidly, including the rate of change of things. @azeem – a leading technologist (and friend) – delivers a clear-eyed, compelling, and highly readable tour of where all this is headed uk.bookshop.org/books/exponent…
15/ The overstory, by Richard Powers. Hugely acclaimed and multi-prize-winning, Powers’ novel weaves together individual narratives into a portrait of nature, its precarity, and its importance. A book that invigorates, warns, and enriches. uk.bookshop.org/books/the-over…
16/ The ratline, by Philippe Sands @philippesands. Follow-up to East West Street (see 6) is equally brilliant, and again weaves together intimate family history with a rompingly good narrative, while exploring profound questions of morality and history. uk.bookshop.org/books/the-ratl…
17/ Entangled life, by Merlin Sheldrake. A runaway success, and I can see why. It’s a mesmerising journey through the world of fungi and their profound importance for all of life. And it really is beautifully written – a joy to read. uk.bookshop.org/books/entangle…
18/ Sentience, by Nicholas Humphrey @Humphren. Humphrey – a leading philosopher and psychologist – integrates personal history and science to present a distinctive view of consciousness and its evolution – with some surprising conclusions. Recommended. global.oup.com/academic/produ…
19/ And finally, by Henry Marsh @DrHenryMarsh. The latest from the irascible and deeply humane neurosurgeon and writer (of #DoNoHarm). And Finally is a meditation on life and its end, and is candid, insightful, and poetic. Spend time with it. uk.bookshop.org/books/and-fina…
20/ Planta sapiens, by Paco Calvo & Natalie Lawrence. Are plants conscious? Surely @Humprhen would say No (and so would I), but Calvo & Lawrence make a provocative case otherwise. Agree or not, you’ll not look at our leafy friends the same way again. uk.bookshop.org/books/planta-s…
21/ Stone blind, by Natalie Haynes @officialnhaynes. New from “the nation’s greatest muse” as @dradamrutherford correctly calls her (disclaimer – both are friends), this is a delightfully witty retelling of the legend of #Medusa. A wonderful listen: uk.bookshop.org/books/stone-bl…
22/ Bewilderment, by Richard Powers. As with The Overstory, a eulogy to the natural world. Surprisingly, a central device is ‘decoded neurofeedback’ – an innovative neuroscience method developed by @hakwanlau see 7) & others. Powerful stuff. (@Vincent_T_D) uk.bookshop.org/books/bewilder…
23/ How to think like a philosopher, by Julian Baggini @JulianBaggini. One to watch out for. He writes so well that perhaps his next book should be “How to write like Julian Baggini” but I doubt that even Baggini could teach that. Generously intelligent. press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book…
24/ That’s the wrap for this year. For some other book recommendations, check out my @five_books selection of my favourite books on the neuroscience of consciousness, in conversation with @philosophybitesfivebooks.com/best-books/neu…
25/ And that’s all! Thanks for reading, and thanks also to everyone who read #BeingYou this year. It just tipped over 1,000 ratings on #Amazon, which is great – if you’ve read and haven’t rated, I’d be super grateful if you’d consider doing so amazon.co.uk/Being-You-Scie…
+1/ late addition (damn my memory, sorry) - Two heads, by @cdfrith, @utafrith, Alex Frith, and Daniel Locke - a unique graphic novel & a delightful perspective on neuroscience, the mind, and the self, from four excellent heads uk.bookshop.org/books/two-head…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2/ I greatly admire the work, but I am concerned about the "exhibit sentience" in the title of the paper. True, sentience can be formally defined merely as 'responsiveness to sensory impressions' - but many people interpret it as a minimal form of consciousness or awareness
3/ There is *no reason* to suppose that @CorticalLabs#DishBrain experiences anything at all, and confusion over this issue is dangerous because the prospect of synthetic awareness in cultures/organoids is ethically highly problematic
Really enjoyed this opening panel on "AI, sentience, and hype" at #WSAI22@WorldSummitAI - many 🙏🏽 to my fellow panelists (& brilliant host @Kantrowitz), and I'm so sad I can't be there IRL ...
I talk more about the prospects and pitfalls of 'machine consciousness' in my book Being You - A New Science of Consciousness, elaborating on the distinction between consciousness and intelligence & much more anilseth.com/being-you/
2/ It's great to see the Physics prize recognise work in the fundamentals of quantum mechanics (QM) - in particular the fantastically creative & rigorous experimental work, stretching back decades, showing that the universe is not 'locally real'
3/ The experiments test, in various ways, the famous 'Bell inequalities' - formulated by the physicist John Bell (who sadly died in 1990, & so could not benefit from the prize). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stew…
2/ There's a near-dead-give-away quote right up top, from Lujan Comas: "For us, it’s important to demonstrate that death is only for the material body". Using 'demonstrate that' rather than 'investigate whether' speaks volumes
3/ I don't deny that NDEs are extremely meaningful for those that have them, but to take their content literally is to make a common confusion between 'how things seem' and 'how things are' - a confusion that bedevils all of perception, in one way or another
2/ It may seem to us that we experience the world ‘as it is’, but in fact we each inhabit a unique, personalised ‘inner universe’. Just as we all differ on the outside, we all differ on the inside too.
3/ Sometimes, these differences are very clear. Remember #TheDress? Half the world saw it as blue-and-black, while the other half saw it as white-and-gold. (It really was blue-and-black, honest).
1/ A little late to the #LaMDA party, but here's my 2p for what it's worth 🧵. Basically, I agree with @GaryMarcus (& the vast majority of the AI/neuro community) that there is no reason whatsoever to believe that #LaMDA is conscious garymarcus.substack.com/p/nonsense-on-…
2/ #LaMDA is a highly impressive 'word sequence model' (h/t @rogerkmoore) which can give the impression of intelligent understanding, but it is a mistake to take this (variable) impression as evidence for actual intelligent understanding.
3/ In this sense, #LaMDA is fully in the tradition of previous chatbots, such as Eugene Goostman (b. 2014), for which grandiose claims were also made (both @GaryMarcus & I wrote about Goostman before, & the same points apply) neurobanter.com/2014/06/09/the…