@PRRIpoll & @BrookingsInst just released the findings from a new survey of over 6,000 Americans. This report helps us know who embraces Christian nationalism, and what those folks believe. #ChristianNationalism
For instance, around 29% of Americans are at least sympathetic to Christian nationalism. @PRRIpoll labels these folks "Adherents" and "Sympathizers".
They asked 5 different questions and created a Christian nationalism scale. This is similar to what we did in Taking America Back for God.
Glad to see a continuation of what questions are asked which help us further specify what Americans really believe and desire.
As expected, a majority of White evangelical Protestants are at least sympathetic to #ChristianNationalism (64%).
An important continuation of past findings, though, is that sympathy for CN is not solely located w/in this group.
Another interesting finding: Christian nationalism adherents and sympathizers are much more likely to "prefer the US be a nation primarily made up of Christians."
Christianity as a key marker of national identity, and who is a true American.
Be sure to check out the report--it also shows how Christian nationalism is intertwined with anti-black racism, anti-immigrant views, anti-Semitism, anti-Muslim views, and gender views.
Like below: strong association w/ "replacement theory"--immigrants replace "our culture"
One finding that should worry us all--Christian nationalism again strongly linked to embracing QAnon.
QAnon believers (see the ?s @PRRIpoll asked) are much more likely to be CN adherents and sympathizers.
Again, check out the full report. Lots of interesting findings that will help us further understand what Christian nationalism means for our nation going forward.
Real talk: sometimes (as a Christian) I've found it poses less risk to converse with atheist or agnostic friends when experiencing deep pain or suffering than it is with some fellow Christians.
Why?
1) I've found there's less of a chance of being bright-sided.
What's bright-sided?
It's the "often toxically positive and well-meaning attempt to offer comfort, it's the phenomena where someone insists that, no matter your situation, you look for some kind of positive."
I've come to see this propensity to "bright side" as likely due to American Christianity being marked by a kind of triumphalism, of always “winning.”
White Christian nationalism (WCN) is a cultural framework that idealizes and advocates for a fusion of Christianity* with American civic life. It combines a number of different elements.
The first is a strong sense of moral traditionalism based on creating and sustaining social hierarchies.
Oftentimes these revolve around race/ethnicity, gender, and sexuality.
The second element is a comfort with authoritarian social control. The world is a chaotic place and sometimes needs strong rules and rulers to make use of violence, or at least the threat of violence, to maintain order.
Some thoughts regarding the ridiculous @CBMWorg hit piece on @bethallisonbarr, @kkdumez, & Beth's rural Baptist congregation, via Life of Pi:
"There are always those who take it upon themselves to defend God, as if Ultimate Reality, as if the sustaining frame of existence,
were something weak and helpless. These people walk by a widow deformed by leprosy begging for a few paise, walk by children dressed in rags living in the street, and they think, 'Business as usual.' But if they perceive a slight against God, it is a different story.
Their faces go red, their chests heave mightily, they sputter angry words. The degree of their indignation is astonishing. Their resolve is frightening. These people fail to realize that it is on the inside that God must be defended, not on the outside.
Now, Pew doesn’t call it Christian nationalism, which I understand given various constraints, but that is definitely what they’re measuring.
Pew sorts respondents into several different groups:
Strong church-state separationists, moderate CS separationists, Mixed, CS integrationists, and no opinion. Check out their methodology or later in this thread for more.