For too long the people of #Pakistan believed that the Army was a force for good in the country. They believed the propaganda of the #ISPR that everything was the politicians' fault, which it partly is, but they conveniently misled people about the harm the Army has caused 1/n
to the country. For too long we believed that the Army can deliver, that it is the savior of last resort when politicians screw us over. The military elite sold us Askari-koolaid which the vast majority of us consumed without question. Finally, we know 2/n
that the emperor has been naked the entire time. In the name of national security we sacrificed our growth, development, and frankly our own future. But it isn't enough to parrot talking points against the Army. It is important to understand how the Army continues to be a 3/n
roadblock in our progress. I know many officers will read this and it will hurt them. To them I say: you are our brothers, our sons, our fathers. This isn't not about your personally but the role that your institution plays in inhibiting our country's progress. Many of 4/n
you aren't even aware of it because you believe what your organization teaches you. We love you and we don't want you to die for causes that can be resolved politically. Please read this with an open mind. Most of you have civilian families who are suffering today. 5/n
1. The Army is the protector of status quo: in fulfilling its role as an army, it ends up protecting the rotten system that exists today. These politicians, mullahs, and the rent-seeking business elite bank on the Army to protect the state as it exists at the cost of masses. 6/n
2. Defence spending: we have an over sized Army for the size of country we have. The entire point of having nukes is that we don't need a large standing army yet it persists. Large military = high spending. We spend more money on defence than on education or health. 7/n
3. Political disasters: From '71 to creating #MQM, #PMLN, #PTI, arming the mullahs, using the mullahs to blackmail political govts, becoming a rent-an-army for $$$ , cutting deals with corrupt politicians, interfering in foreign policy, the list goes on and on... 8/n
4. Economic interests: Running massive corporations in the name of welfare that destroy competition and create monopolies (fauji fertilizer, FWO), and enrich the officer class. Corp Commanders run DHAs and get extra plots for being CC Khi and Lahore. AG in GHQ runs DHA Isb 9/n
Massive corruption in acquisition of land for these DHAs where generals became billionaires overnight (LTGs Zarrar 'Zamin' and Imtiaz Hussain to name a couple). Similar hoarding of state resources that end up benefiting 600k Army vs 200M people. 10/n
Every dollar spent on defence is a dollar wasted because it's a dead investment. It doesn't give us any return. Every dollar spent on defence means a dollar less for education, healthcare, infrastructure, development projects etc. 11/n
5. Usurping rights of the people: every election is staged managed by the Army to bring a political elite that can be blackmailed into keeping the Army's economic interests secure. Not once have the people outvoted political leaders that they chose, 12/n
because every govt is sent packing unconstitutionally. The reason for the lack of working democracy isn't bad politicians, it's because the Army hasn't allowed the democratic process to work long enough for the bad politicians to be filtered out. 13/n
The good news is that the farce is finally over. The people have realized that we don't have an army of officers but an army of 'politicians in uniform', who will bend every rule in the book to protect their economic interests and prolong this rotten republic. 14/n
To my countrymen I say this: never has any political force given up space voluntarily. It has to be taken back, sometimes by force. 600k armed men vs 200M people. Kitni Vigo layen gaye yeh? Don't be afraid, fear is a state of mind that they have used to keep us down. No more.15/n
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
There are two types of officers in the Army right now. Those who joined before the tech revolution, and those who joined after. The former - boomer class - got inducted straight out of 12th grade and was pretty much cocooned behind cantonment walls.
Groomed by officers who experienced the '71 debacle, this boomer class inherited their paranoia, disdain of civilians, and a lack of understanding of the world outside cantonment walls. They don't trust anyone not in uniform, and believe everything is a conspiracy to
disintegrate the country. The most stubborn among them are those from Military College, and others who joined the Army from lower socio-economic groups. Mind you the majority of seats in Military College are reserved for sons of JCOs/NCOs/ORs hence they don't have the same
1. Ever wondered what happened in #Bangladesh ‘after’ #1971? I used to think about it a lot growing up. At the time it never occurred to me that it was our collective way of forgetting that 🇧🇩was ever part of our history. If you are a history buff like me, you'll enjoy this.
2. On #16Dec 1971, Sheikh Mujib was in custody in West Pakistan. He was released in Jan 1972 and arrived in Dhaka via London and New Delhi on 10 Jan 1972. Naturally, he received a hero’s welcome. The Bengalis called him Bangabandhu, Friend of Bengal.
3. He became the PM and was able to pass a new constitution within a year enshrining the principles of secularism and socialism in it. Unfortunately, running a country proved harder for him and his party, the Awami League (AL), than they had envisioned.
Why is it that we #Pakistanis become so beholden to mere mortals? Every hero we have had, has disappointed us, yet we keep repeating the same pattern over and over again, expecting different results. #Bhutto was once a messiah for West Pakistanis. They loved him so much 1/n
that in the 1970 elections Awami League didn't win a single seat in West #Pakistan. How did that love affair turn out? A broken country and despotic civilian dictator who runied all economic progress of the 60s, the affects of which we still suffer from. 2/n
Then there emerged an entire section of society which still thinks Zia was mard-e-momin. Smh. Next BB, then Nawaz. Bloodly hell still Nawaz! Then his daughter. FFS. Still can't blv how Iftikhar Ch became an overnight hero. Abdul Qadir Khan, nuclear weapons smuggler. 3/n
To help explain the two worlds that exist in #Pakistan (n hopefully explain the civil-mil divide), I want you to read the following two pages from Brig FB Ali's book: Prison Journey. Brig Ali wrote this letter to a friend after being deputed on martial law duties in the 1/n
late 1960s. The two Pakistans described in this letter are as real today as they were 50+ years ago. The #Pakistan that exists within cantoment walls guarantees peace, security, fairness, and dignified living. Inside these walls everyone ceases to be who they were before they 2/n
came in. Their new identity is the uniform that unites them and their families. It's 'all for one, and one for all'. However, outside the walls, it's another story. Even today it's a jungle where might is right. The lack of resources to share has divided those outside into 3/n
In the country I live in I can tag the Prime Minister, Chief of Defense Staff, or the intel service on twitter and say whatever I want without fear that I will become subject to monitoring or be detained illegally. Of course I cannot engage in hate speech or start 1/n
making threats of violence because that's illegal but other than that, I am pretty much free to say whatever I want. My indv opinion doesn't get under anyone's skin here. Who cares about some dude sitting in Waterloo tweeting about the govt anyway? 2/n
On the flip side the narrative in our country is so toxic that you cannot state your opinion online without people attacking you for what you have said, without actually listening to or offering counter agreements to your points. We are quick to accuse the other side of 3/n
Since a few days have passed and thing have "relatively" calmed down, I want to comment on the optics of bringing out APCs in #Lahore Cantt. You all have seen the images go viral on this platform, and some were rightly outraged. 1/n
However, this isn't the first time #PakistanArmy brought out APCs against protesting public. Many years ago, there was a dispute between farmers and the Army over some land in #Okara. That's when this image was shot. For me, personally, it became of the most defining images 2/n
of how the Army behaves in the country. My shock stemmed from the fact that my father commanded 40 AK, which is equipped with TOW mounted APCs for hunting enemy tanks. How could the Army bring out APCs - which are essentially troop carriers - mounted with machine 3/n