#RobodebtRC One of the early findings was that DHS made a decision that those who don’t respond to their initial Centrelink Debt notice, regardless of the reason, would be deemed as being
“Satisfied with the information”
& that the Debt was Accurate. 1/2
Former DHS Manager Scott Britton tried to excuse this as only being part of a “pilot”
Angus Scott KC not satisfied, forces him to concede it was used as part of their illegal #Robodebt program where they assumed anyone who doesn’t respond, accepts the illegal debt. 2/2
They did run a Pilot, but it went ahead & used in Robodebt.
Within that Pilot, Britton admits they pressed ahead with this method of assuming Debt was accurate, without even a ph call & that 58%, yes, 58% of those they sent letters in pilot, didn’t respond. They still went ahead
So they said let’s contact a bunch of customers as a pilot.
58% did not respond
100% of those (in the 58%) were assumed to agree the debt was real by not responding (even if didn’t receive it)
& then used that method in Robodebt.
Phone calls came after debt was assumed accurate
Concluding Britton’s evidence, he summed up what he thinks went wrong, by saying the “drivers” of the program were “Sound” but that
“It all happened very quickly”
& systems were not equipped to handle it “as expected”
Intentions for the Robodebt Scam were good, he says. 😒
Oh and he also couldn’t recall a damn thing, either. 🙄
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
#RobodebtRC The amount of times the same Q had to be asked of witness Kathryn Campbell was just extraordinary. Here is one an example, about her
“understanding of DSS advice”frustrating for the commission but they did not give up & extracted the answers they were seeking. [1/3]
#RobodebtRC Commissioner Holmes can’t hold back what appears to be sheer disgust at Campbell’s lack of understanding or attention for DSS advice relating to the drafting of a minute she engaged in for the minister to DSS. [2/3]
#RobodebtRC After finally drawing some sort of answer, Holmes passes the baton back to Greggery who finishes the job & obtains the concession he was seeking [3/3]
Alan Tudge & Christian Porter to face off with Commissioner Holmes on the 1st & 2nd February as #RoboDebtRC releases it’s next witness list.
Bring it on 🔥🔥🔥
Rachelle Miller also called to give evidence, day before Tudge.
She was the former media advisor at the time.
And the Commissioner has encouraged those who can share their stories, if possible, to do so, by 3 Feb. #RobodebtRC
#RobodebtRC Former Director in DHS Jason Ryman was put through the wringer by the commission. After conceding he knew debts would be created based on “speculation”, the commission digs in for some shocking concessions. [1/8]
#RoboDebtRC They ran a “soft launch” by sending 1000 recipients their initial letter, as a test. But it was never completed.
They also ran a Pilot, which Ryman concedes was “Not much of a Pilot”
🙄🙄 [2/8]
#RoboDebtRC More concessions, and revelations of a series of complaints from recipients after the soft launch, & tensions with Malisa Golightly. [3/8]
Angus Scott & Catherine Holmes’ persistence led to alarming concessions from witness Jason Ryman. One of the bigger ones was that he allowed the scheme to go ahead whilst knowing false debts would be created, even after running a Pilot that yielded horrible results. #RobodebtRC
Ran out of time for a video for the day but there is one coming (another big one), tomorrow should be set.
There is nothing to indicate anything happened by accident, despite their pleas the intentions were to “help” welfare recipients & “reduce” debt 🙄
Just a teaser of some of what will eventually be shown in detail, Holmes’ reaction at one point 😬 she walloped him.
#RobodebtRC Jason Ryman, a former Director of DHS who was nominated as Australian of the Year his crafty work in Robodebt, shocks Commissioner Holmes by conceding he was aware when he set up the system, that debts were being raised
“Based on speculation” 🤦♂️
Commissioner then leaves Ryman gasping for answers, fumbling, taking deep breaths & under the pump as Holmes didn’t hold back.
“What was your thinking?!”
Ryman’s nomination for the Australian of the Year award was highly controversial, when Angus Scott KC pressed Scott Britton (Ryman’s boss) on it, he conceded there was a panel of members who made the decision, which appears to have included Kathryn Campbell & Malisa Golightly.
Commissioner Catherine Holmes.
No one better to see through the bullshit. 👍 #RoboDebtRC
Gives best death stares 😂
FYI I’m still watching the hearing, where possible, and there will be more videos coming eventually surrounding Mr Flavel (he just keeps getting roasted)
But now for some family time, we’re having pizza tonight 😍🍕