Gujarat High Court questions Surat Municipal Corporation for its "efficiency" since till Monday the civic body had sealed only 63 shops selling meat without proper licence and in unhygienic conditions. But today, the number has rose to 570 plus shops.
Bench has asked State to clarify if it has constituted District Slaughter House Committees to oversee if slaughtering of animals is being done as per law across Gujarat.
Meanwhile, Sr Adv Percy Kavina for some licenced shop owners urge the bench to make them a party to the PIL.
Kiwana: What is being argued that animals need to be slaughtered only in abattoir and not shops, is just too much sticking to the law. We need to have a pragmatic approach in this matter as there are only 3 slaughter houses in Gujarat.
Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul: We need some thinking out of the box. So many statutes have limitations, but the matters are not heard on time. If you have specialised Tribunals, these are but manned.
Former AG Mukul Rohatgi: This retired judge syndrome must end. Those in TDSAT or electricity matters would have never dealt with such matters in their life.
Justice Kaul: That is why by and large like in AFTs, where there is balance of judicial and military members, worked well
Counsel: Regional benches can help.
Justice Kaul: I would not mind sitting in Chennai.
A constitution bench of the Supreme Court will decide today if the challenge to WhatsApp's privacy policy needs to be heard right away or deferred in light of the new Personal Data Protection Bill to be introduced in Parliament soon.
Justice Roy: Today we have AG and SG - what you were saying is there is many a slip between the cup & the lip. Just because bill is proposed to be presented before the parliament.. it could go before a committee for deliberation..
#SupremeCourt hearing matter regarding reservations in promotions.
Sr Adv Indira Jaising: States may be directed to begin collecting data. Several SLPs pending before this court, Court may first decide on how Union is to collect data. Almost all States are currently before you.
Jaising: Union employees include Railways, Ministry of Defence. Deliberation of this Court will apply to employees across States.
Sr Adv Gopal Sankaranarayanan: Mr Jaising is not right in saying Union has to be heard first. Haryana orders were ordered to be so.
#SupremeCourt hearing PIL challenging political parties using names with religious connotations.
Sr Adv Gaurav Bhatia: Rejoinder may not be needed.
Bench asks Sr Adv and former AG KK Venugopal who he is appearing for: This is an application. Lots of other parties will be affected. Far reaching consequences. Lordships may consider, it should go before Constitution bench. Petitioner is himself on bail, he said businessman.
#SupremeCourt hearing plea by former Karnataka Chief Minister BS Yediyurappa against Karnataka HC order refusing to quash FIR under PC Act in connection with illegal land denotification case.
The Supreme Court is hearing a batch of petitions to devise a policy strategy for granting bail in cases where appeals of trial court convictions have been long pending.